50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Old Forge

“We ordered from here last week , had my sons Birthday and ordered 3 pies , Absolutely loved it , Pizza was very tasty , tho it looked light on top the crust was excellent crisp to it , 7 Italians in one room and it is rare that we all loved the same place , but we did , My main Pizza place to order from weekly now , . Thanks to whole staff and owner for making my sons Birthday a great dinner ❤️❤️❤️“

“I was having problems ordering online so I went to the Old Forge location and Alexis the manager was quick to assist and help us.She is very sweet and helped us out.“

“Our favorite of The Old Forge pizza restaurants. They only do “takeaway”. The white is perfect and the red is also delicious. Could not be nicer servers. They have a bocce court and also a rental hall. At the “takeaway” store they offer a variety of Italian cuisine specialties.“

“first time here tonight based on my dates recommendation..very happy with our dinners and the service..I got the gnocchi with meat sauce and she got a chicken caesar salad I believe..both large portions . Will definitely be back“

“Great food, fast and friendly service. Never disappointed. Wings rock!“

“Fantastic place! Super nice server, plus the owner stopped by to go over some choices. We ordered toasted ravioli, rosemary chicken, veal and peppers(all excellent) and the home run of the evening, manicotti made with a crepe. Pricing was moderate/low, for the quality.

Parking: Parking in rear.“

“Great food ! Love the antipasto , ravioli , gnocchi , calamari & pizza“

“Ordered from las vegas. Everything was perfectly packaged and fresh. Great customer service. Quality was as we remembered it. It was great to have a taste of home. Will definitely order again“

“Teberios Restaurant is a great place to go and eat your dinner, They have great Pizza & the Hot Chicken Wings is very YUMMY ! the Hot Sauce is Delicious ?!! The Employees are real nice to talk to !! It's a great place to go after a hard day !“

“Since moving to the area in September I finally got around to trying the pizza here this last weekend and I can’t believe I waited so long. The pizza was delicious and the wing bites were great as well. Definitely recommend trying them!“

“The crabcakes are absolutely amazing!!!!!! Thank you so much!“

“best slice of square I've had in a long time! bottom is airy crispy and lite. sauce is what you want on a square sweet seasoned and buttery. 10/10 reccomend. I will be back with friends!! Worth the drive!!“

“As I’m sure you can tell Jamie Kennedy is trying to tear a good business down. The truth is her boyfriend worked for us for two weeks but we found him on drugs so we had to let him go. Every business goes through this at some point unfortunately“

“great hoagies. a variety of items for last minute items quick service“

“Good place in town nice people.“

“Shandra’s is a staple for our family and we are never disappointed.“

“pizza was delivered super fast...out of the oven blazing hot..and delicious!!! Great service. Definitely my go to place from now on. !!“

“Good food and service is nice“

“Always great food and service“

“The best chocolate chip cookie I have ever had
Nice staff
For the chalkboard wall I would recommend them to get the color black so if people make a mistake or if you are making a pizza that might want to put a black olive on it

Kid-friendliness: Vary nice staff and a big chalk wall“

“Very good pizza and wings! I should have tried it sooner! Will definitely be ordering again. Thank you!“

“Consistent and delicious always. Best pizza in Dickson! Highly recommend the hot wing pizza.“

“Ordered a steak n cheese Stromboli for pickup yesterday and I couldn’t wait to eat it! It was delicious!! They opened at 12 noon and I was able to order online for that exact pickup time. The staff was quick, super friendly & polite!! Can’t wait to go back again!!! Thank you Armetta’s!!“

“Friendly staff, clean shop, and really great food. I had an outstanding chicken parm sub. Lightly toasted, melty cheese, properly cooked chicken, and really favorable sauce. It was packaged so it was still piping hot when I brought it home. Close to Hampton in & Hilton Garden Inn. It will be on my list of places to return to when I travel thru Wilkes-Barre.“

“10/18/24. I was visiting my sick Auntie in the area, and I decided to get something to eat b4 heading back to Jersey! Googled pizzerias and came across Serpico’s !!! A California cheesesteak and chicken tossed salad Later,I was full, satisfied, and impressed by the quality of of the food and the freshness of the of All the ingredients!!!! My NEW GO TOO SPOT when I’m visiting my Auntie!! Great Job Serpico Pizza ! God Bless the Staff….“

“Lemme just tell you, I wanna kiss Giuseppe right now! We ordered subs, wings and pizza and drove it back to Scranton. Everything was fire ?. How have I not eaten here before.? You guys got your s*** together, lemme tell you!! I'll be back, Jack!!“

“Very friendly and Unbelievable pizza & hoagies!!! I recommend the hot wing pizza!!! Omg its amazing well all their Speciality pizza's are amazing!! Their broccoli and cheese is also one of my favorites.....

Vegetarian options: Awesome Vegetarian Pizzas....“

“Great Place i ordered personal pizza and spicy thai wings. Excellent on both i used Slice App to order very easy to do. Its not the first time i ordered and wont be the last“

“I’ve been going to pizza plus since the late 80’s Still my favorite pizza“

“This is one of my favorite pizza places!! �“

“best red velvet cake I ever had“

“Napoli's is great especially when you're on a time crunch! They have several different kinds of slices available and service is fast and friendly. The dining area is super clean, and the pizza is great! Perfect place to pop in on lunch break. They have full pies available too but I love being able to just grab slices!“

“I happened upon Angelo's restaurant by chance and thought it was just a little pizza parlor but instead I found a cute little restaurant a wonderful atmosphere great service and excellent food. I would highly recommend this to everyone whether you're looking to have a quick bite or a leisurely dinner. Angelo's accommodates both. I will definitely be returning.“

“Excellent food had the pizza and wing bites. Would highly recommend“

“Great staff and quality food“

“Amazing service,prices,& the food was incredible!!!

Dietary restrictions: Tons of options= meets everyone's needs

Kid-friendliness: My son's favorite spot

Wheelchair accessibility: Very handicap accessible“

“Great food, customer service is owners middle name. Been a regular for years. Highly recommend :)“

“The atmosphere doesn't matter. Bc you take the pizza with you! My favorite pizza in the area for sure! Ordering one pie or ten pies! It's always perfect and that sweet sauce is the best! Also the pizza dough and crust is on point!“

“never been /but have had his Dad's food back in the day and he's got the recipe/ so I'm saying it is great“

“Hubs and I ordered a hoagie and cheesesteak stromboli today. Both were delicious! We highly recommend.“

“Just love the people and the food! You can't go wrong no matter what you order.“

“the stung honey bites are my absolute fav. with very generous portions“

“Hands down, the best cheese steaks and sausage and pepper parmasean subs in the area! Great round pizza too! I've been ordering here since my college days off the early 90s and they've remained consistently great down through the years.“

“The garlic bread cheesesteak-omg it's the best! and the apple cider martini- FANTASTIC! the bartenders, cook and owner are also all pretty amazing! keep up the great work!“

“Pizza Avenue just catered my nephews birthday party and everything was great. Thank you so much guys.“

“I just attended a retirement lunch there. The food and service was phenomenal. I would definitely recommend this place!“

“the sandwiches are hard to beat - unique names AND flavor combinations! Delicious!“

“I can't say enough great things about Colarusso’s La Palazzo! From the very start of planning to the day of the event, their responsiveness and kindness were unmatched. They went above and beyond to accommodate all our needs and added such a personal touch to everything. The food was absolutely delicious and exceeded all our expectations. We highly recommend this venue and will definitely be repeat customers for life! Thank you to you and your staff for making our event so special.🪼💙🥹“

“Last night I picked up a tray of pepperoni pizza at Maronis. I wish I took a picture of it. It was perfect. Better than a 10!!! And the picture would never outdo the taste. One of the best I ever had and we've been getting our pizza here for almost 5 decades. Hands down, over and over, consistently the best!!“

“Hands down one of my favorite places to eat REAL authentic Italian food . Never disappointed when I get my chicken calabrese from here !! Not many pull this flavor off and they can make it without sausage ( I don’t eat pork ) and didn’t make me feel Like they were annoyed .. My husband SWEARS by the Rigatoni and meat sauce and my kids will say they loved everything. So let’s just say we have never been disappointed!! This is your FRIENDLY FAMILY neighborhood restaurant the staff is AWESOME from the host to whomever is cooking your meal you will get a warm hello with that GREAT meal !!!“