50 Best Italian Restaurants near New Cumberland

“good stuff, highly recommend!“

“This is my go to delivery place in New Cumberland. Best pizza in Cumberland county as far as im concerned. They deliver and they are usually early and very pleasant to interact with. A+++ �“

“Wanted a place to go with friends before a movie at the theater nearby…stumbled onto Fratelli’s…so glad that we did. Food was fresh and delicious. Homemade dough for the pizza and Stromboli. Apps were awesome…we had the pretzels and the cheesesteak egg rolls. My friend had wings and said they were good as well. Everything was reasonably priced and the service was impeccable. Definitely recommend that you check it out. They have Italian entrees and a dining room as well (that I believe is open on the weekends) and I can only imagine that the entrees would be just as good. We are certainly planning on checking out this little diamond in the rough again.“

“Delectable authentic tasting Italian food. It's as delicious as eating in Italy!“

“Love this place!! When I go to visit my daughters this is such a treat I love to take her and her boyfriend here for dinner. Mario is the waiter you want he is phenomenal he’s been there 21 years and the service he gives is impeccable. The food is amazing every course is amazing. We always get oysters Rockefeller and lollipop lamb chops as our first course you won’t be disappointed! Any other veal entrées are amazing! Cocktails top shelf! We’ve been there many times and we’ve never been disappointed don’t miss out on this treasure!!“

“Came down for the Carlisle car show and ordered out. It was excellent food, fast delivery and very friendly! Going back tonight for more!!“

“Chef Qui Musarra is one of the finest chefs in central PA. There isn't a dish I wouldn't recommend, but if I had to give recognition to one dish I would tell you that "Il Toscano" (the Tuscan Rib-eye) should be on your must have list. When available, the Chuleta and Percebes are also on that list. Mangia!“

“This is a very convenient restaurant/bar just off of Cameron Street. I got the meat lovers pizza, and it was perfectly sized for one person. The sausage crumbles, meatball slices, and pepperoni were very proportional and tasty. The sauce had a nice fresh tomato flavor to it, and the thin crust was chewy and crispy. This is a pizza that will appeal to everyone. Our server was a delight with a great combination of playfulness and competency. Also, they have a very nice parking lot.“

“made a visit here back in the fall 2024 a couple times. the owner and his crew are extremely friendly and the service is amazing. the meals made from scratch and with care, including the desserts. found this place out of curiosity one day and is now a favorite. if you need a nice. quiet friendly place to dine in at, come check out romas. Definitely going back“

“Had reservations for 11 plus a baby on 8-2-25. Staff, food, and service were exceptional! Our group was treated first class from beginning to end. Thanks to everyone for making a family gathering special!!“

“Great food, excellent, friendly service. Wonderful atmosphere.“

“We were traveling from PA back home to VA, and we love Carrabba’s but they closed the one near us in Richmond/Short Pump, VA We have never had service at this level before. Our server Billy (William) was beyond exceptional! We were having a bad night and he read his table we’ll and exceeded expectations. He absolutely made our night. Thank you so much, we will be back!!!“

“After a long day today of flights, I saw this shining restaurant on the way to my Hotel. They had pizza ready to go and added a few knots and when I ate this my mouth was watering. I could never get sauce like this in Ohio. The food was absolutely Amazing. I was watching them making pizza crust from fresh dough. Never get that back home. This was such a nice Family and Thank You for the Amazing food. I will stop in next time I fly back up.“

“The food was delicious! I would buy there again!“

“The food is delicious and reasonably priced! The service is really quick for food that they make to order. My family and I are thankful that the food cart visited our neighborhood tonight :)“

“I was there for a birthday dinner and it exceeded my expectations. It had a nice cozy atmosphere.. We were served ice water in four carafes for our table of ten. The server was very nice and helpful with the menu. My order of nonna's meatballs (size of tennis balls) and spaghetti was delicious. They had live jazz music. Definitely recommend.“

“I've been coming here since they first opened which was years ago! This pizza place never let's me down, has a great variety of food and a great atmosphere.“

“Always good! Very Friendly service!“

“been going here since I was a kid...always brings back the best memories...excellent cold cuts.“

“Everything is always delicious!“

“We go to eat breakfast at Tito’s almost every Saturday morning. The service is good and the food is always hot and delicious. The owner is very cordial and always makes you feel welcome.“

“Very good pizza. Tastes very fresh and juicy. Great atmosphere. People who work there are very kind. BIG portions. Thanks again for great food.“

“Had a wonderful dinner at Vito’s tonight. Husband and I each had a cheese Steak. Delicious. The home made bun was soft and spectacular! The Cheese Steaks were HUGE. We took home enough for at least a second meal. Husband had cheese fries with his Cheese Steak. Hey were hot, cheesy and all kinds of wonderful. I went with the fried mushroom appetizer. Super delish! Served hot and crunchy, perfect for dipping in the provided ranch dressing. Our waitress, Bethany was wonderful. Perky and personable, she made great recommendations AND made dinner very enjoyable. PS. The desserts looked so tempting that we took one home!“

“Had the cheese ravioli today. Was delicious. We love this place. Have never had a bad meal. Everything always fresh and delicious. The owner is great. Always so friendly.“

“Friendly staff, delicious food! Their pink sauce is hands down the best in the area!“

“I am new to the area and this made me feel at home but even better!! I order about every week. Fresh and very hot. Family restaurant and made me feel very welcomed!! I brought my family from back home here for dinner, they enjoy this just as much!! I need to try a few more things on the menu so I can brag more!!“

“Arguably the best pizza in the hbg / Hershey area . 3.50 for a slice is a steep though but I’d rather pay that than 3 bucks for garbage. I’m just thinking it shouldn’t be what they charge back east where rent is mucb more expensive . Either way it’s much better than most of their comp“

“I want to take this time out to give u all a high ? . All stars, U all r amazing ppl thanks again for letting me take pictures of my granddaughters in your lounge for homecoming 2024 mechanicsburg pa. The pictures turned out amazing. U all made their memories and mine to. U r a blessing keep up the awesome work ?“

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****“

“I live over 2.5 hours away from this restaurant. I make it maybe once or twice a year to my favorite restaurant. I love having the build your own pasta. I started cancer treatment earlier this year and my wife gave me an incentive to get through it by telling me she would take me to Macaroni Grill after I completed the treatments. Today was the day. I am sorry, her name escapes me right now, but our waitress went way above and beyond for us. She got me a slice of key lime pie and had congratulations written on the plate. I am not going to lie, I got emotional. The food was awesome as usual. The 5 hour round trip was more than worth it. My waitress should be employee of the year.“

“Lovely people. Great wings and pizza. Felt like family. 🤓“

“What a great find during a recent weekend in Harrisburg. Our server, Maria, was outstanding - knowledgeable, very friendly, and fun. Other staff members were also very accommodating and gracious. I particularly enjoyed the whipped ricotta app and arugula and beet salad. Highly recommend!“

“Our party of 6 was so warmly greeted and our server was simply amazing! She was so responsive to our questions and needs. We were never left thirty or hungry. And the food came out so fast for how busy they were. It was abundant and delicious! Very clean too. This restaurant is awesome and I’d drive an hour again to return. Bravo team! 5 stars all around.

Vegetarian options: Plenty of pasta, salad and dessert options where meat can be excluded.

Dietary restrictions: Our family has all kinds of food allergies and the restaurant was able to accommodate our needs.

Parking: Massive parking at ground level in a huge shopping center. I can’t imagine them ever not having enough parking.

Kid-friendliness: Oh yes kids were at nearly every table! It’s such a great environment for them.

Wheelchair accessibility: All tables and even the bar has space for wheelchairs. The restaurant is on one level.“

“Best pizza in town“

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****“

“Went in for a slide and got the meat lovers thick crust. Large piece for $3.98 with tax. While waiting I was shocked to see the very large menu of subs, cold and hot, salads and Strombolis. Casual setting if you dine in with great 80s music and sever was great. I was feeling like I walked into a joint in NYC the minute I opened the door and when I saw the sever wearing a NY cap, I figured I was right on with a smile on my face.“

“We have been coming to Jigsys for years and it never disappoints. Yesterday we had the opportunity to have a family event in their awesome lounge area with catering provided for 20 people. Boy what a treat! We were provided a spread including a variety of their specialty pizzas, wings, stromboli and an enormous antipasto…all of it amazing! Everyone went home happy and full that’s for sure. The staff were also fantastic and super attentive throughout the afternoon making the party just an overall perfect experience.

If you are looking for a place to host an event with amazing food, friendly service and a great atmosphere, this is the place.

Awesome place!“

“great food, always hot and fresh. service is great. staff is friendly.“

“First time getting pizza from them and it was AMAZING! Definitely reminds me of the Italian pizzeria back home! My kids absolutely loved it too, we definitely will be back again, and again! It's hard finding a good pizza spot that has deals on 2 large pizzas.“

“Pizza was delicious and their subs are huge and filling. Best cannoli I’ve ever had!“

“Excellent food. I always order more than I am going to eat a one meal. Their food is so fresh my son and I can eat salad n taco pizza , then have carnival fries for a snack, next day we have canzone in the air fryer Robertos is the best and not yucky or fall apart when we heat it up ... love love love it ! Always polite even when they are swamped, and if you are patient, they even carry it out to my car for me. I AM A VERY HAPPY CUSTOMER BEEN A CUSTOMER FOR OVER 20 YEARS !“

“Ordered 2 Italian baked dinners. Excellent flavor, big portions plus a great salad and breadsticks. Frank and his crew always prepare the best!“

“the Italian subs you make are the best in Cumberland county! Thank you for having delivery service.“

“Ordered on one of the busiest nights of the week. HALLOWEEN! Food still came out hot a fresh. Worth the wait! I hope you all get to enjoy a nice cold beverage after work.“

“Awesome private club great food cheap drinks , pull tabs and game of chance not hard to get a membership card as long as your a decent human being. Fyi the smoke is not that bad smoke eaters n fans in place. You have hundreds of places non smoking dont like it dont join your loss“

“I just moved to North Steelton area and when I first moved in I decided to order pizza. So, I Googled pizza shops that deliver by me. This was about 9pm and there was a shop 2 blocks away and said they closed early, so I looked at Google again and found a few that were still open and deliver. I checked them all out and Pizza Delight was rated highest so I placed my order on the Slice App. Pizza Delight has now become my favorite pizza shop in the Harrisburg area! I've ordered different pizzas, subs, and sides and have yet to get something that I didn't like! I've been here 3 weeks now and have made one order every week so far. I don't know who to thank at Pizza Delight, but I want to give you a shout out for making good food and delivering to my N Steelton home!“

“I had a really enjoyable experience today! The service was fantastic – friendly and attentive. We were seated quickly with barely any wait time, which was a pleasant surprise
.
The food was exactly what you would expect from Olive Garden. Everything was fresh and flavorful, and the portions were generous. Good breadsticks and the salad was fresh.

Overall, it was a solid meal and a great choice for a casual and satisfying dining experience. If you're looking for a reliable spot with good food and efficient service, this will do.“

“Coccio Fríes. With some Steak Rolls. Delicious. Gracias al buen servicio. Ambiente cómodo.“

“Lol, when Adelyn says she wants to make a trip to Giant. She is actually saying I want pizza from Tonino’s. Yesterday we tried pizza di Tonino. I’m thinking this is a new favorite. Always well worth the travel and time.“