Restaurants near Wellsville

“Me and my girlfriend went there for lunch and the food was great didn’t take long at all to get and the staff was super friendly, strongly recommend!”

“This is a hidden gem we have passed it numerous times and finally decided to stop. Food is excellent !! Little language barrier BUT we finally were given Makayla! Thank heavens because no one could open a bottle of wine let alone bring us not sweet white wine ( they sent red at first) Makayla was then asked to step in and she saved the day 😁 Salad was great ! Chicken Parm was outstanding and prices are very reasonable. Definitely will be back if Makayla is working.”

“I have lived in this area for 25+ years and have seen changes with Mammas throughout the years. They have it going on again. high five to the cooks and staff! Recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza. I am not a pizza crust eater but I eat their pizza crust.”

“This was a very nice subway. My kids are hard at work fishing less than a mile away and I went in for a short break. The sandwich shop was clean, the man behind the counter was nice and asked me what I wanted, provided it and wrapped it neatly. The food board was nice and clean. The table area was clean and all the tables looked like they had recently been wiped down. Nice quiet shop, provided a good product. Will be back. Will also file it away for a location easy to access while fishing Pinchot ?”

“I have ordered from here at least twice a month for over a year now. The owner is a fantastic man who really keeps his word. They have the best pizza and Strombolis..”

“Delicious!!!!! Dude can cook!!! Very professional, very friendly, good dude!!!!!!! BBQ Chicken Ranch loaded fries!!! Best ever!!!!”

“this is an amazing bakery. I routinely buy their Fruit Nut loaf. I'm so impressed by it that I carry it all the way to Nevada when I go out to visit family. Everything I've had is high quality they rate 5 of 5”

“I truly don’t even know where to begin — THEA is not just a restaurant, it’s an experience that touches the heart. From the moment you walk in, there’s a warmth and sincerity that only comes from someone who truly loves what they do. AnnMarie, thank you from the bottom of my heart for opening your doors for my son’s First Communion dinner and making it feel like home. The food was absolutely incredible — every dish bursting with flavor, authenticity, and soul. You could taste the love in every bite. From the beautifully prepared appetizers to the delicious entrees, everything was flawless. My family and I felt welcomed, understood, and truly cared for in every detail. You didn’t just host a dinner, you helped create a memory that we’ll cherish forever. The atmosphere, the lights, the service, the heart — it was all magical. If you’re looking for a place that feels like home, that feeds your soul as much as your stomach, THEA is that place. Grazie di cuore, AnnMarie. I will never forget this night.”

“Just enjoyed a great meet & greet over a cup of excellent Three Arrows Coffee with Congressman John Joyce during his listening tour of Adams County today. The venue is fully accessible, conveniently located just off the Hampton, PA, round about with plently of free parking on site. The friendly owners and staff showed every courtesy and hospitality to make our experience wonderful in every way.”

“Absolutely Adorable place. The waiters were so nice, and we later became friends. I can and am recommending this place for anyone who just wants to relax and eat some great food.”

“BEST breakfast around! Staff are kind, and friendly people. 5 STAR!!! My Favorite!”

“Very outstanding,Delicious food. Service is beyond great! Chef Neil is there please. You will want to go back to Sidney's every chance you can.”

“Their food is Great in my opinion and the prices are reasonable compare with any other place around. Their burgers are better than most if not all the places around. WaWa doesn't compare in sub and hamburger area. WaWa is for coffee and a bagel sandwich. Their biggest problem with Glacier Flakes is their new location is not great and their sign is not helping. They need to add some color to the sign to get people's attention and advertise on it for specials, Like Taco Tuesday, Mr Sub Saturday, Wings and Things Thursday you get the point. OK so they don't serve wings, Fish Fry Friday. Anyways I've love their food it is good and solid and the price is good as well.”

“Staff was very accommodating and friendly. The coffee was on point. Kids books and small play area are great.”

“Such a nice place to be! What a wonderful addition to the area!!”

“Best pizza/sub shop in the area … everyone is super nice!”

“Great wings, friendly service.”

“if you don't know about this place you really need to check them out fantastic food and you get your money's worth”

“been going there with my girlfriend for a few months that older waitresses with grey hair always has a bad aditude or spazzs out when it gets busy. I got uncomfortable and left. the tall one with brunette hair name goes by anika is too busy talking about her personal life to customers than doing her job. I won't be going back for a long time.”

“they have the very best food around and very freindly people that work there they make sure you are happy with everthing.”

“Highly recommend Soulshine Coffee! Brian, the owner, has a passion for perfectly roasting the beans and a passion for people! Bless this precious company by purchasing their coffee and you will be soooo glad you did! ♥️”

“Very friendly. Great coffee. Great atmosphere!! Will visit often.”

“It's the best Tavern. The staff is awesome . You never know what your walking in to karaoke, bands, something new all the time it's the best bad decision you will ever make lol”

“We picked up some delicious desserts at the York home show. Absolutely amazing and very fair prices.”

“My go to coffee and/or breakfast meet up location! Indoor and outdoor seating, vegan and gluten free options if needed. The mocha is delicious 😋”

“Gave a 24 hr notice for 25 people. We arrived and the seating was reserved and marked easily to find. Service was quick. Food orders were prepared as per request. Food was delicious. Would highly recommend visiting here for a delicious lunch or dinner. Family friendly. Off street parking. Plenty of seating! Accommodations for couples and large groups as well as a banquet area. 5*****”

“It has been 40 years since I was there but I stop in and Awsome food people was warm and friendly I will definitely be back”

“Miss Cindy Lynn (aka Leona) was a pleasure to meet. Her fresh made menu of foods and desserts was absolutely delicious. I had the lasagna and lobster bisque. I must say, the lobster stayed instead of just dropping a little lobster trickle in the bisque; every spoon full had chunks of lobster meat and great flavor. The lasagna portion was huge and most loaded with meat and cheese; clearly fresh made. My friend had the crab bisque and said hers was loaded with crab meat too! I got dessert to go, and the pink velvet cookie was heavenly. The chocolate peanut butter chunk cookie was so big I got 1 for my husband and daughter to split. We will definitely be back to partake in her cooking and baking classes, and to enjoy more of her menu.”

“If I am in the area, I always stop at Sarah's Creamery. My son graduated from Penn State, and we got hooked on Penn State Ice Cream. Sarah's is the only place I know that has Penn State Ice Cream other than Penn State! My favorite is "Peachy Paterno"! I stopped in Sarah's Creamery today and got my Peachy Paterno Ice cream cone. It's the best treat ever! If you are ever in the area, you must stop in Sarah's Creamery and try the Penn State Ice Cream!”

“Best Pizza in York County...just WAY too salty...wont shop there again...sadly”