10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newtown Square

“From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The food is outstanding—everything from the authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, with its perfectly charred crust and rich, flavorful sauce, to the homemade pasta and classic Italian dishes was absolutely delicious. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients, and the flavors speak for themselves. But what really made our night special was the amazing service at the bar, thanks to Nick and Jack. These two are hands-down some of the best bartenders in Newtown Square! Not only are they knowledgeable about cocktails, wine, and beer selections, but they also make every guest feel like a regular. Their energy, professionalism, and attention to detail set them apart. Whether you’re looking for the perfect craft cocktail or just great conversation, Nick and Jack make the bar experience at Carmine’s unforgettable. If you’re in the Newtown Square area and looking for delicious Italian food, a great bar, and top-tier service, Carmine’s is the place to go. We can’t wait to come back!“

“The absolute best food and service we had in a long time 8 persons at our table and every meal got A great feed back. We will definitely make this our restaurant of choice!“

“Tonight we had a mistake with our order. I called the restaurant and spoke with two people who could not have been nicer and more apologetic. I cannot thank them enough for making the order right and the best part, the food was delicious!

Everyone makes mistakes from time to time, but not everyone quickly rectifies them. Thank you, we will be calling again!“

“Wonderful people and great staff!“

“Best food in town by far, & the service is 5-star“

“Is mod pizza the best pizza around.....no....BUT it's always there when you need a trusty, reliable and affordable friend. I appreciate the fact the staff is always kind. Newtown Square is a wasteland, so why not support this friendly buisness who in my experience put it's customer first. Also yay plant based sausage!

Bonus points for satisfying my brazilian husband who always wants 16 toppings on a pizza without having to mortgage the house.“

“I love this place! Everyone's always so friendly and the food is always so delicious! Definitely recommend!“

“U don't know what quality level U will get from day to day. Some of those young kids that work there don't care & it's going to have a negative impact on the business in the future.“

“This place is a must and their food is fantastic. We moved near them about a year ago and every time we order it's always the best. The food is always fresh and very tasty. The owner as well as her staff are very friendly and accommodating. We have ordered pizza, sandwiches, hoagies, hoagie trays and everything was delicious. Their delivery service is always on time and they make sure that you get your order. Please don't believe any negative review as this place is the best and you have to try it for yourself. You can thank me later! Marc“

“We attended a Holiday party there, we were blown away by the atmosphere, food and staff“