15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Nicholson

“Had the Margherita, Quattro Fromaggio, and Plain pizzas (a slice of each). They were all good. Soft dough, sweet sauce. Generous with the cheese. They DO NOT deliver. Someone posted on Google that they had contact-free delivery, but they only offer pick-up. I would say the pick-up is definitely worth it if your drive is less than 30 minutes. The person answering the phones was very understanding about that confusion.“

“Always love the friendliness of the staff, the prices & taste of the food. It keeps me coming back. The staff are always very sweet to my dog when I walk down. For a small deli they have a great range of homemade food and a variety of other items they sell.“

“Decent NY style pies, great toppings menu. Their hoagies are always good. My only issue is the delivery charge; I (and everyone should) tip their drivers and servers to provide them a respectable living.But, Rosario’s has good pizza, and a wide variety of sandwiches and entrees.Support local!“

“Excellent is not a big enough word. The food is awesome...first time trying the pizza and wings. The best around. I can't wait to go back! I'll travel the extra distance to come back to this place...and they have three locations so they are obviously doing something right.“

“Fantastic & accommodating people! On Thanksgiving day, hours after the main event meal was over, my 5-year-old was hungry. We were renting a nice lake house at Acre Lake for the holiday, so although we had TONS of Thanksgiving leftovers, there was nothing other than that for him to eat.I remembered the pizza at Acre Lake Store nearby was good, so I tentatively called to see if they were open. They were! Although they were only serving Thanksgiving dinner, I hoped they could maybe sell me something he would eat. The woman on the phone that I spoke to was extremely helpful, & suggested a few things. We ended up getting bread, cheese, & butter to make grilled cheese for him. Evening saved! She even added a bag of macaroni, which he ate as well. Great experience, nice people - above & beyond experience.“

“Was in the area for work and found this place online as the closest so decided to try it out. Called my order in and actually enjoyed ordering. The guy was super cool and very positive sounding over the phone (hard to describe). Got to the place for pickup and it was in a gas station with the guy who took my order being the only guy who does everything there M-F.Order was for two pizzas, some Death Fries, and pizza rolls (“pizza rolls” was a calzone! ?). Food was great. I wrecked the fries in their entirety on my way back home and I’m sitting here now knocking this pizza down. Great service, great food!“

“just because it's the only spot in town doesn't mean you're settling! get ready for a good time! a friendly reminder that local bars have charm and charisma you just can't find anywhere else. they got a pool table for groups and a gambling machine for the solo visitor. and an electronic jukebox too! chairs and tables inside, and a fireplace warming the place in winter, make a cozy, intimate gathering place for all members of the local community. the great food is made upstairs and handed down to the bartender through a hole in the floor. wing nights can't be missed. tables and chairs and smoking being a social activity makes hanging outside fun and relaxing. excited to see they do carry the much anticipated arizona hard iced tea in all three flavors! highly addictive i must say.“

“Never been disappointed with any of our orders in almost 20 years of ordering here. our #1 pick for pizza and wings in PA.Parking: some pothole repairs needed at entrance but easy to enter/ exit and park.Kid-friendliness: games for kids to play, staff is very friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: easy wheelchair access, no stairs.“

“Heard a lot about the pizza from a co worker . Finally took the wife to give it a try. It was really good. The crust bottom was done perfect. And not burnt. And it had a nice crispness to it. Not like some pizzas that are soggy. I can’t wait to go back and try a cheesesteak. I don’t think I will be disappointed. I highly recommend.“

“I ordered 3 medium pizzas and 2 sides. When I got there they had only made 2 pizzas. I asked about my 3rd pizza and they realized they didn't make it, do they took the food back to keep it warm, made the pizza and gave it to me for free.Great customer service here!“

“Staff was super friendly. Had chicken bacon ranch pizza and was very good! Also had mild wing bites and they were very good as well! First time here last week. Have heard good things about their wing bites and hot wing pizza. Maybe next time. ??‍♀️“

“There’s a reason Dinos has been around for nearly 5 decades. Their pizza is the best. Thin, Neapolitan style foldable crust with fresh tomato sauce that is neutral in taste, not too sweet, topped with flavorful mozzarella cheese.Parking: Parking is available in front of the establishment, handicap parking is available in the first row.Kid-friendliness: They offer all American foods like pizza and chicken.Wheelchair accessibility: The entrance is flat with no stairs.“

“I had a slice of their Cheeseburger-in-paradise pizza and it was one of the best slices I've ever had.Dough and crust was cooked to perfection and the housemade sauces on the pizza were to die for.Can't wait to go back for a full tray!“

“Sorry guys, I ordered steak and cheese with mushrooms. The employee was very nice and the restaurant very comfortable. I brought the sandwich home with a beverage only to find no cheese, and no mushrooms. Truly disappointing based on how others have raved about the place.4/30/24Changing my review. The owner reached out and was very receptive to correcting the error. Definitely great business practices here!!“

“Review 6/5 their hospitality and setting are pofessional and have the ettiqute to be defined as excellent they will always have good feed back when I leave this comment. Fresh Food that is brought the NEPA if your're visiting this part of our community join the people who bring wholesome happiness and defining real Italian food and it's attribute of the environment to join them with their prescene!“