New York City Pizza

190 E Bay St #102, Charleston
(843) 805-5933

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Shirin ALL

Horrible customer service. The two ladies working inside were extremely rude to me and my family. Shame on both of you.

Christopher Patten

Awsome pizza joint! It's our go to for a quick bite near Market Street.

Elaina Peterson

Don't be turned away by lower reviews because this place was fantastic! Not expecting this but we had some amazing food. They were out of stock of gluten free pasta, so we got a gluten free pizza which was pretty great. We got one of the best calzones we'd ever had, and the fettuccine Alfredo was far more tasty than I was expecting. Everything tasted homemade and fresh and flavorful! Our waiter was super friendly and professional and quick to get us what we needed. This place is great - give it a shot!

Tracy Strevel

Service was perfect. The waitress was attentive without smothering. Food was amazing! Mozzarella sticks bigger than a Twinkie and so delicious. The NY thin crust pizza was crispy around the edges and the toppings were so so delicious too. Chopped salad was so fresh and tasty. Highly recommended and great value for the amount of food.

Cassie Madison

Glen was an amazing server, professional, polite and attentive. The pizza was great as well. Will be back.

D Mad

Our server Glenn was outstanding, the pizza was fantastic as well, will definitely stop there again!!!!

Scooter Smith

April was the best bartender. She was very attentive. Best bloody Mary’s. We
Didn’t eat because we had reservations elsewhere. We will be back to check out the food!

Bo Hermes

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. The best in Charleston

Elia Amor

Finally went to try out their food, so disappointed we didn't get there sooner..
Food was excellent 👌
We love there cheese sticks... prices are good
Lot's of choices for drinks
The employees are very sweet. My favorite is April
She is the best... 🥰🍕🥗
We've eaten there 3× in 1 month & will be back

Meredith Newman

We are from Buffalo, and moved to Cali 5 years ago. Cali pizza is absolute trash and while on vacation we discovered this gem. THIS IS LEGIT NY PIZZA! I cannot recommend enough!

James Chaney

Food was great and huge pizzas! Well worth the money.

jLarry Frazier

If you eat here. You'll be glad you passed by all the higher priced food spots around the market. Saw it as we walked around. Glad we stopped in. We were blown away by the authentic flavor of the sauces. All homemade we found out talking to the waitress.

Nathan Nesmith

Amazing New York style pizza!! Have been twice and both times they nailed it‼️

Mr. Cox

Amazing pizza!! Crunchy where it should be, amazing sauce, and just overall very delicious. They were slammed busy, but still super quick, never missed a refill, and kept everyone super happy! Literally can’t say enough good about this place, so glad we happened to stumble in visiting from knoxville

Tiffany Hall

Cute little pizza joint in Downtown Charleston with a nice atmosphere. Very nice people, AWESOME NY style pizza with REAL ingredients, not that store bought stuff, service was on point. The only downfall is you have to pay to park either on the street or in the parking deck behind the building and walk, but it's not far at all. The wings were good, true authentic NY style pizza with hand stretched dough. The lighting was dim and relaxing. I definitely recommend going if you have not been here and want a good pizza!

Loading...