50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Old Forge

“We tried their pizza for the first time today. The pizza is excellent. We went on pasta night. The pasta, meatballs and sausage are exquisite. Will definitely go back again! Well worth the trip.“

“Had to travel to Wilkes Barre, well worth the extra time to go to Old Forge. The classic red pizza tray was delicious, whole family loved it. Crust was perfect slightly crispy on bottom and great bread texture. The tomato and onion flavors are well balanced. The white pizza is also good, tons of cheese. Goes great with tomato soup the next day. Only slight issue was woody rosemary leaves on the white pizza, other seasonings are tasty. The kids enjoyed a quick game of bocce ball while the adults picked up the pizzas. Staff were friendly. Didn't get dessert this time but they're always delicious too“

“I was having problems ordering online so I went to the Old Forge location and Alexis the manager was quick to assist and help us.She is very sweet and helped us out.“

“first time here tonight based on my dates recommendation..very happy with our dinners and the service..I got the gnocchi with meat sauce and she got a chicken caesar salad I believe..both large portions . Will definitely be back“

“First time trying Club 17 tonight 3/17/23. Absolutely awesome. The red pizza was some of the best I’ve had in Old Forge. Light, crispy and flavorful sauce. The fresh tomato and garlic pizza was equally amazing. Super fresh ingredients and the garlic was the perfect amount. The star of the show for me though was the Rigatoni Abruzzi with hot sausage. It’s done in a light creamy tomato sauce with roasted red peppers, hot Italian sausage and just the right amount of chili flake. Everything was awesome and we got it to go. I’m sure it would be even better sit down in the restaurant which we will certainly be trying in the near future. Highly recommend.“

“Great food, fast and friendly service. Never disappointed. Wings rock!“

“If I had to have my last meal on earth it would be RIGHT HERE! The greatest food ever!“

“Ordered from las vegas. Everything was perfectly packaged and fresh. Great customer service. Quality was as we remembered it. It was great to have a taste of home. Will definitely order again“

“Teberios Restaurant is a great place to go and eat your dinner, They have great Pizza & the Hot Chicken Wings is very YUMMY ! the Hot Sauce is Delicious ?!! The Employees are real nice to talk to !! It's a great place to go after a hard day !“

“Ordered for the first time yesterday for lunch. The food I ordered was delicious and fresh with good quality ingredients. The guy that took my order was kind and patient which is appreciated and delivery was fast. Prices are reasonable as well. Great job D’Amore thanks again for the great food, service and delivery!“

“As I’m sure you can tell Jamie Kennedy is trying to tear a good business down. The truth is her boyfriend worked for us for two weeks but we found him on drugs so we had to let him go. Every business goes through this at some point unfortunately“

“Since moving to the area in September I finally got around to trying the pizza here this last weekend and I can’t believe I waited so long. The pizza was delicious and the wing bites were great as well. Definitely recommend trying them!“

“Just amazing Pizza. Headed to first time with sweet sauce and pepperoni. Out of this world. You must check his place out“

“Excellent fried Sicilian pizza. Loved the dough. Will be back!“

“Open broccoli pizza is amazing! It tastes better every time I get it!“

“Can’t imagine my day not starting with a breakfast sandwich and coffee from the deli ❤️“

“Hello, What a marvelous treat & surprise! Stopped in June 2, gnocchi special, marvelous! But the real treat was the most cordial, professional, amazing, friendly, & the list can continue❤️❤️👍 We met “Frankie” by far Northeastern Pennsylvania’s best of the best, Bartender! We are visiting from Flordia and we were welcomed by Frankie. Food great! Service above & beyond! I would encourage everyone to stop in great specials & Frankie is just warm & welcoming!😊😊😊😊👍👍👍👍 Sorry, I forgot to take pictures! We will return, highly recommend.“

“With no doubt Pizza by Pappas has the Best food in town! I am from Hershey and I always come here to eat they're specialties. The tuna sandwich and the Pizza are my favorites, you need to try!“

“Shandra's pizza never disappoints, always delicious. I recommend getting it with onion. Their buffalo bites are really good not to spicy and very tasty.“

“Great place to have an event! Family owned and operated and very accommodating for groups of any size. You must try the eggplant as one of your entree choices!“

“I just attended a retirement lunch there. The food and service was phenomenal. I would definitely recommend this place!“

“Good food and service is nice“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ If you haven’t had Demuros pizza, you’re seriously missing out. From the moment you walk in, you can tell they care about quality. The dough is fresh and handmade, the sauce has the perfect balance of sweet and savory, and the cheese is always melted just right. The cheese pull on the double crust white pizza is INSANE😍 Their pizzas come out hot, loaded with toppings, and cooked to perfection every time. You can actually taste the difference in the crust — it’s crisp on the outside, soft on the inside, and never greasy. Whether you’re grabbing takeout for the family or ordering delivery for a cozy night in, they make it easy and always get it right. The staff is friendly, the service is fast, and the prices are more than fair for the quality you get. Deals like two fresh, handmade medium pizzas for $19.99 make it a no-brainer. This is the kind of local pizza shop you want to support — consistent, delicious, and welcoming. Once you try it, it’ll become your go-to spot. It’s an absolute Pittston staple! Highly recommend! 🍕🔥“

“Lemme just tell you, I wanna kiss Giuseppe right now! We ordered subs, wings and pizza and drove it back to Scranton. Everything was fire ?. How have I not eaten here before.? You guys got your s*** together, lemme tell you!! I'll be back, Jack!!“

“We tried their Pagash today and it was amazing! Will definitely be getting again!“

“Back to the Beginning at Nicholas' Pizza. Thank you for taking care of my mom and me today. As I sat there, I thought about how we've been coming here for as long as I've been alive — and what feels like my mom’s whole lifetime. There's no other place that would support her, or us, the way you do. You always seem to lift her up — literally and figuratively. I truly appreciate all of you. Paul & Donna, you are the best.“

“Yep! It’s just like NYC pizza. I am glad to have found this place!!

The pizza is good, thin and crunchy. The sauce is on point and the cheese is good.

For me personally, cheese taste better than pepperoni slice. I have yet to try anything else but do plan on continue visits and try many other things. Wait on the updates.

The place is clean, the condiments are organized and the restroom were clean.

The customer service is ok.“

“Really REALLY good pizza.
This place seems to be strictly take-out. There's nowhere to sit. Really hooe-in-the-wall that makes great, thin, NY style pizza.
No fancy toppings, no bs.

For the full experience get 1 sweet sauce and 1 savory sauce pies. If you really wanna hit it - put them one on top of the other and give it a bite 🔥“

“Friendly staff, clean shop, and really great food. I had an outstanding chicken parm sub. Lightly toasted, melty cheese, properly cooked chicken, and really favorable sauce. It was packaged so it was still piping hot when I brought it home. Close to Hampton in & Hilton Garden Inn. It will be on my list of places to return to when I travel thru Wilkes-Barre.“

“We ordered the Gramma Sicilian tonight.....Excellent!! The crust was perfection! The blend of sauce, cheese and pesto was the best Gramma pizza I've ever had. The gentleman who handled my order was so welcoming and friendly also! Thank you!“

“Tried for the first time last night and everything was delicious!!!! Will definitely be back!!!“

“I order the pizza every Thursday. It is super dee duper delicious!! Hot or cold! Can't go wrong with this place“

“Cara Mia’s catered our daughter’s graduation party this past weekend and they were fantastic to work with. From ordering to delivering-the communication was awesome. And the food was absolutely delicious. Lots of compliments-will definitely be using them again in the future. Thank you!“

“never been /but have had his Dad's food back in the day and he's got the recipe/ so I'm saying it is great“

“Walked through door and greeted immediately with a hello and smile. Super clean and cozy atmosphere. The wings were amazing and the pizza was just as amazing. The owner was very personable and had no issue when we asked for extra crispy last minute. They go above and beyond. Next trip in from Florida I will definitely be back. My new pizza and wing place. Definitely give this place a try. You won’t regret it. Thank you for making our dining experience enjoyable.
Denise, Evelyn and Cindy.“

“Best Pagash in town! Light and crispy dough with a beautiful cheese blend and nicely seasoned potatoes!“

“I really liked the Old Forge style pizza. It was delicious with cooper cheese. The taco was good too! Got the street style taco. I wouldn’t go back for the taco, but for the pizza 100%. Cashier was very nice. This was my first time going and won’t be the last.“

“I was just here last Friday. I was here about 15 years ago. I liked it then and it might even be a little better now. GREAT N.Y. Style Pizza! Try some Wings too. Good stuff. Next time I go in I will try Tacos. Give them a shot. Very reasonable Prices too. ❤️“

“The sausage and pepperoni pizza is outstanding and to top that, the garden salad is about the best around! The “small” is more than enough for 2 people. The prices here are surprisingly reasonable, as well. This place should be packed!“

“Absolutely delicious Sicilian. 6 cuts red with onion never disappoints.“

“The food is alway good. I've never had a bad experience.“

“Great food, customer service is owners middle name. Been a regular for years. Highly recommend :)“

“food is phenomenal, we got the gourmet pizza, and let me say the BBQ bacon is sooo good. The pizza is still the same and great.“

“The woman who answered the phone was very pleasant to order with. The pizza was so good! That’s all I ordered but I am excited to try more from this place! Very reasonably priced. We enjoyed our Pagash and Shrimp & Hot Pepper Pizza 🙂“

“Excellent food had the pizza and wing bites. Would highly recommend“

“Great pizza! Get it at work occasionally and never disappointed.“

“Napoli's NEVER disappoints. This is genuinely the best restaurant, and it's owned by the BEST family. Authentic Italian food, and you can tell. Always always always handcrafted perfectly. You don't see many authentic Italian restaurants anymore... but this one? The BEST. Anyone who tells you different has lost their mind.“

“Our new favorite pizza place! The sweet sauce is delicious. Their wings and hoagies are really good, too. Inexpensive and a great value for your money. And their customer service is top notch!! 🍕“

“I will die with this pizza in my mouth“

“Just love the people and the food! You can't go wrong no matter what you order.“