Fourstar Pizza & Fresh-Baked Subs
1506 Old Butler Rd, New Castle
(724) 656-9222
Customers' Favorites
Meatball Stromboli
Pepperoni & Cheese
Deluxe Stromboli
Chicken Parm Sub
Steak Stromboli
Steak & Cheese
Cheese Pizza
Bread Sticks
Deluxe Pizza
Chicken SM
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The service you get at Four star pizza is amazing!! We were passing through for the night and decided to get pizza for dinner, and tried this restaurant! We told them it was our first time and the staff was amazing and told us the specials and what was good! We ordered and went to our car to wait for our order to be done...... they even brought it out to us in the parking lot!! That is amazing customer service right there!!!!
4 star? Should be 5, what was initially an elevated experience turned into 5 star white glove service. We've been looking for a solid pizza place around these parts of New Castle for awhile. The one biggest down side is not offering wings. This place does. Thankfully the owner accommodated that for us within the last 10 mins of being open. Just bit into the pizza and wings and man it's definitely a great time. Thank you 4 star. I mean... 5 star. We'll be back again...
I’ve always had good experiences, never had any problems with orders or food. I wish the pizza was a lil more hotter for todays order but it was still warm when picked up 20 mins after ordering. Paid $19.06 for 1 large and 1 medium pizza. Under $20 bucks is not bad for 2 pizzas anymore. Medium was cheese and large was pepperoni and cheese. I wish there was more cheese or that it would be gooier. Bread taste fresh and fluffy, but not enough cheese that wasn’t stretchy as preferred....
You May Also Like
Kelly's Side Door Tavern - 1403 Old Butler Rd
![]()
Bar & Grill, Irish Pub, Seafood
Subway - 1200 Butler Ave
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Jimmy's - 1829 E Washington St
![]()
American, New American, Vegetarian