50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Middletown

“I was just there to catch up with old friends and had the veal Parmesan sub. It was delicious, big, decently priced, good sauce, perfect balance of soft/chewy/firm bun. Very friendly staff, pleasant, quiet atmosphere, and very clean.“

“if you want quality food and the best prices this is the place to go. I'm yet to find a place with better prices with better food“

“I've been eating here for about 4 years now. I'm a pretty regular customer. Food is always fresh and taste amazing. I've tried almost everything they offer and all of it is great. prices are on point as well. make sure you get a pizza because they do it right!“

“Ok place. Nothing like mothers that used to be there. Got turkey and bacon regular sub. For 14$ I was expecting more meat. Had 2 slices of turkey on each half. Plenty of bread if your a bread lover. Quality was good but more meat would have made this 5 stars.“

“Me and my girlfriend went to the Hozier concert in Hershey and stopped in for a little lunch before the event. Midtown pizza exceeded my expectations in a small Italian restaurant. We ordered garlic knots, chicken parmesean sub, meatball sub and fries. The garlic knots were small but came with 9 and were buttery and garlicky, the meatball sub was good and as was the chicken parmesan sub. The bread on the sandwiches really made it special. Though we didn’t go to the bar, but we dined in, the food came out in good time and the service was good. I recommend for those looking for a quick bite and the prices aren’t outrageous.“

“I have ordered from here at least twice a month for over a year now. The owner is a fantastic man who really keeps his word. They have the best pizza and Strombolis..“

“Bellia’s Pizza II is easily one of favorite spots to order food from!! Always giving out quality food & serving with a smile 🫶🏼 Daily special - your choice of sub, fries & a drink for $11.99 (we order on the slice app) Subs are always delicious and consistent every single time. We frequently buy the cheesesteaks and Italian subs, 10/10 🤤 Ventured out just recently and grabbed a salad from them & it’s so good!! I got a Caeser salad, added chicken and onion. & it’s incredible!! Absolutely worth the money 🫶🏼 & Honorable mention of my favorite pizza to get from them - the Big Mac pizza. Perfection with every bite. 🤤🤤 Thank you for the tasty food 🫶🏼🤤 we love ordering from your restaurant“

“Great thin crust pizza, with good cheese and fresh toppings. We will definitely be back!“

“I tried the buffalo chicken pizza and it tasted really good“

“Everything (handhelds, dinners or pizza) we have ever had was absolutely fantastic! This is our lunch/dinner stop anytime we pass through Harrisburg! It is worth venturing off the Linglestown exit. Eat in or take it to go....you will be glad you did!“

“their pizzas are amazingly good. you can tell and once you take the first bite that it was freshly made👍“

“The best pizza shop in the area. The staff is so awesome and professional. I love the cheesecake subs with fried onions and grilled sweet peppers. Always delicious 😋 Love everything about the restaurant. TRY IT!!!! Won't be disappointed.“

“David's pizza is by far the most amazing pizza restaurant I have ever ate at in my whole life! I would recommend this place to anyone who is looking for top level food at a very affordable price! I also tonight had the pleasure of meeting the owner Mr Davis himself and let me tell you he is a very special and kind man who cares about his customers which is very hard to find in today's world! Please if you haven't yet try this place out or you are missing out! I know I will be coming back again and again!“

“Been missing pizza from another place in Lebanon for years now and a friend told us this place has that sweet taste I was looking for! He was right 💯 percent! Makes sense now that I know they were family relatives! If it were closer to my house, I'd be in big trouble! Soooo good! Thank you guys for giving me the pizza taste I've been looking for since Pete passed! You've got a customer for life!“

“Arguably the best pizza in the hbg / Hershey area . 3.50 for a slice is a steep though but I’d rather pay that than 3 bucks for garbage. I’m just thinking it shouldn’t be what they charge back east where rent is mucb more expensive . Either way it’s much better than most of their comp“

“Old school small town Italian Sandwich and Pizza Shop. Bread on my hoagie and crust on daughter’s pizza was very nice. The bread for the sandwich had the crunch crust that is exactly what makes a hoagie good. Wife got an antipasto salad that was enough food for two. Overall a good experience.“

“If you’re anywhere near Harrisburg and haven’t tried this place yet, you’re missing out on a slice of Italy itself. These folks are true Italians through and through — you can taste the love and pride in every bite. From the moment we walked in, they treated my family like we were part of theirs. The service wasn’t just good; it was genuine, warm, and downright old-school in the best way. Now, the pizza. Their homemade sauce? Absolute perfection — easily the best we’ve had since our trip to Italy. It’s rich, fresh, and clearly made with the kind of care you can’t fake. The crust hits that magic balance: light, crispy, and chewy. My oldest, who’s never really been into pizza (still not sure how that’s genetically possible), couldn’t stop talking about how good their pie was. That alone says it all. Bottom line: this isn’t just pizza — it’s craftsmanship. A must-have, every time.“

“We have been in a few times recently as we were working in the neighborhood. Great food, friendly staff, quick service! Today we shared an old world pizza, delicious!“

“Highly recommend the Grandma’s Trio. Don’t be afraid of the margarita pizza in the middle. I was worried it was too saucy but wanted to step out of my comfort zone. I am SO glad I did! It turned out to be my favorite section, although I must say all three are outstanding. It’s pizza you’ve never had and don’t know you needed, and 100% worth trying. We literally planned a weekend in Harrisburg based on Papa Joe’s. We first tried it two years ago on a trip to the RV show and when the memory popped up this week we decided we needed the 2.5 hour road trip. Thanks for another great meal!“

“I am new to the area and this made me feel at home but even better!! I order about every week. Fresh and very hot. Family restaurant and made me feel very welcomed!! I brought my family from back home here for dinner, they enjoy this just as much!! I need to try a few more things on the menu so I can brag more!!“

“Great pizza! And with a gluten intolerant child, them making their gluten free pizza in its own tin and sending a pizza cutter to lower cross contamination is greatly appreciated!“

“Everything I have ordered has been delicious! Staff are always very friendly!“

“always nice and hot, And they delivere with in the hour at the most, very good, you don't have to leave home, and the driver was very polite and respectful and wore a mask 👍😎“

“They have delicious pizza, and so happy they make a white pizza! If you order 2 medium or 2 large pizzas on Thursday, Friday, or Saturday, you get a free 2-liter.
They also have delicious stromboli, calzones, and subs. Eat here! Just eat here!“

“guyssss, that cheesesteak pizza you made tonight is AMAZING!! You're always our go-to, and I'm so happy we can support each other's small businesses!! 🤌“

“My favorite pizza around! Online ordering is so easy, delivery is quick, and their sauce is amazing!“

“Great food love this place. And great customer service“

“Courteous, attentive staff, fast , delicious, pizza. Highly recommend!“

“Excellent NY style and strombolis“

“good stuff, highly recommend!“

“Consistently great food and friendly service. I will drive 15 minutes to go here when there are other pizza shops closer to my home. There aren't any pizza shops that compare.“

“Best local pizza 🍕“

“We were in the area for a soccer tournament and were looking for somewhere that could accommodate our team for lunch. They gave us the all clear when we called, and they did not disappoint! The staff was great and the food came out really fast. Our family shared a pizza (cheesy and a great crispy crust), but by the looks of a lot of empty plates, the sandwiches and steaks were good too! We would absolutely eat here again when we’re back in the area.“

“I love pizza and I have never been a big Sicilian pizza fan but their plain Sicilian is hands down the best pizza I have ever had. Not just Sicilian, the best pizza in general. Not to mention how amazingly friendly the staff is. I could not recommend this pizza more! It truly is amazing“

“This is a great establishment. I love there pizza, owner always makes it how I like it. Great customer service, the owner is always very friendly and makes sure customers are satisfied!“

“I love boulevards pizzeria, I just got a pizza from them tonight. The owner is super friendly and nice. He gives good customer service and always makes us feel welcome. I hear Nick take orders on the phone . I highly recommend this place they sell amazing pizza, chicken wings , bacon cheese fries and so much more 🍕🍕🍕🍕“

“I ordered a pizza from here on Uber Eats and it did not disappoint! Lots of options for vegans including very clearly labeled crust options saying which ones are vegan, plus vegan cheese and a vegan protein option. Unlimited veggie toppings at no added cost per topping. Updated from previous review on 2026-02-18“

“I got a veggie pizza and fries . It was very good and the service was amazing as well . The woman at the register was Beautiful 👀👀👀 ...“

“Love this place been coming for years . Although it's been a long time we came on Sunday with a big fried items order but they did not hesitate to serve us. The people were friendly even though they were closing they were happy to do it my grandma absolutely loved it and she is so picky for food but she ate very well that day ?❤️.“

“I found this place on an accident. I turned into the parking lot to turn around and go to a different pizza place but figured I ended up in their parking lot so it was fate. I'm so glad I went in and gave them a try! As soon as you walk in it smells amazing! The pizza in the window looked great and the desserts in the car looked delicious. I got a large extra cheese pizza, a large pepperoni pizza, large cheese steak boli and 4 cannolis. The man at the counter maybe the owner? An absolute sweetheart. He was so patient with me during the ordering process and genuinely seemed to enjoy his job. While waiting for the food to be made I was presented with 3 bags of their house made chips to try. And oh my goodness they could just sell nothing but those they were so delicious!!! The house blend chips were delicious and went great with their spicy dip. The barbeque give middleswarth a run for their money, seriously that good. And the buffalo were BUFFALO. lol. If you love spicy his that builds in intensity as you eat then they are the chip for you. Super spicy but a nice warm addictive heat. Me and my husband were seriously blown away at how good those chips were! The pizza also didn't disappoint. Hot, fresh, delicious airy dough, flavorful sauce, and good quality cheese. The cheese steak boli was massive in size and flavor. So much cheese, delicious caramelized onions and so much meat. We ate off of it for 3 days. Such good food, service, prices, and quality. We loved the cannoli filling the shell just was soft but oh well things happen. Everything else was top notch especially the man I interacted with from the moment I walked in to him carrying it out to my car he was absolutely fantastic. Please give this gem a try you won't be disappointed.“

“I'm a truck driver for the America's, sometimes down to Mexico all the way up to alaska, and I can confirm that this is the best pizza and wings I have had in a VERY long time!
I did have a small hiccup ordering because I didn't know it was an old menu I was looking at, but that was quickly resolved. And at request they sent a couple of menus so I could replace the old ones at the APU shop I had to bring my truck to.
My husband and I got a large cheese pizza and 12 jumbo boneless wings to share. Half hot wings and the other half garlic parmesan, with Bleu cheese and celery sticks. Bleeding delicious they were!!!“

“Their Angus steak burgers are shockingly good! I didn't have a fresh pizza but I got a slice of margherita pizza (at 8pm) and it was still very good despite being most likely hours old. Am definitely coming back later in the week to try a fresh pizza.“

“The Funnel Cake fries ! 😋❤“

“You eat delicious pang donna sandwich hors d'oeuvres of all kinds I recommend the place Budding pandem corn screw chiskay of everything go and try and the delicious pizza pan donut of everything delicious a very good place to go with the family“

“I don’t ever go out of my way to do reviews… however I ordered pizza today for a work event and The first pizza shop cancelled my order after I waited an hour. I called Ninos and they had 4 delicious pizzas whipped up and delivered within a half hour!! So thankful for that!!!“

“Love the pizza and subs. Atmosphere is great. I was reading the reviews and someone actually complained about a $14 large pizza. I guess they don't travel much because in most places, they are $17+. Family owned. And I'll say this, to anyone complaining about prices, I also own a resturant and you can blame Biden and his staff for the price increases on food. Keep it up usa and I.“

“All the time fresh and is good management and very nice people“

“So this was my first time trying their pizza had a couple people refer me, so i came here first time customers service was great and then i took the food to my kids and they said mom keep going here, now they love dominos and givonnies, in steelton pa but now thats done, i think i found a new spot.

Kid-friendliness: Love the customer service atmosphere for a first time customer this is everything and i will now make this my new go to“

“Such great staff with warm welcome every single time without a fail. I feel like home going to this place. We take every single family member here when they visit us.“

“the manager Junior was AMAZING!!! i can't reccomend him enough!! we had our son and daughters birthday at chuck e cheese and he made it unforgetable!!! the kids were saying they can't wait to come back now. one of the best experiances i have had for the children's birthday! we were deciding between Dave and busters and chuck e cheese... we took a chance and Junior made it an AMAZING experiance! He went above and beyond, serving the pizza for us, making sure the table and drinks were all ready when we got there, dancing and interacting with the kids, being so friendly nice and welcoming. the kids (and adults) had a blast. worth EVERY penny! THANK YOU JUNIOR AND STAFF FOR CREATING A UNFORGETABLE BIRTHDAY!“