Mary's Restaurant & Bakery
131 E Long Ave, New Castle
(724) 652-2447
Customers' Favorites
Grape Leaves and Tabbouleh
Chicken Fatoush Salad
Small Grape Leaves
Combination Plate
Falafel Sandwich
Stuffed Zucchini
Chicken and Rice
Lamb on the Rod
Stuffed Cabbage
Lamb over Rice
Menu
Photos
+37 photos
+36 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Get takeout from here 3 times a week and it's always on point and delicious. They are closed Sundays and was craving tried from somewhere else local and it was not good. Couldn't even compare at all to marys. 5 stars all the way around!
I have eaten at Mary's for years and it has always been exceptional. However, today was disappointing. The stuffed grapeleaves tasted like nothing, were under filled and mushy. The lamb had absolutely no grill marks. I did order grilled lamb. The kibbee was over fried and the baklava was stale. 53 dollars for one person is too price to be this laxadasical about their food.
I didn't like the raw kibbee at all. It was extremely mushy and not very flavorful. And the hummus and garlic sauce wasn't that good either. I did really enjoy the fried kibbee though.
You May Also Like
Patsy's Bar & Grill New Castle Pa - 207 E Long Ave
![]()
Bar & Grill, Bar, American, Pizza
Faraone Brothers Catering - 1015 S Mill St
![]()
Caterers, Pizza