Nico's Italian Pizzeria

275 PA-61, Schuylkill Haven
(570) 385-2262

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tay Pal

Went here for the first time on a friday night. Despite many customers going in and out, our food was made extremely quickly and was DELICIOUS! Highly recommend the white pizza - one of the best I've had in a long time!

Jeff Jones Jr.

Wings cooked to perfection and the pizza is thin, crispy, and cheesy. Just the way I remember it from years back. John goes over the top for his customers, glad to see them back in there. 10/10

Kora Elizabeth Kunkel

Already ordered twice since they opened in Auburn on Wednesday and everything has been so good! The pizza is amazing and their sub rolls omgggg

Leane Beckey

WOW WOW AND WOW!!! I wish I lived closer because I'd go there several times week! Good food, great service, overall awesome place!

Michael Melendez

I ordered the super Italian sub, and it was delicious. The bread is made fresh daily.

Paul Lapinsky

Great grub!!

Dan the Mind Sculptor

Okay I know it’s a β€œplain pizza” but this is just trolling at this point. No sauce? Just 10lbs of cheese and a shit ton of grease? No.

Michelle Ditzler

Wrong prices charged my card 25$ when I was confirmed 15$ and sum cents Plus, tell me that was purchased a Sicilian pizza which was probably three dollars or four dollars that still comes to $20 or $21. Do the math, the mushroom bacon & cheeseburger didn’t get bacon.

Lynn Longenberger

They charged $5 for delivery when I live just minutes away. My cheese steak Stromboli was disgusting. This place used to be great. Do not recommend now.

James Brossman

Worst Italian I ever had,roll was like a loaf of bread.Ordered a Roast beef sub and got Turkey ??

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Jim Brossman

Worst Italian I ever had.The roll was like a loaf of bread 🍞. Ordered a Roast beef and got a Turkey πŸ˜‘πŸ¦ƒπŸ‘Ž

Andrew Yatsko

This place was a nice little hole in the wall. The pepperoni and green peppers slice I ordered was great, the bbq chicken was alright. The crust on the pepperoni slice was great and left me disappointed as the bbq chicken dough was slightly undercooked. I will back in the future to try some other things on their menu.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice

Kristen Ludwig

One of my favorite pizza shops!
I love the owners!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beth Wolfe

Order the deep dish pepperoni pizza pizza was delicious the owner was very friendly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Betty Deysher

My grandchildren and i went into there on thursday June 13, 2024 around noon. The place was reeking of pot. We wanted to dine in .. went to the dinning section. Table dirty, meus everywhere and no one was at the counter. I called out. We only stayed in there but 2 minutes, but that was enough. The smell was overwhelming. So we left and went to a pizza place close by. Without the overwhelming smell of pot. Lost our business.

Atmosphere: 1

Loading...