Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop
$ • PizzaAbout Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop
Customers' Favorites
Buffalo Chicken
Italian Hoagie
Sicilian Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Steak Hoagie
Super Salad
Breadsticks
Pepperoni
Lamb
Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop Reviews
148 ratings
Share your opinion about Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop
I used to order at least twice a week. They burned my pizza this time and told me I could bring it back after I had someone bring it to me. Then told me the person picking up the pizza there was a big air hole so she just threw cheese on top to cover it. So 90 percent of my pizza was burned while 2 slices had uncooked cheese! Then I told them I wasn’t driving they just told me to put the pizza in the fridge and bring it back tomorrow. Terrible! Never again will they get my...read full review
First time ever eating here and OMG amazing!!! Will be back drove from Leechburg to get it well worth it!!
The chicken parm hoagie is literally chicken fingers with tomato sauce. Decent pizza though.
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 10PM |
Carol of Casey's Pizza Shop offers great service and food. Orders are ready promptly and surprisingly quickly, and the menu includes a variety of options such as pepperoni pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, Greek pizza with white sauce, steak hoagies, and meatball hoagies. The buffalo chicken pizza features crispy chicken cooked to perfection, and the meatballs are homemade. The sauce is exceptional, and the bread for hoagies is fresh. The shop has a charming atmosphere and is a great family pizza restaurant. Customers appreciate the friendly, welcoming, and warm staff who greet you with a smile and work quickly. The food quality is impressive, with pizza that isn't too greasy and has a soft, chewy crust. The Greek pizza with white sauce is the best pizza ever. Some customers have noted inconsistencies, such as a small pizza with sparse toppings or extra charges for debit card transactions. Overall, the restaurant's friendly service, fair prices, and variety of options make it a popular local spot.