48 Best Italian Restaurants near Middletown

“Enjoyed Mother’s Day Tea with my daughters and granddaughter on Saturday. It was wonderful! The food was delicious! The decor was beautiful! Our server was attentive, polite, and very personable! What a delightful afternoon!“

“I was just there to catch up with old friends and had the veal Parmesan sub. It was delicious, big, decently priced, good sauce, perfect balance of soft/chewy/firm bun. Very friendly staff, pleasant, quiet atmosphere, and very clean.“

“Best shop in town!!! Our family go to!!!“

“Love this place!! When I go to visit my daughters this is such a treat I love to take her and her boyfriend here for dinner. Mario is the waiter you want he is phenomenal he’s been there 21 years and the service he gives is impeccable. The food is amazing every course is amazing. We always get oysters Rockefeller and lollipop lamb chops as our first course you won’t be disappointed! Any other veal entrées are amazing! Cocktails top shelf! We’ve been there many times and we’ve never been disappointed don’t miss out on this treasure!!“

“Used to work here and I couldn't recommend Little Italy more, both as a customer and as an employee! It's a very warm and inviting place, with the owners often greeting you personally and welcoming you in. Fran and Enzo make you feel like family. Great food, great service, and a wonderful family oriented atmosphere.“

“Had reservations for 11 plus a baby on 8-2-25. Staff, food, and service were exceptional! Our group was treated first class from beginning to end. Thanks to everyone for making a family gathering special!!“

“My experience here has always been great, the food has been consistently good and I have never had a bad meal. During our most recent visit, my husband and I. we're taken back to what appeared to be management decision. While we were eating, we overheard management approach a booth with two women, a man and a child say that that table had a reservation and the party has arrived, So they will need to finish. Up. Although the family was clearly close to leaving, the young child was still drinking his soda and seemed disappointed that he needed to leave it behind. The situation seemed very uncomfortable and unnecessary, since they appear to be wrapping up on their own.. The was very disappointing to hear, considering that there should have been some kind of an overflow for this type of situation. Sincerely Disappointed !!“

“The food was delicious! I would buy there again!“

“One of the best restaurants in the area! Such good quality & always so tasty.“

“We love coming here. The food is always delicious. And it’s fun being able to bring our own wine! They always give us ice and open it for us. They are very flexible with switching out sauces as well. The free bread is fantastic too.“

“Food was delicious and made our stay in the area so much better having a wonderful dinner with my fiancé“

“I've been coming here since they first opened which was years ago! This pizza place never let's me down, has a great variety of food and a great atmosphere.“

“We go to eat breakfast at Tito’s almost every Saturday morning. The service is good and the food is always hot and delicious. The owner is very cordial and always makes you feel welcome.“

“You walk in this place and look behind the counter and you just know that you're about to have the best pizza you've ever had. That kitchen is organized chaos lol. Bartolo's Special sicilian is my go-to here. I wish they had some version of online ordering/delivery, but the quality of the food makes up for it. Best place around to get a pizza!“

“Great thin crust pizza, with good cheese and fresh toppings. We will definitely be back!“

“Wow! The pizza was fantastic along with the cannolis. This is the best pizza I had in a long time. The toppings were plentiful and flavorful. The crust was light and chewy. Delivery was fast and courteous. The next time I come up to PA we’re going to order again from Palmero’s. This place is a gem!“

“Always good! Very Friendly service!“

“Thursday September 17th my husband and I what's heading to Hershey from Derry Street we passed two pizza places when we realize he needed something in his stomach to take his medicine the third pizza place which is Italian Pizza and subs... I went in and ordered two slices of pepperoni we ate the crust we got home later on that day we decided to order a whole pepperoni pizza it was so good this morning it's Friday we just ordered another pepperoni large does pizza is so good .. highly recommended“

“I am new to the area and this made me feel at home but even better!! I order about every week. Fresh and very hot. Family restaurant and made me feel very welcomed!! I brought my family from back home here for dinner, they enjoy this just as much!! I need to try a few more things on the menu so I can brag more!!“

“Pizza is excellent. I’m an Italian and pizza sauce is unbelievable. If I had any complaints, it would be having a dog in the restaurant. Which is unsanitary I believe no animal should be allowed around when you’re eating food. Other than that great food“

“The hotel manager at Hampton Inn recommended "What IF" for dinner. He was spot on. Excellent service and our table just off the end of the bar provided a quiet place to enjoy an excellent meal.“

“guyssss, that cheesesteak pizza you made tonight is AMAZING!! You're always our go-to, and I'm so happy we can support each other's small businesses!! 🤌“

“We have been in a few times recently as we were working in the neighborhood. Great food, friendly staff, quick service! Today we shared an old world pizza, delicious!“

“Its been awhile since going there. I got lasagna with Shrimp Sausage and meat sauce. Was not sure how that would be. It was great. Staff was great. Was packed when I was there.“

“I love pizza and I have never been a big Sicilian pizza fan but their plain Sicilian is hands down the best pizza I have ever had. Not just Sicilian, the best pizza in general. Not to mention how amazingly friendly the staff is. I could not recommend this pizza more! It truly is amazing“

“They have delicious pizza, and so happy they make a white pizza! If you order 2 medium or 2 large pizzas on Thursday, Friday, or Saturday, you get a free 2-liter.
They also have delicious stromboli, calzones, and subs. Eat here! Just eat here!“

“🍕Babbo's Pizza in my opinion has the best 🍕👌 in Elizabethtown!! We have tried many different pizza restaurants in Elizabethtown, and BABBO'S PIZZA always comes in 1st place! I am one that I always place a telephone order ahead of time and drive through to the pick up window. So due to that I'm not really sure how the atmosphere is inside the restaurant. I'm pretty sure that they have a huge TV for the sports fans out there. They do have a self serve of beer for sure, I'm not sure what all drinks they sell there. They also have quite a variety of food on their menu. We like to get cheesesteaks🥖, French🍟fries, and their burgers 🍔are delicious as well. The employees at the pickup window have always been very pleasant and friendly. Next time you are hungry for some pizza, give BABBO'S PIZZA 🍕 a try! I highly recommend them. 👌“

“Awesome private club great food cheap drinks , pull tabs and game of chance not hard to get a membership card as long as your a decent human being. Fyi the smoke is not that bad smoke eaters n fans in place. You have hundreds of places non smoking dont like it dont join your loss“

“good stuff, highly recommend!“

“I just moved to North Steelton area and when I first moved in I decided to order pizza. So, I Googled pizza shops that deliver by me. This was about 9pm and there was a shop 2 blocks away and said they closed early, so I looked at Google again and found a few that were still open and deliver. I checked them all out and Pizza Delight was rated highest so I placed my order on the Slice App. Pizza Delight has now become my favorite pizza shop in the Harrisburg area! I've ordered different pizzas, subs, and sides and have yet to get something that I didn't like! I've been here 3 weeks now and have made one order every week so far. I don't know who to thank at Pizza Delight, but I want to give you a shout out for making good food and delivering to my N Steelton home!“

“Delicious food and friendly people! A must try if you're in the area“

“I don’t ever go out of my way to do reviews… however I ordered pizza today for a work event and The first pizza shop cancelled my order after I waited an hour. I called Ninos and they had 4 delicious pizzas whipped up and delivered within a half hour!! So thankful for that!!!“

“We tried this place for the first time for my friend’s defense and it was delicious! I ordered the hangar steak and it was perfectly cooked to medium rare. The cocktails and desserts were also good. We sat in the indoor dining room but they also have a really nice outdoor patio!“

“Coccio Fríes. With some Steak Rolls. Delicious. Gracias al buen servicio. Ambiente cómodo.“

“My family and I stayed at the Hilton right next door this week. This lodge is very conveniently located and has a wide array of food. I wasn’t feeling well so my husband ordered a soup for me, which was ready and packed by the time he got there. Very friendly staff and clean environment.“

“this place makes really good food I love it with the first time the hospitality was great for me and my wife we enjoyed ourselves I give a five stores and more“

“I’ve lived in New Cumberland for 4 years and only learned about Fratelli’s a few days ago so my wife and I decided to go for the first time. I immediately loved the vide as soon as we walked in. Sunday night football so the bar was a little rowdy but that’s to be expected. Unfortunately we didn’t catch the servers name but she couldn’t have been nicer. She was very welcoming and engaging. She seemed proud to work for such a cozy little place. I got grandmas gravy and my wife got pizza. We were very pleased with our meal. The food is homemade and delicious! Highly recommend and will definitely be going back!“

“Love the pizza and subs. Atmosphere is great. I was reading the reviews and someone actually complained about a $14 large pizza. I guess they don't travel much because in most places, they are $17+. Family owned. And I'll say this, to anyone complaining about prices, I also own a resturant and you can blame Biden and his staff for the price increases on food. Keep it up usa and I.“

“I love the pizza I love the dessert it reminded me a lot of CiCi's pizza so I will be back again when I come back around this area cuz I'm from 5 hours away“

“This place is really delicious as far as a chain restaurant goes. Everything was cooked perfectly and tasted really wonderful. I highly recommend the cheese sticks, they are outrageously good! If you haven't been to an Olive Garden in a while you've got to go back to this location - it's really good!“

“I know I’m late to the party here but if you’ve only been a pizza shop customer you’re missing the boat. We had a fantastic sit down meal last night. Great drinks, appetizers, entrees, and service. We will definitely be back for dinner more often.“

“You guys out did yourselves on the cheesesteak sub I ordered today! It was amazing! Keep up the good work!“

“Just had literally the best cheese steak - South Philly Cheese steak!! and I have tried many cheese steaks in my years“

“I am not happy with the attitude I got from one of the employees . of that employee was having a bad day there was no need to take it out on the customer. I will take my busy some where else.“

“The Funnel Cake fries ! 😋❤“

“I tried their pizza for the first time. It was very good! Please don’t change your red sauce. As in adding grape jelly like a lot of local pizzerias do. I would love if you make a thin crust.“

“Had an amazing first experience here. All of the employees were so friendly and treat each other and customers like family. Our cashier, Barbie, was particularly sweet and kind. We got takeout subs - meatball, and roast beef. Both were so tasty and fresh! I loved the bread. My daughter, who is picky about meatball subs, said hers was absolutely delicious. The restaurant was clean and well-organized. Our subs were made lightning fast and were huge. We will definitely be returning!!“

“Pizza boil food is always good Hot and fresh The staff is very friendly“