Mr Pizza
1204 E Washington St, New Castle
(724) 658-6603
Customers' Favorites
Double Slice of Pepperoni Pizza
Wedding Soup and Pizza Greens
Chicken Pastine with Egg Soup
Tues 2 Slices of Pizza
Meatball with Cheese
Fresh Tomato Pizza
Pepperoni & Cheese
Pizza by the Slice
Meat Lovers Pizza
Anti Pasta Salad
Menu
Photos
+13 photos
+12 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Ask for banana peppers and got hot yellow peppers, greasy pizza, topping fell off. Couldn't cut with knife and fork,
When I was asked is everything okay I said no but he just walked away. Would not go back. Staff was just standing around. Would not recommend. Dinning room was clean
When I was asked is everything okay I said no but he just walked away. Would not go back. Staff was just standing around. Would not recommend. Dinning room was clean
I used to love coming here but the staff isn't very friendly compared to the people that worked here prior to the current crew. The food is great and affordable but the staff is never pleasant to deal with and aren't quick to fix mistakes. The staff seems annoyed when you ask for anything or if they have to deal with you at all. Management also wasn't super helpful when issues were present.
You May Also Like
Riardo's Bar & Grill - 1223 E Washington St
![]()
Bar & Grill
Starwood Restaurant - 1115 Butler Ave
![]()
Steak House, Pubs, American
All I ever get at Mr. Pizza is, the pizza. That's because they have the hands down best sauce in the area. I'm from Youngstown area, so like a chewy crust with a good sauce with some flavor.
Mr. Pizza doesn't have a thick crust round, but I get the anchovy (this picture...