50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Eagle

“Thank you for delivering to our house on redds mill rd… we are spreading the word… we will be ordering more pizza from you.. thank you for dinner“

“Solid pizza I would recommend“

“The art and photos of the pizzas drew me in! The place is filled with the art, and you get filled with the pizza. It's a good situation.

I got my pizza with no cheese, and I'd do it here again! The usual cheesy pizzas look good, too, so I doubt you can go wrong.“

“The white pizza is amazing and Italian hoagies are the best so filling“

“Love their pizza sooooo much!!! And the owner is a really cool guy.“

“This is a great spot for a delicious pizza. The Pepperoni Pizza had a perfect crispy-chewy crust, tasty sauce, plenty of cheese, and just the right amount of pepperoni. Everything tasted fresh and not too greasy. Service was quick and friendly, making for a perfect pizza night. Highly recommend if you’re nearby!“

“OH MY GOODNESS! We have been searching for a good fish sandwich/dinner that is worth ordering a second time. Not until today did we find some worthy of ordering every Friday. My husband picked up a fish and fries order and we demolished it and the bonus is it is within walking distance of our shop (Collin’s Corner).“

“I called IVP to order pizza for a school sports team event occurring on a Monday. I didn’t realize they are typically closed on Monday, but the person I spoke with was so pleasant and helpful and took our order anyway. They said they are usually there on Mondays to make dough, so they were happy to help us out with the pizzas we needed. Everything was perfect and ready exactly when we asked for it. I have always had great service and great quality food every time I have order from them.“

“The best pizza we have had in Pittsburgh! Had the Italian Hoagie too- delicious! Place was super clean and folks were friendly. Look no further!!“

“I been going there for some time. The food is delicious. It’s a small place with big flavor .haven’t eaten any thing bad yet. And don’t think it’s possible.“

“Very good pizza. Never disappointed.“

“Great customer service, absolutely love the sauce! Plenty of great choices!“

“order from here occasionally, I prefer it to the other pizza places that deliver. sometimes they're spot on sometimes they're not, but what restaurant doesn't have their bad days. Will definitely order when I have a want for pizza amd don't want to drive“

“Try the Chicken parm family meal deal .. you won't be disappointed!!“

“Great place. Just nothing stay in stock for long. There like really our only deli like place. So many people from our area depend on this place. Great employees and they follow most guidelines other then the temperature check, but this is my favorite because they try their best to have and keep supply and demand. A Lot without cars here in this town . so product leave a bit faster then others. Great jon Station“

“I have been driving by this shop for so long and felt that I should give them a shot. I stopped in and wasn't disappointed with the kicking chicken pizza. It tasted wonderful, and the pricing isn't far out expensive like a few other places. Great job.“

“This has been my mother's favorite place for hoagies ever since they opened. I've always enjoyed the food whenever she brought me here for lunch. The portions are HUGE and the prices are very reasonable. I brought my wife here on our road trip through PA this summer, and she claims that she'll likely have dreams about the chicken bacon ranch hoagie from here until we return again.“

“I am addicted to their giant hoagies and their pizza is awesome !“

“Great food, convenient and good prices.“

“Pizza Burgh, Pizza Burgh, PIZZA BURGHThis pizza was fire and before I jump into details let me tell you what I ordered, a large extra cheese and pepperoni hand tossed, baby just go get it ??? “17.99 two topping large special”Okay let’s get into it, I’m a pizza girl and I can say this is theee best pizza I’ve had in a while. I usually only get pizza that looks and tastes like this when I go out of town.From the crust to the toppings everything was fresh, just absolutely finger licking delicious. I ate more than I usually would!I didn’t pick up my Husband did and said everything looked very clean and he had wonderful + respectful customer service from “the man behind the counter”I will travel downtown to cafe milanos for pizza like this that’s my favorite place but I’m going out on a limb to say this might be better, I gotta see if yaw have a garlic butter sauce ?Being pregnant, moving, needing a quick and filling bite, having had to settle for little Caesars, Pizza Hut, palmers, broadway, fat Angelo’s (which has disappointed me twice) this is the best in the area! You now have a new family of forever customers.“

“Delicious food recommend nice people“

“Very clean place nice workers excellent pizza“

“had a big order of pizza ordered the day before & picked up everything was delicious!!!“

“get a lot of lamb on gyro and cucumber sause is out of this world. pizza 🍕 great.“

“I have been to Mama Pepino's in Glassport several times. Great place!!! I've been there with 20+ other members of my family and they took great care of us!!! But I made the mistake of ordering delivery yesterday. The delivery guy was the sorriest excuse for a human being I have ever met!!! He needs to stay in the restaurant!!! He was not a good ambassador for the business!!! He did nothing but complain when he got here!!! Not a pleasant person. He gave me the wrong order and had to come back to exchange the orders!!! I felt sorry a 350+ lb. person had to climb my steps a second time!!! I gave him a $13 tip. Should have been 13 cents!!!“

“Wonderful tasting super yummy steak hoagie! Great tasting pepperoni pizza and white pizza!! Breadsticks are great, and the customer service was super friendly??Highly recommended!!The picture of the half eaten is because it was so good I forgot to take a picture before hand?“

“Great service! Hoagies were delicious. Looking forward to trying the pizza before we head back home.“

“From the pizzas (regular or gourmet), to burgers, don't forget fresh hibachi, and to the milkshakes. I haven't found nothing here that wasn't delicious! They definitely have a little bit of everything!“

“I love their pizza! The thin crust and large slices are a hit in our household. Always delicious, and passes the picky-pizza-eater kiddo test.“

“There are many pizza places in the Mon Valley. Very few of them are consistent. This is one of the few. You never disappoint. Food is always too notch, and the service is the icing on the cake! I applaud you and will brag about you from here to eternity. Thank you, thank you, and thank you again!“

“Thanks for the delicious pizza! Our family loved them! It was so nice of you to make a new pizza for our take out order tonight! It was nice meeting you Drew!!“

“Immaculate pizza enough said“

“This place has become our go-to spot, especially with their fantastic anyday, anytime lunch specials. I often take my kid, and it’s perfect because they offer great options that keep both of us happy. The portions are generous, the pizza is always hot and fresh, and the deals make it super affordable. The staff is always friendly and welcoming.“

“Friends and I enjoyed dinner at Tillie's last night and it was a great evening. Of course, the company was great but the food was also great. And, our server was a joy. She was pleasant, attentive and did a good job. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for great food and excellent service. Thanks!!!“

“AMAZING way to come back! So excited for this! Food is always AMAZING! Thank you so much. Great to see y’all back 💕💕💕“

“I had your competitor’s pizza Caliente’s wasn’t as good as this! I really like it! And delivery man was nice too! I won’t order any pizza in future only Olive Oil’s believe Me !👍🏼“

“Very friendly staff. They treat you like somebody they know, not a customer which I happen to like. Food is awesome. And generally very large portions

Kid-friendliness: Just a pickup counter. They do have a few things to entertain the younger people while you wait but there's nothing specific“

“Food is always really good. I usually get the spicy Italian hoagies. Very delicious, but if you don't like a saucy sandwich, it is loaded with the spicy mayo. Perfect for me though. Love the pizza and the zucchini sticks which arent sticks. Nice size pieces. Never had to wait more than 20 mins, even with delivery. When they answer to phone, some times it's hard to hear. Everytime I call in, they never seem happy to be answering a phone, they usually sound annoyed. And they can be quick to hang up as soon as they give you your time frame. But they do get busy there.“

“Pizza is really good! My husband likes it there with the new owners, they are doing a good job taking over. However the Parmesan garlic bites were sooo spicy and bitter, tasted like eating a straight glove, but my husband is a pure Italian so he ate them. Thank you!“

“Super nice people! The owner is very friendly - large selection of product - hoagies are VERYYY good and great price! Very organized and clean. Grew up going to the drug store originally there and so happy someone did something with it 😊“

“they have the best pizza and wings and french fries and the staff are awesome“

“Thanks for the delicious pizza! Our family loved them! It was so nice of you to make a new pizza for our take out order tonight! It was nice meeting you Drew!!“

“I wish I was down that way to enjoy their fare more often. You won't find a more authentic homestyle burger anywhere!“

“I order delivery ,usually get the big daddy it’s not an authentic Italian pizza but a good and consistent American pizza ,I have never been dissatisfied with my order fast ,friendly and hot .The Big Daddy is great when we have family over and don’t feel like cooking.In the food business consistency is the key!!!“

“Our grandson loves it there. He is only 2 1/2 but love to hit golf balls & loves the ice cream.“

“Great food and amazing customer service. If you’re from resa, you know foxes is family!“

“The pizza is very good here as I'm sure other items are on the menu. The owner bites all types of employees, even ones with disabilities. I'd recommend this place to anyone, over big chain restaurants. Shop small, shop local. 🍕 🍕 🍕“

“The beer selection is top notch and the food is solid with friendly service. We are lucky to have this in the south hills. I recommend the wings and pizza cooked in their wood fired pizza oven. The wine is always fresh as it is on tap vs a wine bottle. Live entertainment and dog friendly on Tuesday nights on the outside patio when the weather cooperates.“

“Nice food and atmosphere!“