Keystone Bakery (Formerly Traub's Bakery)
CLOSED$ •
About Keystone Bakery (Formerly Traub's Bakery)
Recent Reviews
126 ratings
Clean bakery but didn't have a lot to pick from
First time customer with my daughter's...lemon square below average. Strawberry short cake dry. Cannoli average don't get the yellow filling. Got a cheese pocket cant give you a review on it because they forgot to put it in my bag. I called when I arrived home and they asked what I ordered I told them my order and the items that I did have and they suggested that I drive back to get it, I said that I was fighting traffic just to get home and the person that I was having the conversation...read full review
Not the same service as Traubs, definitely not customer Friendly
Traub's Bakery is a beloved destination for special occasions. Their custom cakes, like the replica Barney Cake, bring joy to customers. The bakery's goods are a staple at family gatherings, with favorites like strawberry shortcake and Frankfurter cake. The talented cake decorators go above and beyond, creating beautiful cakes that exceed expectations. Customers also enjoy the peanut butter kandy cake, and the bakery is known for having the best milk around. The service is always great, and the bakery has a cute atmosphere with plenty of free parking. However, some items like lemon squares and cannoli may not meet everyone's expectations, and there have been issues with missing items and stale baked goods. Despite this, many find the bakery to be a charming place with delicious treats and friendly staff.