Millie's Homemade Ice Cream

Driving through Pennsylvania we came across this delight of a place! Who doesn't love cold ice cream on a hot day?!

The ice cream was delicious and creamy! Staff was so friendly and fast!

One of the best ice-creams I have ever tasted. We got the blue cotton candy and the pina cola da. Both were excellent.

My best friend and I went here last night. Now I can't say that the workers were great as I think they were annoyed about having to put hot fudge and caramel on our ice cream. However, I still think the ice cream was super good. I got coffee break with hot fudge. It was very good and super worth the price. My best friend got the butter pecan ice cream with caramel. Overall, it was really good ice cream. The place itself was super cute too.

Delicious, adorable, and staff was so nice. We love it!

Incredible. The coffee flavor blew me away. Can't wait to go back.

THEY MAKE MY FAVORITE ICE CREAM AT THE GROCERY STORE AND 2ND STOREFRONT

The creamiest and most delicious ice cream, you literally cannot choose a “bad” flavor. I opted for the seasonal lavender and oh my, it is fantastic! How they made such an herbal flavor so creamy and delicious, I’ll never know, but I’ll continue enjoying! The young women who waited on us were very nice and efficient as well! Highly recommend!

Love this location, very sweet workers! My girlfriend and I go here all the time when looking for a sweet treat!

super cute decor and delicious ice cream vegan options!

We love Millie’s and my daughter says they have the best waffle cones in the world.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

12/14/24 Shadyside location:
We came into Millie’s for the first time and wasn’t impressed. The two girls working the front were by far the worst employees I’ve ever came across. They clearly wanted to close up early and get out of there. We came in around 9:00, and they told us we couldn’t put the chairs back down to sit in AFTER we just paid for our ice cream. We did it anyways, we’re paying customers. The chubby girl with glasses gave us dirty looks as we sat and ate. The ice cream was mediocre, the caramel topping tasted so bad and old. Probably won’t come back, especially to this location.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Incredible ice cream but the staff definitely take the cake. I recommend this location to anyone in the area! 100/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Really nice to take pints to go but also nice to get a scoop. High quality ice cream. Seemed like a fairly standard ice cream parlor setting (bright fluorescent lighting and linoleum faux wood flooring) so I didn't really want to stay to eat but I will get ice cream to go another time!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Millie's is my favorite ice cream shop. Always a line, but efficiently served. The servers that work there are absolutely the best.

Dietary restrictions: Has plenty of vegan options

Kid-friendliness: Kids friendly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream, Scratch-Made Waffle Cone, Sundae with Coffee Break Ice Cream and Chocolate Sauce, Dairy-Free Brownie Batter