Armetta's Pizzeria & Pub

2092 PA-848, New Milford
(570) 465-5492

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rexann Peppers

Ordered a couple slices of their White pizza. Very delicious, service was good and price was right.

Linda Lindsey

Best white pizza in the area!

Douglas Knapp

Wanted a hot carbo dinner on a rainy night Wednesday the 30th of May. The gnocchi were cold and tasted like dough the meatballs were cold, the sauce was the only thing warm on the plate. I sent it back for a veal sub that came with two strips of meat basically a cheese & sauce sub. I brought my dissatisfaction to the (cook) owner who with a tight lipped smile said I was wrong about the gnocchi and the veal is portion controls. That food was worst the a hot lunch served in middle school! I did tip more than I should have, the server isn’t going to Paris on the money she makes here.

Brad Stringer

Even though its a drive for us, we used to stop at Armetta`s frequently. But after a couple of poor service issues, we stopped going. Last night we decided to try again, only to find that service had gotten much worse and the food was horrible. We had to leave the bar and go to the kitchen to ask for refills on our beers and then when food came, it was terrible. Cold Calzone`s and the sauce on the pasta tasted burnt. So, I had to leave the bar again and walk to the kitchen to let them know that they were way under cooked. We had to ask for the garlic knots that were supposed to come with the Pasta dish, and they came 20 minutes after we got our meal. And they were over cooked. I also, had to go looking for our waitress to get a check. Maybe this is why there was only one other customer in the restaurant while we were there. Not Happy at all with our experience at Armetta`s.

Ricardo Tamayo

Me and my wife decided to give this place a try on our way to New York, we didn't expect much, just hoped that it was decent. The place looks really nice inside, everything is clean and organized, we were told to pick a table and someone would help us. The waitress came to our table probably every 3 to 5 minutes to check on us. We ordered the Antipasto salad, the Hawaiian pizza, garlic knots and fried pickles. The appetizers were great and delicious but nothing too crazy over the top. The pizza and the salad on the other hand is what will keep us coming back every time we have a chance to pass through here. What a delicious pizza made to absolute perfection!! And the salad, wow! My wife was so happy. They have a very delicious garlic sauce which sadly they don't sell bottles of, because it's that good. The waitress was extremely helpful and attentive. Loved this place and their food, will definitely visit back.

Pam Hoffman

Outstanding pizza!!

Robert Goutermout

Excellent food and wait staff amazing and fun will definitely recommend and be returning

Michael Mosscrop

We come to this area to ski and love to visit this place. Nice menu and good pizza. Always service with a smile and good selection of beer. This place is a gem. Come visit when you are here.

Glenn Wilson

Ordered a slice of Sicilian, awesome! Wife Ordered spaghetti and meatballs. Sauce was burnt, except for the meatballs, inedible. I ordered shrimp Alfredo, same thing. Ate the shrimp but the pasta was congieled together, had to cut chunks w a fork. They did remove the cost of one meal. Service, not great but acceptable.

Phil Wirth

Best pizza for miles. We enjoy both the NY-style traditional round and the double-crusted white. Nice bar with big beer selection. Laid back atmosphere.

Theresa Devanney

Yummiest pizza in the area !

Christopher Mirra

porterhouse t-bone or ny strip. wich do you prefer

Kurt Roth

Awesome place to eat! The food was so fresh.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad

steven carpenter

Sal has a great staff and awesome food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Chicken Parmesan Dinner, Fried Ravioli, Salad, Cajun Chicken Salad, Chicken Broccoli Pasta

Mike Flor

Always a good meal...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...