Pesaro's Pizza

5424 Butler Street, Pittsburgh
(412) 681-8220

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ronny Cassinelli

THEY CANT REMEMBER TO MAKE YOUR ORDER ....CANT ANSWER THE PHONE AND THEY ALSO WONT REMEMBER TO MAKE YOUR ONLINE ORDER .... 4 TIMES THIS HAS HAPPEND

Dawn Walter (Dawn)

Food and service are great! We love pizza night!

Mercury Intergrade

Best regular normal pizza in pgh. When you think pizza, that's what they make. Order pick up!!!!

EJ

Great service, very friendly. The food was good, my first time eating there.

Jason Clark

I’ve been ordering pizza from here when they were in their old location and I’m glad they have reopened. Pizza is amazing as always and super quick and fairly priced. My local go to!

David Kraus

Typical pizza and wings. Leftovers don't reheat well, wings included.

Dan Aniszewski

I took a plain slice home from Pesaro’s today. Look at the size of that slice, it won’t even fit on my dinner plates. I really enjoyed it, fresh dough, good sauce and cheese. I’m about 12 miles away, so I had to reheat it in the oven, but I bet it’s even better right out of the oven. Quick, friendly service too. Good value for the money, I’ll be back.

Maggie Sarver

Such good quality for such a great value. Never disappoints, always fresh and delicious!!!

Tiara Marie

Update (They still never gave me money back ) Found a trustworthy pizza shop to order from without crackhead and dope Fein delivery drivers and cooks !!!!
Ordered a pizza for delivery I paid with a debt card over the phone. When the driver delivered the pizza to my house I filled out the receipt put 0 for tip because I gave the driver a tip in cash! In which I always tip in cash never on my card. I get notifications send to my phone anytime my visa card gets used to stop fraudulent payments . Next day I get notification saying $5.00 been removed off my card from Pizza Pesaros! I called and asked for a manager he told me he was sorry and that next I order pizza from them he will tell the driver to give me $5 back !! However that did not happened!!!! when I ordered again the driver did not give me $5 back and I still tipped the driver. PLEASE CHECK YOUR BANK STATEMENTS FOR EXTRA MONEY BEING TAKIN OFF AS A TIP YOU DID NOT AUTHORIZED !!!!
MY LAST TIME ORDERING PIZZA FROM HERE!!!! LOST A GOOD CUSTOMER OF YEARS !!!! ALSO DELIVERY DRIVER LOOKS DIRTY!!! SHIRT HAD STAINS ON IT AS IF IT WAS OLD AND DIRTY!!!
HANDS HAS NEEDLE MARKS ON THEM STILL FRESH YOU COULD SEE THE INJECTION SITE !!!!
NEVER AGAIN !!!! BETTER PIZZA PLACES AROUND

Bobby D

The pizza is absolutely fantastic and Italian wedgie is very good also. Prices are great too.

Margarita Gray

Amazing food at an amazing price especially for neighborhood. Not from here and they delivered to our girls night even faster than they projected.

Annette Patterson

Really good variety of pizza. We love the Sicilian options.

Josh Mullenite

I order from here about once a week. I'm not typically a big fan of the pizza options in Pittsburgh (preferring thinner slices) and the pizza here ranges from incredible to pretty good when I ask for thin crust. They use fresh crimini mushrooms which is really rare here. Everyone I've interacted with has been great and I'm glad they're around.

The problem is, with some regularity, there is stray sausage on the pizza and I'm vegetarian. Taking a bite and tasting sausage is really off-putting. Thankfully, it's only off-putting and I don't have a pork allergy or a religious dietary restriction. This is something they really should work on and seriously lowers my rating. It shows a lack of care.

Ron Persky

My wife and me ordered two hoagies she ordered a seafood hoagie that was absolutely atrocious and I ordered a meatball hoagie and God only knows what it was it was the worst tasting meatball hoagie I have ever had in my life never again will we be ordering from this place again absolutely atrocious anybody that wants anything from here better think twice because it's absolutely terrible

Connie Murphy

We ordered two hoagie a meatball and seafood today they were terrible take out

Loading...