50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Middletown

“I was just there to catch up with old friends and had the veal Parmesan sub. It was delicious, big, decently priced, good sauce, perfect balance of soft/chewy/firm bun. Very friendly staff, pleasant, quiet atmosphere, and very clean.“

“Best shop in town!!! Our family go to!!!“

“I've been eating here for about 4 years now. I'm a pretty regular customer. Food is always fresh and taste amazing. I've tried almost everything they offer and all of it is great. prices are on point as well. make sure you get a pizza because they do it right!“

“Everything was fresh and delicious! I ordered pancakes and a smoothie and it was the best pancakes I’ve ever had! I had to come back everyday for pancakes while I was in PA. My husband ordered a cheeseburger one day and a philly cheesesteak the next and he also enjoyed his food. This place will not disappoint!“

“I have ordered from here at least twice a month for over a year now. The owner is a fantastic man who really keeps his word. They have the best pizza and Strombolis..“

“their pizzas are amazingly good. you can tell and once you take the first bite that it was freshly made👍“

“Bellia’s Pizza II is easily one of favorite spots to order food from!! Always giving out quality food & serving with a smile 🫶🏼 Daily special - your choice of sub, fries & a drink for $11.99 (we order on the slice app) Subs are always delicious and consistent every single time. We frequently buy the cheesesteaks and Italian subs, 10/10 🤤 Ventured out just recently and grabbed a salad from them & it’s so good!! I got a Caeser salad, added chicken and onion. & it’s incredible!! Absolutely worth the money 🫶🏼 & Honorable mention of my favorite pizza to get from them - the Big Mac pizza. Perfection with every bite. 🤤🤤 Thank you for the tasty food 🫶🏼🤤 we love ordering from your restaurant“

“Great thin crust pizza, with good cheese and fresh toppings. We will definitely be back!“

“Everything (handhelds, dinners or pizza) we have ever had was absolutely fantastic! This is our lunch/dinner stop anytime we pass through Harrisburg! It is worth venturing off the Linglestown exit. Eat in or take it to go....you will be glad you did!“

“I tried the buffalo chicken pizza and it tasted really good“

“Great pizza! And with a gluten intolerant child, them making their gluten free pizza in its own tin and sending a pizza cutter to lower cross contamination is greatly appreciated!“

“The best pizza shop in the area. The staff is so awesome and professional. I love the cheesecake subs with fried onions and grilled sweet peppers. Always delicious 😋 Love everything about the restaurant. TRY IT!!!! Won't be disappointed.“

“David's pizza is by far the most amazing pizza restaurant I have ever ate at in my whole life! I would recommend this place to anyone who is looking for top level food at a very affordable price! I also tonight had the pleasure of meeting the owner Mr Davis himself and let me tell you he is a very special and kind man who cares about his customers which is very hard to find in today's world! Please if you haven't yet try this place out or you are missing out! I know I will be coming back again and again!“

“You walk in this place and look behind the counter and you just know that you're about to have the best pizza you've ever had. That kitchen is organized chaos lol. Bartolo's Special sicilian is my go-to here. I wish they had some version of online ordering/delivery, but the quality of the food makes up for it. Best place around to get a pizza!“

“We ordered a cheese pizza and a Chicken bacon ranch pizza.... At first, the establishment was super clean and every staff member was very attentive. Then once it came the pizza, it had the best crisps to the crust and the topping choices were perfect and perfectly cooked. I would definitely recommend this pizza if you're in the area.“

“I am new to the area and this made me feel at home but even better!! I order about every week. Fresh and very hot. Family restaurant and made me feel very welcomed!! I brought my family from back home here for dinner, they enjoy this just as much!! I need to try a few more things on the menu so I can brag more!!“

“I really liked it! Has a homey, hole in the wall feel, lots of interesting types of pizza (taco pizza!!??), nice indoor and outdoor sitting with lots of condiments. Everything you need! And portions are huge and make the price well worth it.“

“always nice and hot, And they delivere with in the hour at the most, very good, you don't have to leave home, and the driver was very polite and respectful and wore a mask 👍😎“

“We were in the area for a soccer tournament and were looking for somewhere that could accommodate our team for lunch. They gave us the all clear when we called, and they did not disappoint! The staff was great and the food came out really fast. Our family shared a pizza (cheesy and a great crispy crust), but by the looks of a lot of empty plates, the sandwiches and steaks were good too! We would absolutely eat here again when we’re back in the area.“

“We have been in a few times recently as we were working in the neighborhood. Great food, friendly staff, quick service! Today we shared an old world pizza, delicious!“

“If you’re anywhere near Harrisburg and haven’t tried this place yet, you’re missing out on a slice of Italy itself. These folks are true Italians through and through — you can taste the love and pride in every bite. From the moment we walked in, they treated my family like we were part of theirs. The service wasn’t just good; it was genuine, warm, and downright old-school in the best way. Now, the pizza. Their homemade sauce? Absolute perfection — easily the best we’ve had since our trip to Italy. It’s rich, fresh, and clearly made with the kind of care you can’t fake. The crust hits that magic balance: light, crispy, and chewy. My oldest, who’s never really been into pizza (still not sure how that’s genetically possible), couldn’t stop talking about how good their pie was. That alone says it all. Bottom line: this isn’t just pizza — it’s craftsmanship. A must-have, every time.“

“Highly recommend the Grandma’s Trio. Don’t be afraid of the margarita pizza in the middle. I was worried it was too saucy but wanted to step out of my comfort zone. I am SO glad I did! It turned out to be my favorite section, although I must say all three are outstanding. It’s pizza you’ve never had and don’t know you needed, and 100% worth trying. We literally planned a weekend in Harrisburg based on Papa Joe’s. We first tried it two years ago on a trip to the RV show and when the memory popped up this week we decided we needed the 2.5 hour road trip. Thanks for another great meal!“

“guyssss, that cheesesteak pizza you made tonight is AMAZING!! You're always our go-to, and I'm so happy we can support each other's small businesses!! 🤌“

“My favorite pizza around! Online ordering is so easy, delivery is quick, and their sauce is amazing!“

“Everything I have ordered has been delicious! Staff are always very friendly!“

“Great food love this place. And great customer service“

“My parents and I just ordered a large pepperoni pizza ! Taste amazing. Been going here since I was like 5 years old. Thank you Carlo and Ethan for great service and great food.“

“They have delicious pizza, and so happy they make a white pizza! If you order 2 medium or 2 large pizzas on Thursday, Friday, or Saturday, you get a free 2-liter.
They also have delicious stromboli, calzones, and subs. Eat here! Just eat here!“

“Courteous, attentive staff, fast , delicious, pizza. Highly recommend!“

“I love pizza and I have never been a big Sicilian pizza fan but their plain Sicilian is hands down the best pizza I have ever had. Not just Sicilian, the best pizza in general. Not to mention how amazingly friendly the staff is. I could not recommend this pizza more! It truly is amazing“

“Best local pizza 🍕“

“Pizza is excellent. I’m an Italian and pizza sauce is unbelievable. If I had any complaints, it would be having a dog in the restaurant. Which is unsanitary I believe no animal should be allowed around when you’re eating food. Other than that great food“

“I used to go to Pizzatown (R.I.P.) because it was closer and the food there was good. I'd gotten food from Babbo's a bunch of times since the closure and the food is very good. Most recently I got a white pizza with broccoli and tomatoes and it was excellent.

I like that Babbo's has a drive thru, as opposed to having to park and walk in like some of the other restaurants in town. I would recommend using the online ordering system instead of calling it in, if this is your first time ordering with Babbo's.“

“I got a veggie pizza and fries . It was very good and the service was amazing as well . The woman at the register was Beautiful 👀👀👀 ...“

“Amazing and quick. Ordered the chickens and lamb on rice while just down the road and was ready in less than 10 minutes for me to pick up. Got it home and dug in and it was amazing. Wife is a little more hesitant to try some stuff. She tried this and loved it. Full of flavor. We will def be getting this again. Highly recommend.“

“good stuff, highly recommend!“

“Used to work here and I couldn't recommend Little Italy more, both as a customer and as an employee! It's a very warm and inviting place, with the owners often greeting you personally and welcoming you in. Fran and Enzo make you feel like family. Great food, great service, and a wonderful family oriented atmosphere.“

“Love this place been coming for years . Although it's been a long time we came on Sunday with a big fried items order but they did not hesitate to serve us. The people were friendly even though they were closing they were happy to do it my grandma absolutely loved it and she is so picky for food but she ate very well that day ?❤️.“

“Consistently great food and friendly service. I will drive 15 minutes to go here when there are other pizza shops closer to my home. There aren't any pizza shops that compare.“

“Very helpful staff. Had a free pizza from Verizon that I could not get the coupon to work. Staff took the time to help me get the coupon to work. They went above and beyond to help.
My only comment on atmosphere was it was freezing cold in the table area where you eat. I think they need to adjust the cold air that blows right on the tables. No other complaints.“

“The Funnel Cake fries ! 😋❤“

“I don’t ever go out of my way to do reviews… however I ordered pizza today for a work event and The first pizza shop cancelled my order after I waited an hour. I called Ninos and they had 4 delicious pizzas whipped up and delivered within a half hour!! So thankful for that!!!“

“One of the best restaurants in the area! Such good quality & always so tasty.“

“Excellent NY style and strombolis“

“the manager Junior was AMAZING!!! i can't reccomend him enough!! we had our son and daughters birthday at chuck e cheese and he made it unforgetable!!! the kids were saying they can't wait to come back now. one of the best experiances i have had for the children's birthday! we were deciding between Dave and busters and chuck e cheese... we took a chance and Junior made it an AMAZING experiance! He went above and beyond, serving the pizza for us, making sure the table and drinks were all ready when we got there, dancing and interacting with the kids, being so friendly nice and welcoming. the kids (and adults) had a blast. worth EVERY penny! THANK YOU JUNIOR AND STAFF FOR CREATING A UNFORGETABLE BIRTHDAY!“

“This place has amazing pizza! I’m very picky with my pizza options in the Harrisburg area but this place pleasantly surprised us with delicious pizza. We had a half cheese, half pepperoni pizza and you can tell they use good quality cheese and good pepperoni. We also had some of their pastries, we had the guava pastry with a cheese filled quesito, they were both good. They would taste better warmer or freshly made but they keep them refrigerated. If you’re planning to dine-in, you must be aware that it’s a small place and tables are limited but if you’re doing takeout, this is a perfect small local business to support while eating some delicious and decently prized food. We will be back!“

“Love the pizza and subs. Atmosphere is great. I was reading the reviews and someone actually complained about a $14 large pizza. I guess they don't travel much because in most places, they are $17+. Family owned. And I'll say this, to anyone complaining about prices, I also own a resturant and you can blame Biden and his staff for the price increases on food. Keep it up usa and I.“

“I recommend both the pizza and the cheeseburger sub. The staff are extremely friendly. My daughter‘s class went there for a field trip, which is why we went there for dinner, and Mr. Joe came out to talk to her which made her day! Highly recommend!!“

“Wow ? I have had many pizzas (never heard of Mama’s before), but this was the best ever! They were kind from the time I said please hurry and there was a lot of traffic because of the fair, till the delivery. Excellent service and pizza was delicious ?!! Thank you, Mama’s Pizza! Your the greatest!“

“I’ve been a HUGE fan of I&E for a while (their soups are INCREDIBLE) but now I have to eat Gluten Free. Today was my first time having their GF Grilled Cheese and it was AMAZING!!! I’m so excited to still be able to eat at my favorite lunch spot!“