Papa Gelateria
318 Highland Ave, New Castle
(724) 576-9133
Customers' Favorites
Gelato Bowl
Menu
Photos
+25 photos
+24 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Nestled in and around a grove of tall oak trees sits this little Gelato haven. After ordering the creamiest dessert I've probably ever had, we sat on their deck overlooking New Castle in the shade of these oak giants. I felt at peace just being there.
We love this little treat-stop here in New Castle. They have about 8 to 10 flavors each week, some which change. I always sample before I pick and the staff is friendly. Sometimes the place is packed with customers, and other times we're the only ones. If you like coffee, try their Afrigatto...espresso over a couple scoops of gelato. So good!
This place is super cute and has amazing Gelato! Friendly shop staff and tucked away from the main street. The outdoor deck is lovely. I want to go every day. Also had a latte which was tasty. Mango, blood orange, chocolate, pistachio and black cherry I've tried so far. All were delicious!
You May Also Like
Dunkin' - 134 N Mill St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Coffee
Speedy Café - 208 N Jefferson St
![]()
Coffee & Tea
Hazel's Restaurant - 119 N Mercer St
![]()
American