8 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Milford

Hot Pies Pizzeria Pizza • $
253 Jackson St, New Milford

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Butter Dipping Sauce
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Cheese Pizza Slice
Crispy Chicken
Garlic Fries
Half Sheet
Wings

“This is a Small Mom and Pop Pizza Joint in a Beautiful Small Town. I Had the Buffalo Chicken Mac-n-Cheese, And it exceeded all my expectations, better than most iv'e tried! It was also SPOTLESS inside, couldnt be cleaner! Definitly will be returning, they got themselves a regular!“

4.6 Superb22 Reviews
Uncle Charlie's Bella Pizza Pizza • $
914 Main St, New Milford

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
White Pizza
Wings

“A gem was found during our travel and it is Uncle Charlie's Bella Pizza! A family business oriented to make fresh, delicious food. Our experience entails as follows: called ahead of time and ordered four sandwiches. The phone attendant was courteous, patient, honest, and told us the time and cost of the food, very pleasant to talk. The place was easy to find without major directions. Upon arrival, the attention was superb and came out to greet us. We certainly didn't know this was a pickup only place. Got the food right away, paid a very fair price for the 4 twelve inch sandwiches ($37). Everything went very smooth and great. We picked 4 different sandwiches and every single one of us rated it a 5 star ⭐ for food, courtesy, pricing, and service. I had a delicious eggplant parmigiana, others had awesome cheese steak, special cheese steak, and Italian.The back draw: place is small and obviously cannot handle more so it will be like this for a while;however for improvement a couple of chairs and a table outside will make it a better appealing.“

4.3 Superb11 Reviews
Armetta's Pizzeria & Pub Pizza • $
2092 PA-848, New Milford

Customers` Favorites

One Slice New York Style White and One Slice Plain
1 2 NY Style White 1 2 Palermo Pizza
Italian Hoagie Extra Cheese Pizza
Steak Cheese Peppers Stromboli
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Grilled Chicken Salad
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Garlic Parmesan Wings
Palermo Pizza Slice
Gibson Surf and Turf

“Nice and quiet spot on a Tuesday afternoon. Grilled chicken salad with the house garlic dressing was delicious. Sicilian pizza slice was a tad messy but it was still tasty and hot. Kat was a great server, very nice and accommodating with my weird requests. Definitely going to pop back in on my next trip to the area.Kid-friendliness: I did not have children with me but saw plenty in the restaurant.“

3.6 Good37 Reviews
Original Italian Pizzeria & Restaurant Pizza • $
401 Grow Ave, Montrose - 7.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Pepperoni & Broccoli
Salad and Veal Parmigiana
Side Salad Dressing
Chicken Parmigiana
Sausage Parmigiana
Ravioli and Pizza
Gluten Free Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Salad
Sausage Pizza

“Start off with the food. I think the food is really good. The house bread it is a clean place to eat. Prices are not bad. This place I highly recommend having a meal at. It's my favorite place in town to eat. Thanks for the nice experience, W. Slater“

4.4 Superb63 Reviews
Little Ireland Brewing Co Brewpubs • $
1260 E Main St, Susquehanna - 8.09 miles

“I have not been in the town of Susquehanna in over 50 years. I made friends with an individual that resided there. Who has since pasted on, we met while both attending a trade school during the early 1970's. I had a few fun weekends with his friends and family there.This town is a quaint place, I'm guessing it was like so many towns in north eastern Pennsylvania. A coal mining town that thrived during the day's when coal was king.The Little Ireland Brewing Co. came up while looking for a restaurant to get something to eat and a beverage. This is a great little place for just such a stop. Prices are reasonable and it's an on-site micro brewery. So if your looking for a quaint restaurant bar, with a caffee layout, highly recommend you check it out. Also this town has a beautiful railroad train station that is serious need of being restored, and put to use. Jim Thorpe is a perfect example of what to do with a train station and town like this place.“

4.7 Superb7 Reviews
Iron Tracks Brewing Company Brewery • $
1260 E Main St, Susquehanna - 8.1 miles

“We've been wanting to stop at Iron Tracks ( love the new name!) but were never in the area until today. We tried 4 different pints and all were excellent. The food was very good, reasonably priced and Justin was super knowledgeable about the beer, the food and the area! Great conversation about lots of stuff, even about pool! ?“

4.3 Superb15 Reviews
Conrad's Pizza Pizza • $
1338 E Main St, Susquehanna - 8.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tenders
Garlic Knots
Stromboli
Pizza
Mac

“I absolutely love their pizza, we go there all the time. Its the only pizza my 5 year old grandson asks for and the only pizza my 9 year old son will eat. No one else around even comes close to having even decent pizza, so we're grateful to have the best. People there are friendly and super good with the kids!“

3.9 Good9 Reviews
Tedeschi's Pizza • $$
25066 US-11, Hallstead - 6.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Classic Smash Sandwich
Traditional Stromboli
Mozzarella Sticks
Doz Garlic Knots
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken Jessica
Cheesesteak
Italian
Philly

“The food was great, and our server Maddi B did a great job and was happy to serve us. However, the manager on duty Ryan was making comments in the back about us showing up 30 minutes before closing. He also made another comment when another customer showed up 10 minutes before closing. Overall a good experience but Ryan put a bad taste in my mouth with his comments and his attitude towards the other customer.“

4 Good53 Reviews
Loading...
map Map