18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Orangeville

“Pleasant to order from and the food is very good! We will be back.“

“A+ Always!!..Never had anything bad..Garlic Knots are the best!..Sweet sauce pizza is 👌“

“Best Pizza around everything we have tried has been excellent. The people there always bring a smile to our faces. Wonderful caring and giving family and extended work family. Not just great food great experience.“

“Best wings. Been my favorite since day1.“

“Such a great place! Best pizza I’ve had in years! Also the best service I’ve had in years! Feels like being part of the family. LOVE that vibe!!!“

“If you’re looking for catering services, please keep OIP in Bloomsburg in mind! Extremely easy to work with, responsive to emails, thorough in explanations and recommendations, and accommodating to needs, in addition to having great food! Highly recommend ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I just came here to write a review on a server named Leanne (sorry if I spelled it wrong) We came in Friday night while it was dinner time and busy with a party of 13. We had 6 adults and 7 kids with 3 different checks. Our server, Leanne was amazing. She was friendly, quick, didn't miss a beat. Went back and forth between our two tables. Nothing was messed up and I was impressed. The food was amazing and so were the drinks as always. But our server made the night. She even tracked down tums when desperately needed at our table. Best experience!“

“Staff had amazing personalities! Small dining area but very nicely decorated and very clean . Food was amazing and pricing was reasonable . Only thing I’d change is the plates, they are huge and heavy , glad I would not want to be a waitress and Carry those all day .“

“I ate here 8-27-25 in the evening. Wow!!!! Made with LOVE. Simply put, the absolute best Papa Johns I've ever eaten at. PERIOD. And that's over a couple decades!!! The guy that made my Hawaiian Chicken nailed the extra add ons and it was perfect. So was the Oreo bites.“

“We were looking for a place to get pizza after Knoebels and found Vito’s. As a pizza snob from the Philly area this pizza was a great surprise. Well exceeded our expectations and was very good. I would highly recommend as the whole family enjoyed it as well. Well done Vito’s 👍“

“i got a great deal on uber eats pickup for a large custom stuffed crust pizza, got bbq sauce, pineapple, canadian bacon, and bacon, basically a deluxe hawaiian pizza, would normally have cost $20.50, but with deal it was only $6.98, only took 15 mins for them to prepare it, will definitely be back, pizza was perfect.“

“Made two orders for motzerella sticks. Showed up 15 minutes later, employees are sitting around and never started them. Place is also inconsistent in the quality of preparing and cooking their food.“

“I have been a long time customer of NAPS Pizza. Typically I order the same items, pizza, chicken cheese steak, or Stromboli. But, Today I found a hidden gem, when I ordered the turkey corn chowder 😋 I was extremely impressed and happy to find a new item to look forward to in the future. It comes with crackers, a bread stick and even a soup spoon.“

“I had a cheesesteak and one to go for my Mom. Both were delicious. I also had them make me dinner to eat at a later date, chicken Alfredo and cheese with tortellini shells. The service was phenomenal. Thank you!“

“I ordered from them more than three times for delivery, prize is cheap , my 3 toppings vegan pizza is 8.99 with delivery and tip and tax is less than $15. They even delivered it after 11pm and before midnight, so no complaints for such a good service, and my pizza tastes great every time.“

“Went in with my mom for dinner. New management greeted us. Bett, the manager was super friendly. Made sure we were happy with our order ( pizza was done PERFECT!) Best decision they could make was bring Bett in!!!! We will definitely be back!!!!!“

“I'd like to give a huge shout out to the guy at Little Caesars his name is Donald thank you for being kind to my family he deserves a raise he did his job very he was able to help us quickly identify when an order was messed up that we called the wrong location and then we ordered food and it was top quality food it was made precisely the way we liked it and his co-worker play worked very hard and to make sure as well that the food was made properly they both deserve a raise they did a very good job and they're very respectable young men“

“In the past 6 weeks I have gone here several times with a group of people. Excellent food and service. So much food that everyone went home with enough food for another meal!! The food was deliciously prepared. Our waitress did an excellent job taking and delivering our orders. All of our food came out together ( for 16 people) I would highly recommend eating here.“