First, I'll say the pizza is good, but other than that, it's just confusing. They are not a pizza joint they are part of Coot's. We ended up having to go through the gift shop and into Coots looking for the pizza and eneded up ordering from one of the bartenders. It was a challenge to get her attention( not because they were busy), but due to a couple guys sitting at the bar at the time. She finally came over and let us know we could order there. Order took about 15-20 minutes and came out hot! Overall, next time, I would call the order in and just pick up. Posted pic of menu and pizza. The last review said something about a take out fee, but we did not have that, so that may be a summer thing?
Lauri Ulrich
Ordered 3 pizzas. One was burned they told me, took just 2. The crust on the 2 we bought, was burned. It cost us $41 and they were small. I would never buy pizza here again. It is not a pizza joint, just a bar that sells pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Christopher Coffie
To the Gentleman that left the review stating head to Food Lion and grab 2 Tombstone Pizzas and a 12 pack. You were spot on! We ordered 2 pizzas and 10 wings for a family of 12 and we still had a whole pizza and a couple wings left over. Very expensive over $100 and poor quality pizza and wings.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Jeffrey Garlington
It was a pizza...giving ot two stars because it did have plenty of toppings. It just wasn't very good. It was only Luke warm when I picked it up even though I was there to pick it up exactly 15 minutes after placing the order (when they said it would be ready), I'm not sure they actually bake their pizzas long enough. My wife and I both felt the need to microwave our pieces and the crust was still doughy on a couple pieces.
Bob Lynn
Went for ice cream. Happy tracks was it. Got a cup. It is soothing on a hot day. Lots of souvenirs and pizza! In building with Coots.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sir William Goes
Save your self some time and money head next door to food lion and grab a tombstone, and a 12pk and eat at your rental! This is actually Coots bar, the service on the inside is ok the server that has worked the outside the past two nights is terrible. We tried to sit outside twice and received no acknowledgment each day. Once inside and attended to the beer is cold and they keep um coming that’s really the only highlight. They do have live music and they have a captive audience because they are the only place open past 9 on the island.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Nicole Long
Almost $40 for a small cheese and large pepperoni. There was literally one slice of paper per slice.
Will
Save your self some time and money head next door to food lion and grab a tombstone, and a 12pk and eat at your rental! This is actually Coots bar, the service on the inside is ok the server that has worked the outside the past two nights is terrible. We tried to sit outside twice and received no acknowledgment each day. Once inside and attended to the beer is cold and they keep um coming that’s really the only highlight. They do have live music and they have a captive audience because they are the only place open past 9 on the island.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Sir William Adams
Save your self some time and money head next door to food lion and grab a tombstone, and a 12pk and eat at your rental! This is actually Coots bar, the service on the inside is ok the server that has worked the outside the past two nights is terrible. We tried to sit outside twice and received no acknowledgment each day. Once inside and attended to the beer is cold and they keep um coming that’s really the only highlight. They do have live music and they have a captive audience because they are the only place open past 9 on the island.
I3933FDchriss
It is a little hard to find since it is an insude gift shop and another restaurant Coots. Bang bang shrimp from the Coots menu was good. Pizza was luke warm but had plenty of toppings (meat lovers) not sure it was worth $25. "Breadsticks" were just a small pizza crust baked to death. Server was great.
Pizza is pretty good! Don't listen to the bad reviews it's better than average bar food. I had a good experience and the food was solid. Prices are a tad high but so is life around the beach.
Ash Morgan
We sat outside during the week to grab a pizza. Hot and gooey w cheese and meats. Not many people, so the wait was minimal. Just mind the seagulls. They will steal your food.
Great Pizza! The small pizza is a perfect size for two people to share. We got the meat lovers and it was loaded with toppings. Very good pizza. Great view of the beach. Pelicans is located inside Coot's.
Lovely Lady
Horrible pizza..1 pepperoni on each slice is not my idea of a pepperoni pizza..crust was burnt, tasted like cardboard. Definitely NOT worth what you pay for a Large. Will never go back ☹
First, I'll say the pizza is good, but other than that, it's just confusing. They are not a pizza joint they are part of Coot's. We ended up having to go through the gift shop and into Coots looking for the pizza and eneded up ordering from one of the bartenders. It was a challenge to get her attention( not because they were busy), but due to a couple guys sitting at the bar at the time. She finally came over and let us know we could order there. Order took about 15-20 minutes and came out hot! Overall, next time, I would call the order in and just pick up. Posted pic of menu and pizza. The last review said something about a take out fee, but we did not have that, so that may be a summer thing?
Ordered 3 pizzas. One was burned they told me, took just 2. The crust on the 2 we bought, was burned. It cost us $41 and they were small. I would never buy pizza here again. It is not a pizza joint, just a bar that sells pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
To the Gentleman that left the review stating head to Food Lion and grab 2 Tombstone Pizzas and a 12 pack. You were spot on! We ordered 2 pizzas and 10 wings for a family of 12 and we still had a whole pizza and a couple wings left over. Very expensive over $100 and poor quality pizza and wings.
Food: 2
Service: 3
It was a pizza...giving ot two stars because it did have plenty of toppings. It just wasn't very good. It was only Luke warm when I picked it up even though I was there to pick it up exactly 15 minutes after placing the order (when they said it would be ready), I'm not sure they actually bake their pizzas long enough. My wife and I both felt the need to microwave our pieces and the crust was still doughy on a couple pieces.
Went for ice cream. Happy tracks was it. Got a cup. It is soothing on a hot day. Lots of souvenirs and pizza! In building with Coots.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Save your self some time and money head next door to food lion and grab a tombstone, and a 12pk and eat at your rental! This is actually Coots bar, the service on the inside is ok the server that has worked the outside the past two nights is terrible. We tried to sit outside twice and received no acknowledgment each day. Once inside and attended to the beer is cold and they keep um coming that’s really the only highlight. They do have live music and they have a captive audience because they are the only place open past 9 on the island.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Almost $40 for a small cheese and large pepperoni. There was literally one slice of paper per slice.
Save your self some time and money head next door to food lion and grab a tombstone, and a 12pk and eat at your rental! This is actually Coots bar, the service on the inside is ok the server that has worked the outside the past two nights is terrible. We tried to sit outside twice and received no acknowledgment each day. Once inside and attended to the beer is cold and they keep um coming that’s really the only highlight. They do have live music and they have a captive audience because they are the only place open past 9 on the island.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Save your self some time and money head next door to food lion and grab a tombstone, and a 12pk and eat at your rental! This is actually Coots bar, the service on the inside is ok the server that has worked the outside the past two nights is terrible. We tried to sit outside twice and received no acknowledgment each day. Once inside and attended to the beer is cold and they keep um coming that’s really the only highlight. They do have live music and they have a captive audience because they are the only place open past 9 on the island.
It is a little hard to find since it is an insude gift shop and another restaurant Coots. Bang bang shrimp from the Coots menu was good. Pizza was luke warm but had plenty of toppings (meat lovers) not sure it was worth $25. "Breadsticks" were just a small pizza crust baked to death. Server was great.
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is pretty good! Don't listen to the bad reviews it's better than average bar food. I had a good experience and the food was solid. Prices are a tad high but so is life around the beach.
We sat outside during the week to grab a pizza. Hot and gooey w cheese and meats. Not many people, so the wait was minimal. Just mind the seagulls. They will steal your food.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Food was good quality, staff was friendly ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Pizza! The small pizza is a perfect size for two people to share. We got the meat lovers and it was loaded with toppings. Very good pizza. Great view of the beach. Pelicans is located inside Coot's.
Horrible pizza..1 pepperoni on each slice is not my idea of a pepperoni pizza..crust was burnt, tasted like cardboard. Definitely NOT worth what you pay for a Large. Will never go back ☹