18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Orangeville

“Pleasant to order from and the food is very good! We will be back.“

“Service was quick, friendly, and direct. It's a little small, but extremely clean with some of the best pizza I've ever had (that's saying quite a bit for me). I ended up getting a pepperoni and a veggie slice while I was there, soft fluffy crust with a good crunch to it, couldn't leave without a stromboli and a slice of their sweet pizza. I've been through the area quite often, but usually don't have much time to stop, definitely going to try and work on making more time when I can now that I know this place is here.“

“Pizza is delicious!! They have sweet sauce !!“

“Excellent establishment. Extremely friendly staff and the food is amazing. I always get the chicken cheesesteaks with amazing bread. I recently got their wings and they were the best!! Delicious!“

“Go for the specialty pizzas—the “Sweet Sauce” and the “Special T” get standout shout‑outs“

“I love their hoagies and I tried fried pierogies, which were scrumptious.
Yesterday May 31,2024 I placed an order for delivery. I ordered a chef's salad and a child's chicken finger meal. The fries were terrible. They were raw in the middle. I tried to fry them, but whatever oil they used made me ill just smelling it and they tasted terrible. But the chef's salad was wonderful. Fresh ingredients were used. That was the best I ever had from Berwick OIP!“

“Made two orders for motzerella sticks. Showed up 15 minutes later, employees are sitting around and never started them. Place is also inconsistent in the quality of preparing and cooking their food.“

“Food was incredible! Some of the best I’ve had while visiting the area!“

“Great weekday buffet! Awesome food, friendly owner, all around terrific place.“

“I'm from Long Island, NY and when I first moved to Columbia County, PA I tried to find a pizzeria that reminded of the NY pizza I grew up with. Finally found it after 8 years at Vito's. Amazing pizza and service. Prices are affordable. No complaints and would highly recommend.“

“I absolutely love Papa John's pizza. I wish they were available near me, though. They closed the two places that were available in two neighboring areas. For this reason, whenever we are out of our area, we always look on maps to see if there are any we can go to get this awesome pizza. We always get the thin crust. Yummmmm and don't forget to get extra seasoning packets!“

“Personally I like little Caesars pizza. But this past summer I was working at a fair and a couple of days I got the hot and ready for lunch. What I didn't eat I threw on the ground next to my trash can. I noticed after about 10 days nothing touched it. No birds, no stray cats, not even the ants were eating it. So that really concerns me now. And it was more then one pizza that I tossed the leftovers too“

“I had a cheesesteak and one to go for my Mom. Both were delicious. I also had them make me dinner to eat at a later date, chicken Alfredo and cheese with tortellini shells. The service was phenomenal. Thank you!“

“One of the employees went out of his way to call me and tell me that I overpaid. He insisted that it wasn’t a problem for him to cancel my takeout order and ring it up for half the price. That employee deserves a raise, and if he’s not already manager, he should be.“

“our family wanted to try something different. this place did not disappoint! the pizza was delicious and the stromboli was absolutely amazing! we will be ordering from here again !“

“Ordered 25 wings (which were a poor excuse for wings) 1/2 bbq & 1/2 mild luckily once I got back to the vehicle I checked them and I received plain wings with a small 1oz container of bbq sauce and mild sauce. Returned to the counter and they literally took the containers of sauces and poured them over the wings and handed them back to me. Unfortunately Naps is a joke anymore. Would not recommend.“

“Went in with my mom for dinner. New management greeted us. Bett, the manager was super friendly. Made sure we were happy with our order ( pizza was done PERFECT!) Best decision they could make was bring Bett in!!!! We will definitely be back!!!!!“

“In the past 6 weeks I have gone here several times with a group of people. Excellent food and service. So much food that everyone went home with enough food for another meal!! The food was deliciously prepared. Our waitress did an excellent job taking and delivering our orders. All of our food came out together ( for 16 people) I would highly recommend eating here.“