I was walking around while my girlfriend was getting her nails done and decided to stop here for a drink. I had no idea what kind of bar it was but it seemed like a cool spot to watch some baseball.
Bartender was nice at first but after I asked for a drink they couldn't make, the mood changed and I'm not exactly sure why. I worked as a server/bartender for many years so I'm always make sure I treat all service workers with an abundance of kindness and patience. So, I know I wasn't being rude. I was perfectly fine with getting a beer instead.
I tried making conversation but I was met with a brick wall. Others were making conversation just fine, so I know it was mainly a thing with me.
I had some apps but they seemed like they were brought in by either Sysco or US Foods, so nothing special.
Asked for the check and after I paid I made sure to say thanks and to have a good rest of the day, but was once again met with no response. Every other person that was paid their tabs was met with a smile and a friendly exchange.
This seems like an alright spot, but my experience left me feeling upset. Not mad, but I was just looking for a nice spot to chill and didn't mean to make anyone upset just by asking for a drink.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Benjamin Carroll
This one hurts to write. William Penn was once my favorite bar. Since moving to the new location a few years ago, I've had nothing but negative experiences.
Just now, I asked if I could order food and was just told no. I'm not intoxicated, I wasn't rude. They just cannot handle their front of house with their existing kitchen.
Don't waste your time.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Keith Huthmacher
My favorite place to watch sports, friendly clientele and staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
shera Naydovich
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A spiritual experience disguised as a bar William Penn Tavern isn’t just a bar. It’s a lifestyle choice. I walked in for one beer and walked out spiritually reborn, smelling like buffalo sauce and regret. The second I sat down, I could feel my arteries whisper “don’t do it” while my soul screamed “extra ranch.” The wings here are so good I briefly considered proposing to them. The “Kitchen Sink” sauce changed me as a person. I blacked out somewhere between “medium heat” and “I can see colors now.” I swear I saw George Washington in the steam rising from my plate, and he told me to order another round. The crowd was a mix of college students, sports fans, and one man who might have legally been a couch. Everyone was screaming at TVs like their mortgage depended on it. The bartender had the confidence of a man who could solve all of life’s problems with a Jägerbomb, and honestly, he might be right. At one point I lost track of time. Was I there for two hours or two days? I can’t say. But I do know that when I left, I had a new tattoo, a new best friend named Carl, and a firm belief that this bar could solve world peace if given enough Coors Light. If you come to William Penn Tavern expecting a quiet evening, you’ve made a terrible mistake. But if you come seeking chaos, wings, and the kind of happiness that only deep-fried poultry can bring, welcome home.
Jordan Slack
Bouncer kicked us out not sure why. (no explanation- I happened to be with my black friend?) Avid drinkers, and the bartender/buss boy ripped a bottle out of my hand. Not a great experience start to finish. Maybe go if you just need a quick shot between strip and Lawrenceville on a journey.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Harry Balzac
Nice ambiance, good service, terrible IC Light drafts. Do not get an IC Light here they taste like absolute garbage
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Vanessa Russo
Darcy's the best bartender always remembers your drink! Kind and considerate love this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Betsy Mckelvey
Boneless wings were not good nor were the cocktails. Best thing about the place is the number of TVs to watch the games.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
seth p
Great Vibes all are welcome!! Wings Amazing!! would not get the pizza though. Great customer service and crowd for all people!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sean J
I mean it when I say this is probably the single best Philly cheesesteak in Pittsburgh(as a South Jersey native I might be biased to its name on the menu). Love that it comes with relish on the side, too
Stopped in for lunch, got a drink and a menu and never saw the server again for 45 minutes. First and last time in this dump.
Kailin Clawson
Such a fun place for sporting events or just a night out. Garage door is awesome in the summer and I love the staff. Great specials and food. Their kitchen sink sauce is 10/10!!
Dmytro Scarola
Great place. Special thanks to the bartender (sorry didn't catch your name) who helped me sort out my food pick up issue. Cheers!
travis shuford
The staff is unprofessional and rude
Service: 1
Ana Karen
It's a really good bar if you want to watch a game or just to spend time. The wings are delicious and the sauces, too. They have some deals during the week
I was walking around while my girlfriend was getting her nails done and decided to stop here for a drink. I had no idea what kind of bar it was but it seemed like a cool spot to watch some baseball.
Bartender was nice at first but after I asked for a drink they couldn't make, the mood changed and I'm not exactly sure why. I worked as a server/bartender for many years so I'm always make sure I treat all service workers with an abundance of kindness and patience. So, I know I wasn't being rude. I was perfectly fine with getting a beer instead.
I tried making conversation but I was met with a brick wall. Others were making conversation just fine, so I know it was mainly a thing with me.
I had some apps but they seemed like they were brought in by either Sysco or US Foods, so nothing special.
Asked for the check and after I paid I made sure to say thanks and to have a good rest of the day, but was once again met with no response. Every other person that was paid their tabs was met with a smile and a friendly exchange.
This seems like an alright spot, but my experience left me feeling upset. Not mad, but I was just looking for a nice spot to chill and didn't mean to make anyone upset just by asking for a drink.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
This one hurts to write. William Penn was once my favorite bar. Since moving to the new location a few years ago, I've had nothing but negative experiences.
Just now, I asked if I could order food and was just told no. I'm not intoxicated, I wasn't rude. They just cannot handle their front of house with their existing kitchen.
Don't waste your time.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My favorite place to watch sports, friendly clientele and staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A spiritual experience disguised as a bar
William Penn Tavern isn’t just a bar. It’s a lifestyle choice. I walked in for one beer and walked out spiritually reborn, smelling like buffalo sauce and regret. The second I sat down, I could feel my arteries whisper “don’t do it” while my soul screamed “extra ranch.”
The wings here are so good I briefly considered proposing to them. The “Kitchen Sink” sauce changed me as a person. I blacked out somewhere between “medium heat” and “I can see colors now.” I swear I saw George Washington in the steam rising from my plate, and he told me to order another round.
The crowd was a mix of college students, sports fans, and one man who might have legally been a couch. Everyone was screaming at TVs like their mortgage depended on it. The bartender had the confidence of a man who could solve all of life’s problems with a Jägerbomb, and honestly, he might be right.
At one point I lost track of time. Was I there for two hours or two days? I can’t say. But I do know that when I left, I had a new tattoo, a new best friend named Carl, and a firm belief that this bar could solve world peace if given enough Coors Light.
If you come to William Penn Tavern expecting a quiet evening, you’ve made a terrible mistake. But if you come seeking chaos, wings, and the kind of happiness that only deep-fried poultry can bring, welcome home.
Bouncer kicked us out not sure why. (no explanation- I happened to be with my black friend?) Avid drinkers, and the bartender/buss boy ripped a bottle out of my hand. Not a great experience start to finish. Maybe go if you just need a quick shot between strip and Lawrenceville on a journey.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Nice ambiance, good service, terrible IC Light drafts. Do not get an IC Light here they taste like absolute garbage
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Darcy's the best bartender always remembers your drink! Kind and considerate love this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Boneless wings were not good nor were the cocktails. Best thing about the place is the number of TVs to watch the games.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Great Vibes all are welcome!! Wings Amazing!! would not get the pizza though. Great customer service and crowd for all people!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
I mean it when I say this is probably the single best Philly cheesesteak in Pittsburgh(as a South Jersey native I might be biased to its name on the menu). Love that it comes with relish on the side, too
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped in for lunch, got a drink and a menu and never saw the server again for 45 minutes. First and last time in this dump.
Such a fun place for sporting events or just a night out. Garage door is awesome in the summer and I love the staff. Great specials and food. Their kitchen sink sauce is 10/10!!
Great place. Special thanks to the bartender (sorry didn't catch your name) who helped me sort out my food pick up issue. Cheers!
The staff is unprofessional and rude
Service: 1
It's a really good bar if you want to watch a game or just to spend time.
The wings are delicious and the sauces, too.
They have some deals during the week
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...