21 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newmanstown

“These local/family owned Italian spots with good lunch are the heart and soul of SE rural PA. Justino’s is absolutely top tier. Based. Unequivocally BUSSIN if you will. They make their own homemade hoagie rolls, hand cut their French fries, and the lettuce and meats on the Italian I got were delicious and fresh tasting. Not to mention… their lunch special (1/2 cold sandwich, small fries (it’s a lot of fries), and a bottled drink…) is only $6. That’s crazy, right!? Def the spot for lunch if you’re in the area.“

“it's taken me awhile to visit Brandon at his spot but since I stopped 2 days ago, I want to go back for another sandwich. the bread was fresh , the meat was great , the pizza was just right, the conversation was endless. go visit. you won't be disappointed!!“

“The best pizza anywhere! I have been going to P&J's for the past 15+ years and Pete and John have put in the work to make sure that the quality of their food is second to none. We are enjoying a pizza with bacon, as well as a side order of sugar donuts as I write this. I cannot express just how good it is and how blessed this little town is to have a restaurant like P&J's. Extremely well done!“

“Stopped here for a quick, late dinner. The food was fantastic, service was great, and there were many gluten free options if you have a dietary restriction or preference. Would highly recommend the chicken cheesesteak (the sub rolls are fresh, soft, and incredibly good)!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options“

“Ordered for a work event. Placed the order online through the Slice App for pickup. Everything was done at the appropriate time and the food was delicious! HIGHLY recommend the meat stuffed pizza and Buffalo Chicken! Always good food and friendly service from Mancino's.“

“Tony always greets you with a smile and great food and drinks. I love that we can walk there if we want. It is a big part of the community.Parking: Location it steps away from the door. There is also a ramp if needed.Kid-friendliness: They are always happy and no minds the sound of a family enjoying a meal together.“

“Loved the pizza, especially the amount of toppings. Crust was the perfect thickness. Also recommend the salmon salad. Some of the lettuce wasn't great, but the grilled salmon made up for that!! Definitely want to visit this shop again! Our server was so sweet and kind, and quite attentive to our every need. Thank you! You folks have great service.“

“Katelyn Painter is always attentive and has our order memorized. We usually have the same meal, with the occasional change up! She is always polite and a great asset to TOSCO'S.Dietary restrictions: Thereis a cauliflower crust for those that have a gluten issue. Personally I have a digestive system that works very slow but TOSCO'S Pizza Dough , Rolls and TOSCO'S Pastas are all easily digested with no problems.You will not be disappointed in the food, service and atmosphere.Parking: There is 3 HANDICAP PARKING SPOTS andthere is 1 VAN ACCESSIBLE HANDICAPPARKING SPOT. The HANDICAP PARKING SPOTS are located next to the HANDICAP RAMP“

“Had the meatball sandwich. Fresh homemade bread and very cheesy just wish meatballs had more seasoning. Pizza we ordered is also very tasty. We asked cook to make a Stromboli with meatballs, cheese, and spaghetti noodles. My boyfriend loved it. New item possibly in the future on the menu.“

“I've been here 2 times, and both were wonderful experiences. I come during lunch break for their lunch specials, and the food is wonderfully priced. Last time, I got their burger and fries lunch special (burger and fries, no drink included) for 8$ and was not expecting as many fries to be filling the container that they gave me. I would recommend ordering ahead of time if possible, though.“

“Was out with friends to the Christmas village. We were hungry afterwards and this was the only place near us that was open. We aren’t from around this area and drove 3hrs to get here.The pizza shop was once a barn and it’s tucked back in the middle of no where.Service was good, food was good. Glad we stopped. If you’re in the area and looking for a place, check them out.“

“We just happened to stumble upon this place when we had trouble with our tour bus. While our bus was being serviced at Elite Bus.The owner and his wife were just opening and were able to accommodate 49 people. Just the two of them. Food was great and they made us feel so welcome. Great job!“

“Tosco’s has amazing food. I’ve never purchased anything that I didn’t like. A few weeks ago they accidentally gave me the wrong Stromboli. The manager immediately fixed it by offering me a free one next time I come in (it was too late to take it back because we were already back home).“

“We always get delivery and everything is delicious. I love their chicken alfredo. Our last encounter, we had time to dine in for a quick snack. It was our first time there. Very clean and welcoming shop, friendly workers. We got cheese fries and breaded cauliflower. We've had the cauliflower before and love it. Cheese fries were good, personally too much cheese but that's better than not enough. We were there at closing time and they offered us a few free slices so they wouldn't go to waste. We were shocked. We love Bella Pizza.“

“Visited there a lot on and off for a few years now. Their pepperoni rolls are quite good. I've had the pizza there and it's also very good. Recently I've been getting cheese steaks with their lunch special. Great every single time and generous portions, especially for the price.The service is impeccable. They go above and beyond to make sure you're happy. I really want to stress how good it actually is. The atmosphere itself isn't anything very special. It's small, but it's very clean and gets the job done. The parking is also a bit sparse, but it's to be expected since it's a smaller place.I recommend their lunch specials. Can't beat a large sandwich, a while lot of fries, and a drink for under $10. Better than fast food and you get a lot more for your money.“

“I recently had the pleasure of interacting with Todd and I must say, my experience was nothing short of exceptional. Todd's professionalism and expertise were evident from the moment I walked in. He was not only incredibly knowledgeable about the products and services, but also displayed an exceptional level of kindness and thoughtfulness that truly set him apart.Todd makes dominoes so great!What stood out the most was Todd's ablity to understand my needs and rovide tailored solutions, ensuring a seamless and satisfying experience. His attentive and courteous demeanor made me feel valued as a customer. The level of detail and care he put into addressing my queries and concerns was remarkable.In a world where customer service often falls short, Todd's commitment to excellence was a breath of fresh air. His passion for his work and dedication to customer satisfaction were evident in every interaction. It's rare to come across someone who not only excels in their role but also genuinely cares about making a positive impact on customers' experiences.I would highly recommend Todd to anyone, thanks to the outstanding service provided by Todd. His exceptional skills and warm personality truly enhance the overall quality of this establishment. Kudos to Todd for making my visit memorable and exceeding my expectations in every way.“

“We are so happy to have the original owners back the best people ? HER PEPES SPECIAL CHEZZE STEAK IS HANDS DOWN BETTER THAN ANY GUS CHESSE STEAK AND PEPES PIZZA HAS ? ? FREE FRENCH FRIES ? ON FRIDAYS WITH any SUB you order only on Friday it's worth the drive ? God bless“

“We were there on a Saturday at 4pm and we had a party of 11. Some had been there before but most had never been there. Everyone was very impressed with the portions and also how good everything tasted. Our waitress was Becky and she was awesome. She was on the ball with everything and and we didn't have to ask for anything because she remembered everything. I would highly recommend Riviera's Pizza & Italian Restaurant to everyone and ask for Becky if she's available.Parking: There is plenty of parking in the 2 lots they haveKid-friendliness: Kid menu had good choicesWheelchair accessibility: All on 1 floor“

“Had this place as a kid back in ‘10 when they were in Wernersville. We always thought they just shut down. Randomly thought about it today and come to find out they were here all along! 30 min drive was totally worth it. 10/10. Cheeseburger sub is just how we remembered! We‘ll be back for sure!“

“Honestly BEST Family owned and operated Pizza and Italian restaurant I ever been at many times. Wish they delivered further but worth it for the great flavor and friendly family atmosphere.Kid-friendliness: Very friendly family they make everybody feel welcome even children and they do have a children’s menu“

“My husband and I are sitting here, while I write this review. The food was delicious, the ladies whom took our order were beyond friendly and just so kind and had a smile while taking our order. I will be coming back here and will bring my boys with me. Thank you ladies for delicious pizza and subs, for having an amazing attitude with us and for making my birthday lunch special even tho we did not mention it! Thank you again!“