They have the best ice cream I've ever had and the food is great too.
Keith Eddy
Need to train employees on how to make ice cream cones. When a small and a large look the same something is wrong
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Angel Holt
Love that they have different options. Last time we were there they had sweet corn ice cream.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
walter sokol
Fair price for the ice cream.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tori C
3 stars because the only thing I can eat here is salad and frequently out of items. I understand that gluten-free is not typical for places like this but I guess I got spoiled with Tibi's Dairy Isle having gluten free options for everything on their menu. Tibi's was closed so we tried this place out and I was disappointed that I couldn't even get a burger with a gluten free bun. I ordered a chicken salad which was mediocre, not that you can get that great with a chicken salad but I've had better salads. It's the beginning of the season and they were out of Pepsi both times we went (approximately 1 week apart). They were out of hotdogs the second time so my daughter got a personal pizza which we all tried and nobody liked it. The burgers and fries are good but the fries need more salt. We asked for grilled onions to be added to our burgers and got maybe 3 rings. Not even enough to taste them. They don't have condiments sitting out so you have to wait for someone to notice that you need something to ask for it. Service is very slow. All in all, if we just want ice cream then we will go here but next time I want a good classic burger, fries and milkshake meal, I'll go the extra 5 miles for Tibi's.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Jennifer Wh
Ordered dinner burgers shakes and fries..received wrong sandwiches come to find out cashier rung in wrong food..called in said would make correct sandwiches when I got there no one came to windows, finally a guy came to window asked what was wrong explained he found receipt the told me I ordered wrong..I said I told the girl what I wanted she rang wrong sandwiches why would I order what I dont eat for that price..he asked what I wanted I said correct sandwich I called they said they would make correct ones..he stated I don't know what u want me to do while stuffing the receipt in my face telling me look u ordered wrong...no apologies just it was all my fault his employees wouldn't make a mistake..guess customers are wrong at this place...I left tossed all good on trash cause no one could eat their mistake..wasted 28$ to the garbage can with no shits given from anyone...well not be back with this kind of service..
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mike Hedglin
Ice cream wasn't very good had a funny taste 😞
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Bob Jones
they made the order wrong and then said we ordered wrong and refused to fix it. Asked for a burger with bacon, cheddar and BBQ add lettuce and tomato with extra bbq sauce on the side. I got peppers and onions no lettuce or tomato and got mayo on the side. then was accused of ordering wrong. nobody cares so all of my food went in their trash can. I'm out $20.00 because they refuse to fix their screw up. This is my first time ordering food and my last. With an attitude like I got I don't look for them to be in business long. I will go to Dairy Queen from now on. I will laugh when they close up. good riddance
fred6059
Tried a small burger and fries. It was so fresh and tasty! They even let you call ahead to order. I cannot wait to go back! Very close to home and local. That is what we need more of in Stoneboro. So glad they opened shop!
Did a great job of cleaning up the old McCullough's ice cream shop. It looks much cleaner. Sad to see the custard go, but the ice cream was decent. I ordered two scoops in a bowl and we definitely needed a bigger bowl—we made a mess! Would come back!
They have the best ice cream I've ever had and the food is great too.
Need to train employees on how to make ice cream cones. When a small and a large look the same something is wrong
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Love that they have different options. Last time we were there they had sweet corn ice cream.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Fair price for the ice cream.
Food: 5
Service: 5
3 stars because the only thing I can eat here is salad and frequently out of items. I understand that gluten-free is not typical for places like this but I guess I got spoiled with Tibi's Dairy Isle having gluten free options for everything on their menu. Tibi's was closed so we tried this place out and I was disappointed that I couldn't even get a burger with a gluten free bun. I ordered a chicken salad which was mediocre, not that you can get that great with a chicken salad but I've had better salads. It's the beginning of the season and they were out of Pepsi both times we went (approximately 1 week apart). They were out of hotdogs the second time so my daughter got a personal pizza which we all tried and nobody liked it. The burgers and fries are good but the fries need more salt. We asked for grilled onions to be added to our burgers and got maybe 3 rings. Not even enough to taste them. They don't have condiments sitting out so you have to wait for someone to notice that you need something to ask for it. Service is very slow. All in all, if we just want ice cream then we will go here but next time I want a good classic burger, fries and milkshake meal, I'll go the extra 5 miles for Tibi's.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Ordered dinner burgers shakes and fries..received wrong sandwiches come to find out cashier rung in wrong food..called in said would make correct sandwiches when I got there no one came to windows, finally a guy came to window asked what was wrong explained he found receipt the told me I ordered wrong..I said I told the girl what I wanted she rang wrong sandwiches why would I order what I dont eat for that price..he asked what I wanted I said correct sandwich I called they said they would make correct ones..he stated I don't know what u want me to do while stuffing the receipt in my face telling me look u ordered wrong...no apologies just it was all my fault his employees wouldn't make a mistake..guess customers are wrong at this place...I left tossed all good on trash cause no one could eat their mistake..wasted 28$ to the garbage can with no shits given from anyone...well not be back with this kind of service..
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ice cream wasn't very good had a funny taste 😞
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
they made the order wrong and then said we ordered wrong and refused to fix it. Asked for a burger with bacon, cheddar and BBQ add lettuce and tomato with extra bbq sauce on the side. I got peppers and onions no lettuce or tomato and got mayo on the side. then was accused of ordering wrong. nobody cares so all of my food went in their trash can. I'm out $20.00 because they refuse to fix their screw up. This is my first time ordering food and my last. With an attitude like I got I don't look for them to be in business long. I will go to Dairy Queen from now on. I will laugh when they close up. good riddance
Tried a small burger and fries. It was so fresh and tasty! They even let you call ahead to order. I cannot wait to go back! Very close to home and local. That is what we need more of in Stoneboro. So glad they opened shop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great ice cream and food
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing food!!!!! Service was outstanding!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time there and the ice cream was good!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Did a great job of cleaning up the old McCullough's ice cream shop. It looks much cleaner. Sad to see the custard go, but the ice cream was decent. I ordered two scoops in a bowl and we definitely needed a bigger bowl—we made a mess! Would come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...