11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lititz

“Love the food and the service. The mini Hawaiian boli, AWESOME.“

“Love their pizza, The Party, party is the best deal they have to buy when you got a big family.“

“We just happened to stumble upon this place when we had trouble with our tour bus. While our bus was being serviced at Elite Bus.The owner and his wife were just opening and were able to accommodate 49 people. Just the two of them. Food was great and they made us feel so welcome. Great job!“

“Best gluten free pizza Ive ever had! I ordered the meat lovers and it had the perfect amount of toppings! This quickly became our favorite pizza place in town!“

“First time trying DiMaria’s and I’m already convinced they are one of the best options for Pizza around!Let me just start with how nice it is to place an order to go on the phone and that order be EXACTLY what you wanted. There is ordering online as well as an option as well.The pizza was HOT AND FRESH and the wings were absolutely fantastic. As a wing enthusiast, I always show appreciation when they are cooked to my liking (I requested extra crispy/ well done).All we tried were the pizza and wings but it was convincing enough to make it not be a one-and-done situation. We will 1000% be back.P.s. the staff were super nice and welcoming.“

“Really good food from this place. Pizza is always tasty and they give you giant jalapeño poppers instead of the tiny ones most restaurants use. I usually get delivery through grubgub but calling in your order I think is best. Had a delivery snafu recently that customer service fell well below expectations, but the managing partner Grant called me and fixed everything, which was greatly appreciated.“

“I'm not sure what's going on at Nino's and it's the first time I've been there in some time. However, the one entrance is blocked off and you can't get in that way.

The lasagna dinner which I ordered with the garlic bread was quite honestly very very salty and when I got it home I did eat it reluctantly however, the noodles were also undercooked as well and I've been going across the street to their competitor romas which is much better.

However, I do like Nino's bread and pizza better than Roma's and Nina's subs are actually better as well, but it's personal preference

By the way, I will not leave a tip if I have to go in order my food and take it home with me. That's nonsense and just like most restaurants there is a area to automatically leave it tip and it's nothing on Nino's at all. It's just on the restaurant industry in general“

“Christina is the best!!!!“

“On August 6 2024, I was picking up an order from this Papa John's as soon as I came in I was greeted by Anthony and Brandon. They told me my order would be ready in three minutes. I came out to my car and saw I had a flat tire. I went inside and asked if either one of them had a jack in their vehicle. Brandon, let me use the jack from his car. So I could get the flat tire off of mine. As I was working on getting the tire off, I was starting to feel really hot and tired. So I went inside Anthony gave me a wet paper towel so I could put on my neck they let me sit inside so I could cool down. After I got the tire on Brandon let me use his tire pump so I could put air in my spare tire. These young gentlemen went above to help me out when they didn't have to. I really appreciate their help.“

“Absolutely DELICIOUS Pizza!! I found myself out this way when I typically never am, and was starving. I know I like the Caruso's near me, so I stopped here for a slice. The atmosphere is beautiful, not what I was expecting. I was nervous bc typically the shops I go to have their slices out on the counter and I can just pick & choose. The misses behind the counter explained that they have cheese pizza in the back & they just add the toppings per request. I got 1 slice of Buffalo chicken with ranch drizzled, and a slice of pesto.
I bit into the pesto first and THE CRUNCH! from the crust was amazing, I literally felt my heart flutter ?? Finished that, started on my buffalo chicken. Fresh, generous portions of chicken on another crunchy but not over cooked crust. I loved Caruso's already, but I could see myself driving out of the way for whoever these chefs are. SO SATISFYING ? & to top it all off, I'm pretty sure they gave me an extra slice! Idk if it was because they were closing soon, or I just looked pathetic bc I was so hungry LOL jk. Either way, this is a great spot for pizza and by the way the crust was cooked, I bet everything else is delicious as well.“

“Nino made a special family dinner extra special. The food was delicious as we've come to expect. The quality and quantity were terrific. All of this was wrapped around warm and attentive service making the evening a very memorable one. I highly recommend Piccolo's!“