12 Best Bar & Grill near New Salem Borough

1 The Sherwood Inn

4.1 Good 366 Reviews

305 North Main Street, New Salem Borough

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“After driving past this place for 40+ years, we finally stopped in tonight for drinks and dinner! We got a table on the deck and lucked into a fabulous server, Christina! She was shocked we had never been there before but absolutely treated us like VIP regulars! If she is not training new hires, she should be! Food was great too! Super easy free parking, clean restrooms! Huge menu! We will definitely return and will request Christina for sure! Well done, Sherwood! 🤩❤️🎈”

2 The Cove

4.3 Superb 397 Reviews

1500 South George Street, York · 4.62 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The Cove has been one of our top 3 restaurants for years. No doubt I would still recommend them to anyone BUT we were there on Friday and I was SO disappointed. They changed their fries! They used to be so crispy and good, double fried (I'm guessing) in peanut oil. Now they're just ordinary. I'm not generally a big fan of fries, but I loved theirs. I so hope they bring them back! ❤️”

3 Goofy's Eatery and Spirits, Inc

4.4 Superb 220 Reviews

5965 York Road, Spring Grove · 6.61 miles

• Take-Out

“CARRY OUT REVIEW Locals know they serve to go breakfast sandwiches... now you do to! So go stop in, quicker than the gas stations and better quality too. Yes there are drinks that are for your workday cooler like Monster type drinks, sodas and WATER. The sandwiches are really delicious... and UNDER $5.00 WAIT DID YOU SEE THAT?!?! A SANDWICH FOR LESS THAM 5$ WITH CHEESE AND BACON!!! Plenty of parking in front to the carry out building. Easy in & out even when the traffic picks up. If you look at my reviews, I like local eats over big corporations.”

4 Lincoln Bar & Grill

4.1 Good 52 Reviews

701 West Market Street, York · 4.5 miles

• Delivery

“This is my third time rattling here, and every time the food has been of a high quality and priced well. Tonight I have a cold, so I am having the Chicken Soup and Greg, who prepares all the soups from scratch, had done an AWESOME job on the Chicken Soup! I've had the Steamed Clams twice, along with boiled shrimp...excellent! The Cheeseburger and Fries are perfect.”

5 PR's Bar-N-Grill

4.0 Good 119 Reviews

2350 North George Street, York · 7.25 miles

• Delivery

“nice place to hang with friends the bartenders are the best ❤”

6 Coomb's Tavern / Bones n Shells

4.0 Good 108 Reviews

2575 South Queen Street, York · 5.65 miles

• Take-Out

“Great food! But PLEASE stop up charging for using a MAC card. Your establishment is the only one doing this.”

7 The Vault Pizza & Grill

3.9 Good 261 Reviews

1990 Carlisle Road, York · 5.14 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I've been here a few times and have ordered out a few dozen times. The food here is good if not very good in my opinion. The Cheese Steak is very good especially on their Turnover bread. The only complaint is a couple of times I felt they under performed on the amount of cheese steak and toppings. The Fries are very good and I've always got nice hot salted just right. The Hamburgers are very good and big enough with fries to fill you up. The pizzas Ive had have been great as well and my girlfriend likes the Chicken, Bacon Ranch one the most and she is not a pizza person. Being from the Philippines she is more of fish eater than American Food. She also like their Chicken Cheese Steak again she doesn't eat red meat at all because in the Philippines she never really ate it, it was to expensive. They have a great selection of beer too, if you go to pick up a little early you can drink something while waiting. Long review but I wanted to get one out since I have always liked my food from there so far. I saw a few really bad reviews about the owner which shouldn't have much to do with their food. Order pickup and you won't even know who the owner is. People get drunk in bars and get kicked out then give a bad review since they evidently did something to draw the owners attention.”

8 Ripped Rabbit Bar & Grill

3.8 Good 44 Reviews

2650 Eastern Boulevard, East York · 7.89 miles

“My favorite bartender is Lauren”

9 Stone Grille & Taphouse

3.9 Good 413 Reviews

204 Saint Charles Way, York · 5.51 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We were visiting the area from New Hampshire and happened to stop at Stone Grille & Taproom—and we’re so glad we did! The food was excellent! My husband is a true foodie and, even more importantly, a serious soup snob. He ordered the French onion soup, his favorite, and absolutely loved it! Everything came out piping hot and quickly, and our server was attentive and friendly throughout our meal. It was such a lucky find during our visit. We would definitely recommend Stone Grille & Taproom and would happily stop back the next time we’re in the area!”

10 Bones-n-Shells

3.8 Good 321 Reviews

2575 South Queen Street, York · 5.79 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food! But PLEASE stop up charging for using a MAC card. Your establishment is the only one doing this.”

11 The Crabber

3.7 Good 141 Reviews

3086 South Queen Street, Dallastown · 7.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I don't get out as much as I'd like to, but I always have a great time seeing friends and hearing them sing. Food is great as well!”

12 Arooga's

3.4 Good 263 Reviews

1211 Haines Road, York · 6.86 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great service prices affordable”