37 Best Pizza Restaurants near Palmyra

“You walk in this place and look behind the counter and you just know that you're about to have the best pizza you've ever had. That kitchen is organized chaos lol. Bartolo's Special sicilian is my go-to here. I wish they had some version of online ordering/delivery, but the quality of the food makes up for it. Best place around to get a pizza!“

“Amazing food, amazing service, amazing staff!!!! Highly recommended!“

“guyssss, that cheesesteak pizza you made tonight is AMAZING!! You're always our go-to, and I'm so happy we can support each other's small businesses!! 🤌“

“Its been awhile since going there. I got lasagna with Shrimp Sausage and meat sauce. Was not sure how that would be. It was great. Staff was great. Was packed when I was there.“

“One of the best restaurants in the area! Such good quality & always so tasty.“

“We needed a large order to feed a group of people for a local non profit organization, the owner was wonderful to work with! He helped us build the most cost efficient order and worked within our boundaries. He was very friendly, courteous, and timely! I highly recommend !“

“I tried their pizza for the first time. It was very good! Please don’t change your red sauce. As in adding grape jelly like a lot of local pizzerias do. I would love if you make a thin crust.“

“The Palmyra Pizza Hut Location is one of the best Pizza Hits you could ever get pizza from!!!
The staff is super friendly, sometimes funny too.
Never a disappointment coming here. Been a customer since I was a kid!!! They still have their free personal pan pizza book-it program for kids, be sure to check it out!!“

“We ordered pizzas here today and the card reader was down. We had no cash so they said not to worry and gave it to us free. Great customer service! Thanks Domino“

“always nice and hot, And they delivere with in the hour at the most, very good, you don't have to leave home, and the driver was very polite and respectful and wore a mask 👍😎“

“Great pizza! And with a gluten intolerant child, them making their gluten free pizza in its own tin and sending a pizza cutter to lower cross contamination is greatly appreciated!“

“Wow! The pizza was fantastic along with the cannolis. This is the best pizza I had in a long time. The toppings were plentiful and flavorful. The crust was light and chewy. Delivery was fast and courteous. The next time I come up to PA we’re going to order again from Palmero’s. This place is a gem!“

“Food was very good!! First time there, traveling through, very friendly.“

“Pizza Town 1 in Jonestown is excellent. I don't go out to Jonestown very often at all, but due to high ratings and recommendations, I drove my Can-Am Ryker out there this afternoon and got a medium pepperoni pie. I should have just gotten a cheese pizza so I could taste ONLY the flavor of the pizza, so I pulled the pepperoni off of two pieces to judge rightly. Great taste and very large size for a medium! My favorite pizza place of all time is Bartolos in Palmyra, Pa. but this is still very solid, and highly recommended. Easy 9/10 for Pizza Town 1 and I will purchase again, and it's a 12 mile ride for me, one way!“

“AWESOME Homemade Food!!!!“

“We stopped in last evening to give it a try. Really liked the atmosophere and the decor. Great job. The weather was wonderful so we chose to sit on the screened in porch and we received very good service. Ordered Veal Scalapini and it was good. An addition of lemon or garlic or a splash of white wine in the sauce would take it to the next level. My wife had the chicken bruscetta with broccoli. The dish was cold because the Bruscetta was not warmed before putting it on the chicken. Chicken was nice and tender. Wonderful entree just needed some heat. Since we are wood fired oven pizza snobs we try a small pizza. the cheese and sauce we real good. Can't say the same for the crust, which is the foundation of every good pizza. Suggest a 3 day cold fermentation with the dough to enhance the flavor. Then the pizza would be in a 9/10 range. Overall wonderful dining experience“

“We have been in a few times recently as we were working in the neighborhood. Great food, friendly staff, quick service! Today we shared an old world pizza, delicious!“

“Love the cheesesteaks and the chicken italiano 🔥❤️“

“I was just there to catch up with old friends and had the veal Parmesan sub. It was delicious, big, decently priced, good sauce, perfect balance of soft/chewy/firm bun. Very friendly staff, pleasant, quiet atmosphere, and very clean.“

“Always a great experience at Mancino’s Pizza. Make sure you try their new deli sandwich’s. Mike made me the Rotondi Sub that I’ll definitely be back for!!“

“Courteous, attentive staff, fast , delicious, pizza. Highly recommend!“

“I know I’m late to the party here but if you’ve only been a pizza shop customer you’re missing the boat. We had a fantastic sit down meal last night. Great drinks, appetizers, entrees, and service. We will definitely be back for dinner more often.“

“Upscale cocktail bar located in the Hotel Hershey. The cocktails are delicious, especially the chocolate martini! They also serve fancy appetizers here, but not full meals. We like going to this place to celebrate birthdays and special occasions as it is a bit pricey, but still recommend checking it out!“

“Food was delicious and made our stay in the area so much better having a wonderful dinner with my fiancé“

“We love coming here. The food is always delicious. And it’s fun being able to bring our own wine! They always give us ice and open it for us. They are very flexible with switching out sauces as well. The free bread is fantastic too.“

“I’ve been a HUGE fan of I&E for a while (their soups are INCREDIBLE) but now I have to eat Gluten Free. Today was my first time having their GF Grilled Cheese and it was AMAZING!!! I’m so excited to still be able to eat at my favorite lunch spot!“

“Just had a cheese steak and his and had a cheeseburger sub. The cheese steak was amazing and hubs like the sub. Definitely recommend them for their sandwiches. The home made rolls are very soft!!“

“Delicious food for a great price. The workers are so friendly“

“great place to eat. always hot and delicious. I was a little upset when they had gone on vacation because I enjoy their food so much.“

“I've been eating here for about 4 years now. I'm a pretty regular customer. Food is always fresh and taste amazing. I've tried almost everything they offer and all of it is great. prices are on point as well. make sure you get a pizza because they do it right!“

“We absolutely love Brother Joe’s Pizza! We didn’t use to come here much, but ever since the new owners took over, it’s become one of our favorite spots. The difference is night and day—the food is consistently delicious, and the staff is amazing. Everyone is friendly, welcoming, and truly seems to care about your experience. Highly recommend!“

“The manager - younger guy - Alan maybe? He’s the real deal. We order here every few weeks, and the food and service are always on point. Alan is consistently very friendly with an uplifting attitude towards his job and his employees. Food is always great.“

“amazing breakfast, fresh fruit !“

“Best shop in town!!! Our family go to!!!“

“stopped at Pizzatown 2 last evening for dinner. my wife and I decided to get a chef salad and Large cheesesteak to share. but it's s were made by a gentleman named Kevin who was working the grill. let me tell you that the chef salad was absolutely delicious with an abundance of meat and cheese and the cheesesteak was also packed with meat and was very tasty. once again great job and great food. And thanks Kevin for a delicious dinner. you nailed it.“

“ordered wings and a pizza. 35 bucks for a medium pizza and 8 wings. delivery was 10 min late. the pizza was excellent. I really enjoyed it. but I was disappointed in the wings. they were soft and fatty but the worst part was they must've squirted the BBQ sauce on them and it was not covering the wings. gotta toss those better. the good news, other than the pizza being good, was as soon as I was finished I got an email from them saying they let me down and offered a free medium pizza. so they're on it even when they make mistakes they correct them. so I'm mixed right now. if the free pizza shows up on time and is good I'll keep ordering but if not I'll probably move on to another pizza spot“

“Much better food and set up than previous restaurant in that space. Has three different restaurants and a bar there. The bar is one if the best in Grantville with a large selection of local and craft beers on tap. Plus they have a pretty good whiskey selection“