Crazy Tomato

1738 Filbert St, York
(717) 843-7499

Recent Reviews

Grant Shue

Ordered from here giving it another shot after many mistakes. When there food is done correctly it is great. This time our stromboli the dough was raw along with my wifes pretzel bacon burger.. outside was cooked that was it. I think I've given enough chances.

Samantha Shue

We keep trying to get food here since it's local and sometimes it's really good. But every single time, one of our items is messed up, typically not made the way it was ordered. Today was the final straw. Stromboli dough had bits of raw dough still. Ordered a bacon cheeseburger in a pretzel bun, that I've gotten before, and other than the outside, the dough was completely raw and inedible. Very disappointed that they can't seem to get it together in there.

Samantha Carbaugh

I love the cheeseburger subs

Stacy Strausbaugh

I called started my water for a pizza and they hung up I'll never give them a try again they suck

Todd Davis

Always have an attitude when I call, like I am inconveniencing them. Food was good, but now mostly greasy and not what it was.

Carlos Ramirez

Staff aren’t the friendliest and customer services is everything to me so I didn’t even purchase I just turned around and kindly left. Remember business owners, you guys need my money to keep doors open. I can go to another establishment or cook my meals. Please never think a customer needs your services.

K Sewell

We only ordered a Cheese Pizza but it was absolutely delicious!! Will deffo be back!! ?

Jody Blair

Love ❤️ this place! Great pizza, great service.

Taina R.

Pretzel boil is what I really come here for. The pizza is mediocre. The chicken wings are dry and hard. The say we visit it was one guy cooking everything , which was fine because it was New Year's Day.

Dana qb

Order was incorrect. Politely called and made them aware. Returned to pick up corrected order. They treated us like complete scum for their mistake and even called my daughters phone number AFTER we picked up the food for the second time to argue and belittle her. Wow! I will NEVER support this business again.

Christopher Lopez

Incredibly nice! they had great service and helped us with everything we needed. 5 star service

Damiam Smith

Great place! Boli's are awesome! Subs a little small, but good. I would recommend. Street parking, so a little limited.

De Graves

2 for 22,99 coupon states one large cheese pizza and one large bolinso I ordered that and a large pepperoni pizza, when my wife gets there to pick it up they charged us 19 for the bolinsnd gave us the two 12 pizzas for 23 saving a dollar when my wife brought it up guy gets rude very unprofessional it's literally your coupon that says you get one boli and one pizza for 22.99 on Sundays

Dane S.

The Pretzel Stromboli, that's all I need to say. It's amazing! Very small on the inside and usually hot from the ovens so I've only ever ordered to go. Right in the middle of a neighborhood with houses all around it. One day I might try something else but as long as they have the pretzel boli that's all I need. The staff are always nice.

Kirsten Sterner

Love Crazy tomato! My family has been coming here for years and I’ve never been disappointed. Food is good, customer service is great, prices are fair for the current market! Look no further for your new favorite pizza spot.

Load More