50 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Newton

“My favorite pizza! I drive 35 minutes to pick it up!“

“great staff, good food, fair pricing.“

“Ordered a supreme pizza and told them I like it crispy last night. Walked back to the b and b to eat, and was blown away!!! That was the best pizza I've ever had and id like to think ive had a bunch of pizzas in 40yrs lol. No wonder this place is generational its incredible!“

“the Penn Trafford Boys Youth Lacrosse would like to thank An Extra Slice of New York for coming to our lacrosse tournament and selling hot slices. the line never stopped and everyone loved the pizza! Thank you for always supporting the community!!“

“We stopped here (6-6-26) while on our family raid trip from Illinois and got the pizza and wings combo. It was delicious! The wings were perfectly crispy and the pizza hit the spot for our hungry needs. Glad to have stumbled upon this pizza place while on our journey.“

“Great pizza, friendly and fast service.“

“I ordered here for the first time tonight and the pizza was great! The price was beyond reasonable and I couldn't believe how great it tasted. The owner was so friendly and kind. I will definitely be ordering again and I highly recommend everything here!“

“We are new to the area and exploring all of the pizza spots we can find! Valley Pizza did not disappoint!
I was thrilled to see the option for sweet sauce and chose that for mine-it was delicious! Hubby got the regular sauce and it was equally delicious!
We will definitely be ordering from there again and trying some other menu options!“

“The food is always great but the people who work there are always so miserable, terrible attitudes. Just like they hate their job and it shows. Food is great though, a shame that everyone is miserable everytime I’ve ever been there.“

“Try the Chicken parm family meal deal .. you won't be disappointed!!“

“There are many pizza places in the Mon Valley. Very few of them are consistent. This is one of the few. You never disappoint. Food is always too notch, and the service is the icing on the cake! I applaud you and will brag about you from here to eternity. Thank you, thank you, and thank you again!“

“The Pizza is so delicious, never disappoints, will Definitely return!“

“I have never had a problem there I love that place since day one but last time I ordered 10 split wings I got 5 split wings by charge 20 bucks“

“Super nice people and good pizza. I did order my pizza well done and I think next time I'll just go for a regular pie. I am so tired of undercooked pizza and this was my first time there, so I should have just ordered a regular pepperoni. It was very good though.“

“From the pizzas (regular or gourmet), to burgers, don't forget fresh hibachi, and to the milkshakes. I haven't found nothing here that wasn't delicious! They definitely have a little bit of everything!“

“thank you to who always chops my salad whenever i put it in the special instructions. absolutely perfect!“

“Great place. Just nothing stay in stock for long. There like really our only deli like place. So many people from our area depend on this place. Great employees and they follow most guidelines other then the temperature check, but this is my favorite because they try their best to have and keep supply and demand. A Lot without cars here in this town . so product leave a bit faster then others. Great jon Station“

“I enjoy going to Bills for breakfast, dinner, and lunch. The food is always good and I love the everyday specials it takes the work out of picking from the several other daily items they offer. The staff is always helpful and food comes out quick.“

“very good food. big quantity for the price. nice staff. will be back.“

“We had Jordan as our waitress! What a sweetheart. She was attentive and made sure we enjoyed our food. Food was awesome as well,“

“Delicious food & great service!!! Will be back soon!!!“

“Thanks for the delicious pizza! Our family loved them! It was so nice of you to make a new pizza for our take out order tonight! It was nice meeting you Drew!!“

“I recently hosted my daughter's "sprinkle" at L&I's party room. Scheduling and selecting a menu were very easy! The day of the event the staff was helpful and the food was delicious! I highly recommend L&I's! Thank you for making our event wonderful Danny, Ashley, Jamie and John!“

“Friends and I enjoyed dinner at Tillie's last night and it was a great evening. Of course, the company was great but the food was also great. And, our server was a joy. She was pleasant, attentive and did a good job. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for great food and excellent service. Thanks!!!“

“Thanks for the delicious pizza! Our family loved them! It was so nice of you to make a new pizza for our take out order tonight! It was nice meeting you Drew!!“

“I love their pizza! The thin crust and large slices are a hit in our household. Always delicious, and passes the picky-pizza-eater kiddo test.“

“GREAT FOOD!!! Huge portions and made to order. Had pizza, salad, fresh cut fries and the HUGE fish sandwich. Can't wait to try more on the menu!!!“

“Mama Pepino's is truly the best pizza sub shop on the planet. Keep up the great job guys. Love the chicken parm sub. It is one of my many favorites. Makes me hungry just thinking about it.“

“A recent drop off at the UPS store lead me to an impromptu lunch decision. The aroma outside the shop drew me in to Mama Pepino’s for the first time today. I was greeted by the friendly owner, who took my counter/take out order and quickly prepared what is probably the BEST steak hoagie I have enjoyed from a pizza shop in quite some time. I ordered it exactly as it was listed on the menu. The owner did mention they bake their own hoagie rolls fresh and even after the 20 minute car ride home it held up very well and was still warm. But I’d be remiss to not mention the abundance of steak and toppings that hoagie bun held - very tasty and filling. With trends of prices rising and portions shrinking - THIS sandwich is a robust bite and good value! I know now to keep Mama Pepino’s on my radar when I am in the Irwin area.“

“Delicious food recommend nice people“

“Double M's pizza is literally the best pizza place in southwest Pennsylvania. In my opinion anyway and thats saying a good bit because pizza is my favorite food. The people were awesome and very generous and kind. The pizza there is incredible, I have order from here twice and both times it was fantastic. I have had the pepperoni and cheese, Philly cheese steak and buffalo chicken and all three were delicious. They also gave me a free small Philly cheese steak because I changed my mind about ordering it do to my wife lol. If I could give this place 100 stars I would“

“get a lot of lamb on gyro and cucumber sause is out of this world. pizza 🍕 great.“

“Their food is amazing never ever had a complaint! But Their garlic butter sauce if off the charts amazing especially for dipping steak rolls in. Only place I will ever order steak rolls from hands down“

“We used this company for fundraising at a local school. The company was very attentive, friendly and reasonable. The quality of the products was fantastic! I highly recommend using them for any fundraising you may need. We will definitely be using them again.“

“This is the second time my order was messed up. The first time my gyro meat was burnt Not just dark, burnt. This time I ordered a pizza half plain and half with toppings. I was delivered a pizza with two plain pieces. When called they wanted me to drive the order in and get remaid. I offered to send a picture . Will never order again.“

“everything is wonderful, the Staff is the best they never disappoint...... 😍“

“had a big order of pizza ordered the day before & picked up everything was delicious!!!“

“just ordered a buffalo chicken becks pizza with bacon cheese fries, hot pepper cheese balls and fried mushrooms. everything was hot and tastes amazing. the delivery driver was so sweet. will definitely be ordering again!“

“I literally cannot rave enough about this restaurant!Adorable space with unique menu items all the time. I can always count on a delicious meal be it a regular menu item or special. The desserts ! I am not a huge dessert person but now I am for Orders amazing one of a kind selections! Bonus they have so many gluten free items for those that need! Grateful to have this restaurant close to my home❤️“

“Their food is really good plus you get a nice size portion. The delivery is really good even when they're super busy. The people that work there are very polite and respectful starting from the owner, and manager. I definitely would recommend this place.“

“Their pizza and chicken salad is the best and they are very friendly would highly recommend“

“Great service great food!“

“I've been a solid supporter of this business for better than 10 years.And in that one0 years, I've seen the quality.Go down the price, go up to the point where it's not affordable food anymore.It's exorbitant. I've ordered hundreds of antipasto salads from this place in the past 12 years.I've noticed that the containers half full and then when I ask for things to be added to it like banana peppers or something else , it's just it never makes it through , I get the salad , it doesn't have the thing. My most recent thing is that I've been also ordering this stuff.Shells with meatballs for I don't know 10 years also and the past times 2 times of order, they've refused to put meatballs in the order of stuff, shells that has always come with meatballs.It's never been an upcharge, always come with some meatballs.I know, because I've been eating it for years and years. They Literally wanted $16 tonight.For an order of french fries in a two liter and then told me I had to spend another five dollars to get it delivered I mean it's not enough to bend you over 47 dollars for a two liter and seven dollars for french fries plus a delivery fee for f****** french fries..... My Suggestion is to make your food.The value of what you charge for it, like if you're going to charge $17 for stuff, shells like put some d*** meatballs in there.Put some protein source in there.Like.What are you thinking?I don't even understand that anyways, it's been fun.Enjoy the review“

“The wife and i sat in she got a buffalo chicken salad and i had a steak hoagie. The steak hoagie was up there with the best I've had. There was soo much steak on it i had to litterally take some off. Service was great and very friendly. 10/10“

“Super nice people! The owner is very friendly - large selection of product - hoagies are VERYYY good and great price! Very organized and clean. Grew up going to the drug store originally there and so happy someone did something with it 😊“

“Great place, delicious food, friendly bartenders. Highly recommend.“

“Had a large group this evening for dinner. Our servers were fantastic and the food was excellent! Everyone seemed to enjoy themselves. Excellent experience and am looking forward to going back again to try the pizza!“

“Order from Inferno at least once a week, everytime we get the food it is hot and delicious, with great service“

“I order delivery ,usually get the big daddy it’s not an authentic Italian pizza but a good and consistent American pizza ,I have never been dissatisfied with my order fast ,friendly and hot .The Big Daddy is great when we have family over and don’t feel like cooking.In the food business consistency is the key!!!“

“Today’s order was exceptional. It had been a minute since I ordered from here as usually my order was messed up etc. today I was craving one of their chicken salads so I decided to get that and a pizza for my kids. Both items were amazing and perfect! I understand this place is under new ownership. The manager/owner even brought the food to my car and chit chatted with me a bit. 10/10 customer service. This makes a big difference.“