9 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Milford

“Great food! Best pizza around! Fair prices!“

“We stopped by Hot Pies during a road trip through PA. I can’t emphasize enough how great this place was! Local pizzeria with fantastic pricing, and the foods to die for. I ordered a cheesesteak with mushrooms and onions, and no exaggeration it was one of the best cheesesteaks I’ve ever eaten in my life, and I eat a lot of cheesesteaks. My girlfriend got two slices of pizza (Sausage & Pepperoni) & the employee ensured to ask if she wanted a middle or corner slice - the slices were great too.

Food is 10/10, people are friendly and it’s clear the community loves this local spot. If you’re coming through the area I’d highly recommend stopping.“

“Recently moved up here from philadelphia. The land of Fantastic Pizza. But I have to say that I ordered a pizza from here last week and it was one of the best pizzas I'd ever had. So thrilled to have such a great pizza place 5 minutes down the road. Well done.“

“THIS place was the best food I have eaten out in a very long time. Almost 4 hours later and my mouth still is salivating over the roast beef and mash potatoes and gravy and the price was cheaper then McDonald's. $30 bucks for 2 excellent meals. Perfect portions with no left overs. My friend has the Salisbury steak and it looked amazing and she said it was incredible. Thank you to our excellent waitress as well. So friendly and attentive. We may stop back in for breakfast on the way home. A must stop at for a bite.“

“My husband and I had lunch there on March 19. The food was fantastic. I had a Ceaser salad with chicken that was HUGE. Real grilled chicken, fresh romaine, lots of shredded parm on top and a small loaf of fresh warm bread that was included. Absolutely delicious. Enough for two meals. Hubby got wings that were jumbo and actually got 12 and not 10 like some other places. Crispy and not too hot. We got a pizza to go and that was great as well. Highly recommend.“

“This place is in an awesome area. It mostly sells beer, ice, etc.

Say Hello to George, he has been here almost 50yrs. He knows the area and the history.

This is a vanishing part of the greatness of America.“

“I am beyond impressed with how amazing this place is. From the service to the food, this place has changed in the best way possible! Kelsey was the best waitress!“

“I brought a group of 20 cyclists here yesterday after doing the D&H Trail. Everyone was happy with the food and service. It was an integral part of the whole D&H Trail experience.“

“For a Friday night, we were greeted with nothing but smiling faces! We arrived about 10 minutes early, so we definitely weren’t expecting our order to be ready quite yet. They let us know our pizza would be about another 10 minutes, and they went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of while we waited—even offering us a dessert!

Not only did the young lady behind the counter apologize for the wait, but the pizza chef himself came out and apologized as well. That kind of customer service really says a lot.

They truly went above and beyond! We absolutely LOVE the atmosphere, and you can tell that every single person working there genuinely wanted to be there and was happy to be there.

Great food, great people, and an amazing atmosphere. We’ll absolutely be back! 🍕“