19 Best Italian Restaurants near Sybertsville

“Go for the specialty pizzas—the “Sweet Sauce” and the “Special T” get standout shout‑outs“

“If your looking for an amazing seafood dinner, this is the place. Stuffed Flounder was very stuffed and a very generous portions, Francis finally got the Captains Catch Scallops, Jumbo Shrimp and Amazing Crab Cakes, all came with a salad and side, with bread! 3 dinners we were very pleased with. Also our forever Pizza & Entree place!! Thank you Benito's!! 👍“

“Italian sub was delicious. Especially the bread. And the pizza was also very good. Loved the cheese. Excellent and courteous staff. Prices very reasonable. Highly recommend..“

“I've been looking for some authentic pupusas since I moved back to PA from California. I was so excited when I saw they had some in Nescopeck! I just had to try these and I was Not disappointed. they were wonderful and exactly what a pupusa should taste like. The pizza was also delicious. I love their crispy crust! customer service was awesome as well. We will be back!“

“Wonderful restaurant. Will be back“

“We enjoyed a wonderful evening dining at Rosta’s outside patio area. The aroma of the smoked grilled foods smelled soooo good…. We enjoyed our dinner, beverages, atmosphere, and our service. The menu has so many wonderful options you’ll have a hard time in choosing what you want. We left beyond satisfied with our orders and a lot of food to take home for later. Happy Full bellies. Yum! Thank you Rosta Cafe for providing the area with such a wonderful restaurant.“

“We order from here a lot. The food is always good. Lately though it’s been great! They are always super friendly. The delivery people are always nice. We have never had any problems.“

“We ate breakfast there four times while on vacation. The food was very good and the wait staff very friendly. We will be back next year.“

“Great dining, delicious choices, and fabulous staff! Thank you Amber!“

“Great little hidden gem! Pizza is awesome, cheesesteaks are the best around! Everything is homemade and fresh! Would highly recommend this place to anyone! Prices are more than reasonable. Finally a good place to get a delicious and affordable lunch or dinner! They also do catering for private events! Awesome place!“

“Authentic Roman cuisine…a fine Italian Restaurant!“

“Delicious meatballs sandwich on fresh Italian toasted bread…mmm…mmm…mmm 🤌🏻🤌🏻“

“It is a complete place, where when you visit you have Creole Food services to serve you immediately, with free Delibery service. In addition, there is a room for events, an alcohol license and karaoke every Thursday from 9:00 pm. They also prepare services for Buffett and events of all kinds.....“

“I ORDERED A LARGE PIE. WITH BACON AND ONION. IVE ORDERED MANY IN MY DAY. ITS MY FAVORITE PIZZA. WHEN I OPENED MY PIZZA 🍕 BOX I WAS SHOCKED THE TOPPINGS WERE LOADED ON THERE. BEST I EVER HAD. ILL BE BACK“

“excellent family run business with outstanding service and top of the line selection of the finest Italian food.“

“Everything was fabulous. The inside dining area is so cute but first time sitting outside on their patio was perfect. Long hots, Amatriciana, and Pollo Cilentana 🤍 Honestly the best Italian food around I felt like I was in Italy. Also love that it’s byob 🍷“

“Love that this is a Family run Local establishment. The lasagna was good but not the same as a square cut out of a pan. All the necessary ingredients are present. Found the sauce to be a little wanting of a some TLC. Quantity to Price a good balance.“

“very good food had the veal dinner it was delicious“

“I had the best ever caprese panini this afternoon at Cafe Europa. Haven't been in the area long, first time I stopped by. The outside of the panini was seasoned well and an excellent dressing of olive oil and balsamic vinegar was provided on the side. A good amount of fresh mozzarella and delicious roasted peppers were pressed together and the taste was so good. Will go back for other delights. The Italian desserts looked great!“