Original Italian Pizza
$ • Pizza, Italian
Hours:
5 W Pennsylvania Ave, Stewartstown
(717) 993-5555
About Original Italian Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Original Italian Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about Original Italian Pizza
I’ve tried and tried. Really want to like it but pretty much disappointed every time.
2nd time we have ordered here. First time the pizza was FANTASTIC, got 2 large and 1 free small from the promotion they run. Yesterday 3/27, we ordered 2 medium(one cheese and one pepperoni), with side of garlic knots. And oh my goodness the garlic knots were the BEST thing. Pizza? Not at all good. The sauce flavor was not good, and so much cheese. We are a pizza family, LOVE it, but this? My child who would eat 4 slices in one sitting, said absolutely not good at all.
This...read full review
Great subs and pizza. My kiddo and I really enjoyed their homemade bread and crust. Staff and owner were super friendly, attentive, and kind.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 9PM |
People in Stewartstown Also Viewed
Original Italian Pizza offers a mixed dining experience, now enhanced under new management. The restaurant is recognized for its crispy crust and generous toppings, alongside its friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere. Customers have enjoyed the 3 large pizza deal and the popular Italian sub. Recent reviews highlight the high quality of food and service, the freshness of the food and pastries, and the professionalism in the restaurant. The pizza is often described as the best authentic Italian in the area, featuring a crispy yet light crust and consistently delicious toppings. While some customers mentioned that the cheese can be a little salty and the crust could be crispier, the overall response is positive. The fries have been praised as very good, although the onion rings received criticism for being hard and lacking onion. The new owner is still working to hire new staff, but the existing team has been pleasant, and many customers are eager to return to try more menu items. Original Italian Pizza continues to uphold the legacy established by the previous owner, ensuring the essence of authentic Italian cuisine remains.