Fellinis Pizzeria Penn Hills

I order here all the time and there is an issue with my order that could not be fixed until I got a direct call from the owner Nicky who is absolutely phenomenal and gave me a great discount to help with my satisfaction!! Awesome service!! Thank you Nicky ❤

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time and won't be the last. Great pie, cheesy bread was very good and the sauce is spot on!

Good food decent menu

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Wings, Small, Large

Ordered a Pepperoni pizza with extra cheese on one side, and pepperoni on the other side!
ASKED for a COLD hoagie,, received a hot one!!
It’s sad that they messed up my order,,, told me to call whenever I was ready to order so they could give us a free one!!
Called today because I haven’t had the chance to use my free pass!!
They told me I waited too long to use it!!!
I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM HERE AGAIN!!!!!
$40 was a well taught lesson

Herb C

They didn’t text or knock when the pizza was delivered, it was cold and soggy by the time I realized it was out there… and also apparently full of ants. Freaked out and tossed it before I took a picture.

Perfect value for the price. Sandwiches are decent. Pizza is better.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 4

1st thing the pizza was pretty good with good crust. In saying that...
1. I walked in with no other customers. Guybwas leaning on the counter and never acknowledged I walked in. He just walked to the back.
2. My order was made wrong ( gave specific instructions)
3. I ordered half baked and it didn't happen and it was already cut.
Lastly, the lady that rang up my order was friendly, but I'm not sure if I will use this location again

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 2

Everytime we order from them for delivery, they’re quick, friendly, and the food is warm and delicious! When I’ve been in to do pick-up, they’ve been so friendly too.

The food is good, the people are great, and the price is nice for the amount you get!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’m not sure why they charge $1 for each topping on your pizza and give you little bitty pieces that you can’t even taste. This is the first time I ordered their Sicilian pizza with extra toppings , last time I got pepperoni and there was a thin layer of cheese and 4 like pepperonis and since I knew the crust was thick so I got extra toppings so that I’m not just buying bread like LAST TIME.
I also ordered Cajun ranch (the flavor) wings. Why did they charge me for extra ranch and not even toss the chicken in it? Highly disappointed- I do like their steak hoagies but it doesn’t have a lot of meat which is perfect for me. This is the second time I’ve ordered this flavor and getting charged for extra ranch that I didn’t ask for. If it’s part of the flavor why am I being up charged? Why are there little pieces of toppings on Sicilian crust. Do better. And whatever woman is answering the phone needs to be put in the back some where, cause I believe she’s the one who took the order for the last wings I got that were wrong!

Food: 2

Service: 1

We had a hoagie, wings, and pizza. Everything tasted great AND was hot and ready at the time of pickup.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They are the best ❤️

I cook at the bar next Door. I get his cheese steak hoagies and he makes it just like I want it with extra mayo American cheese, lettuce and ketchup (the Jersey way lol) it is so bomb..Sometimes I ask for extra meat just to be greedy, but it bomb without it???

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hoagies

Food is always excellent! Hot and fresh, accurate and fast! We love Fellini’s Penn Hills! Its our go to spot!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Stallion, White Pizza,

Pizza was good

Used to be my favorite local pizza place. They must have switched ingredients, the quality & taste ( and after taste) were awful. Extremely disappointed. The cook & delivery driver were very pleasant. That was my last visit. Too much competition to ot taste good.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 5