50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Garden City

“While visiting from out of town, we decided to try this Marco’s Pizza for the first time, and it was a fantastic choice! The pizza was delicious, with great flavor and fresh ingredients that made it truly enjoyable. The service was friendly and quick, making us feel welcome even though we were new to the area. We also appreciated the cleanliness of the restaurant, which added to the overall positive experience. If we find ourselves nearby again, we’ll definitely be back!“

“Absolutely delicious!!!“

“Our hotel recommended Toffino's when I ask for a good pizza and we were not disappointed! And when we saw the fresh pastries my wife was sold! I have been making canollies for her at home because there is no place close to us and now I have to step up my game. The food was excellent, the atmosphere was very nice and the service was top notch! You won't be disappointed with anything!“

“Delicious, so flavorful, we had the taco pizza and the pastor pizza and they were amazing! We will be back“

“That "The BEST PIZZA In Town" sign, when you first walk in, ain't no joke! Our first time here was today, my 49th birthday and this pizza was AMAZING! Definitely our Go To pizza place anytime we're in town. Can I give 10 stars 🌟?“

“WOW! Holy Pizza! We were in town with some family this past week and went to hyena Pizza and had the best experience! When you can't decide, hot chick, and Smoak ring pizzas were really, really good! All the pizzas are 10 inch and cooked to perfection, coming out of a woodfired oven gives them such great flavor! I would highly recommend strawberry salad, Bavarian pretzel steaks with a beer cheese! They have a great selection of beer and wine and this one stop pizza joint absolutely knock it out of the park! 💥💥💥💥💥💯“

“Awesome food, friendly service and reasonably priced“

“We dined here last night while on vacation. Will definitely be on top our list for the future. Excellent pizza! 🍕“

“We stopped in for dinner and was pleasantly surprised. The food was delicious and very fresh! Our waitress was an absolute sweetheart and so helpful. They weren’t very busy which was surprising because the food was the best we’ve had in MB on this trip. Definitely plan to visit again!“

“The only thing that matters to me is the pizza. I’m sure everything else is good, but I come here for the pizza. It is without a doubt some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere. Seriously. It’s the perfect marriage of crisp and buttery crust, bright red sauce with a zesty tomato zing, rich and buttery mozzarella and good quality pepperoni. Over the last several years, quality of pizza at most places has suffered. Not at Pizza a la Roma III. There was absolutely nothing disappointing about the pizza. This pizza stays with you after you eat it like all good pizza should. The flavors and aroma hang for a long time after you eat it. Perfect dine in experience. Hopefully if this place changed hands the new owners will keep the recipes and quality.“

“Delicious food, great service…Update: I am so sad the hummus has been changed to a black bean dip (not labeling it as hummus lol). My family and I would sometimes come just for the hummus and order multiple. Since the menu change we don’t bother going very often.“

“Best pizza in Myrtle beach! We absolutely love your food choices and menu. Highly recommended! Great delivery with out all the fees!“

“My wife and I had our first experience at Gios this week for our anniversary. Laurie was our server and was phenomenal. I had the Veal Mediterranean and my wife enjoyed the Chicken Alfredo. We enjoyed the charcuterie board and the escargot for appetizers and finished with the Tiramisu. Everything was fantastic! We will be back!“

“Favorite place for NY style pizza. Our family orders every time we are in town for an event and/or vacation. Our particular favorite is the meat lovers pizza!“

“There was a VW bus inside. I would go again just to sit inside the bus.“

“Food is so yummy!! True Italian hard to find but it’s right here at r-way. Thank you!“

“Mama Mía is a local and tourist favorite. The dough is hand prepared. The wings are cooked well, and the ranch dressing is on point! If you've read my other reviews, you know that's an important part, haha. This particular site is great for catching a game, ordering out, or dining in. Bathrooms are clean. Plenty of parking. Friendly staff.“

“Always awesome! Love the Panzos.“

“Great view, great service and great food.“

“this place is delicious! we ate here a week ago and had to go back tonight. our order was mixed up, but the fixed it and its perrrrfect! great customer service AND amazing food!“

“Everything we had today was excellent. We were impressed with the amount of items available on the menu along with unique items like the Asian BBQ Nachos. The crispy wonton that is under the nachos made the dish wonderful. The staff that helped us were very friendly and helpful with suggestions. We will definitely be back. 🙂“

“We were told that there were no good pizzas in the Myrtle Beach area, but after doing a yelp search, we found Aromas. Their pizza is New Haven style( the owner is from CT). We had a large pie with pepperoni, crumbled sausage and mushrooms, and it didn’t disappoint. It was our first pizza in Myrtle Beach , and we will definitely return.“

“We came in to get out of the rain. Best decision. The bartender Jeff was amazing. He was attentive and kept a lively conversation. We definitely would recommend.“

“Beautiful place to eat at, great service, the lady that took my order when I was there was so sweet and so helpful, I had the meat lovers pizza it was so yummy cooked just right. I’m from New York and I can say this is real New York pizza. They do get busy so it might be a little wait but yall are waiting for good pizza. Trust me BEST PIZZA YOU’LL EVER HAVE.“

“Wonderful food and great service!!“

“We've ordered here a couple times everything on their menu is great. only complaint would be phone etiquette. whomever takes your orders is very rude. Sorry not good business practice!“

“Great beers, friendly staff, and delicious pizza. We will be back to try more!“

“Wonderful place and the staff are excellent.“

“We tried out their breakfast. Their pizza was already amazing so we were excited to see them opening up early and serving breakfast. I can tell you, you won’t be disappointed! Absolutely delicious! Great service and atmosphere too. Rosaria is amazing! She talked to all of her customers and made sure everyone loved the food. Definitely not disappointed and will be back. For breakfast and lunch“

“Just moved to Myrtle Beach 2 days ago from upstate NY,, this was by far the best pizza I have ever had. Ordered a large pie with meatball ricotta, and this pizza was quite large, super thin crust, and tasted amazing. The price for the pizza was only 20 dollars,, very good deal in my book. Roma pizzaria is my go to pizza joint, and I highly recommend them“

“Visiting the area for the weekend. We have pizza on Friday nights, so we chose this nice place. The personnel were kind, caring, and greeted us with a wonderful smile. We chose a taco pizza and cheesy bread. The food was amazing, and the restaurant was clean and inviting. Thank you so much for an amazing meal and experience.“

“Pizza Hut has always been my favorite take out pizza especially the Tavern pizza. Unfortunately they have a tendency to overcook it just a tad but after requesting a little less cook time it's been perfect. Plus the cinnamon sticks are the best!!“

“We have been enjoying your restaurant for many years,but last night was the first time we were disappointed. We brought a couple with us for their first time there.We had been praising everything about it but last night we ordered off the regular menu,not the early bird specials and the portions were smaller than what we had on the early bird specials! It was excellent as always,but we were still hungry when we left. We’re not huge eaters and usually have leftovers!“

“THE FOOD IS DELICIOUS. MY FAMILY, AND FREINDS WAS IN THE AREA AND WANTED SOMETHING WHOLESOME AND GOOD AND THIS IS ONE OF THOSE PLACES WE THOUGHT WE WOULD TRY AND LOVED IT TOO DEATH, SO GOOD TALKED THEM TO DEATH GOTTA COME BACK FOR MORE ONCE AGAIN“

“Looks can be deceiving me and my girlfriend went here for some pizza and we where a little skeptical at first due to some reviews but we went ahead and got there 14 inch pepperoni pizza and it was fantastic it’s cooked in a proper pizza oven only took about 15 min from order to getting the pizza I watched them pull it and box it the crust on the pizza was perfectly crunchy on the bottom as soft on the top a excellent sauce to cheese ratio and pepperonis everywhere“

“First time here and the pizza was excellent. I am super picky and dislike most pizza. The sauce was sweet and fantastic, no oregano covering the whole pizza! I got a personal size with mozzarella and feta and the cheese was ooey gooey and delicious. My husband got onions, mushrooms and sausage. They do not skimp on the toppings. JuJu was our server and she was super friendly. We spend the winter at Myrtle Beach and we will definitely be back. We can’t wait to bring our friends. Thank you for making a pizza comparable to my favorite pizza back in NY!
5 stars all the way.“

“We were passing through Myrtle Beach on our way to Pawleys Island for the weekend, and we stopped here for dinner. We walked in and stopped, trying to figure out where to sit (it was Valentine’s Day, and they were hopping with a “Cupid is Stupid” party with bingo), when one of the owners came over to help us get settled. We enjoyed a burger and a chicken sandwich with a couple of beers, and even though we didn’t play bingo, the love-song themed game was fun to sit in on. Would visit again!“

“Pizza Is Really Delicious Thank You All 🥰“

“We had a great experience at Christos. Food and service were excellent. The owners came out and checked on us and we had a fun and friendly conversation about all sorts of things, including about Greece and Italy. Highly recommend and we will be back“

“👎This is the first time I actually used your app in order to get points -I eat there at least twice a week-I ordered my pizza online this time. I asked for extra mushrooms and onions in selections & in the notes section. I said please extra extra mushrooms and onions. When I got to the location, -the pizza looked between light and regular all the things I really wanted-so while I was there, I explained this was the first time with MOD app and that could we please go ahead and add more of the mushrooms and onions that, I would be OK with going home and heat the pizza up. I did get extra toppings for both. But I did ask for a little extra mushrooms. Your female caucasian agent -brown hair in a ponytail, said you can’t get anymore. She said for the amount of toppings that I had on there she cut me off “already as pictured with the extra toppings in photos ” . I was perplexed speechless- As everything is posted is unlimited toppings. I walked outside, but I came back in and I asked for her name-because as in a large company like yours as well as mine, to make you strong, I needed to reported if something really off happens- I love your place. I’ve always ordered in person before and got everything that I needed fine. You can ask many of the folks that work at the Surfside location off of 544 Commons Dr. I think they’ve all waited on me in person to order pizzas. She would not give me her name. She said, she didn’t have to give her name and I think she also said that I could come see management on Monday. As I work as a customer advisor -you don’t have to give your last name, but your first you do and I wear a name tag.
As this was my first time using the app. Since May 1 to today the 16th I’ve spent close to $70 at your store. I really love it. I work at a large company and I’m customer service advisor myself -so I’m also say going to say I’m an expert after being there 20 years in the field. I have never had this happen to me before. I’m not looking for anything free. Let’s just say between 630 and 7- and it’s now 840. I still have not eaten that pizza. You know when you’re too upset for words. Thank you, signed your faithful customer. I have posted eight pictures for you to view management.
Please get back to me.“

“I’ve been jn Cicis pizza in a lot a different locations and I’m not a reviewer but I feel the necessity to say this because I have never been treated so well in any other restaurant I have ever been to.
Thanks to all gentlemen for your politeness and attention
This is Friday 4:00 pm“

“They need help but the food was great“

“We loved it! Some of the best pizza!!“

“Husband had this pizza years ago at a rural location. He completely forgot about it until seeing sign at a different location in another very rural area. I personally have never had it and I'm extremely picky when it comes to pizza. It's one of my favorite foods. Well he suggested I try it because he remembers loving it over a decade ago. So I agreed and got a simple pepperoni pizza and then drove 15 mins home. Only cost $11.99 plus tax for a 12" Pizza which is cheapest pizza I've ever purchased. I had to rewarm it which made me hesitant on the quality. I was totally wrong. THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER EATEN. First purchase for me was yesterday and today I went out and bought 2 more. Great dough, sauce, cheese the works. I will forever be a Hunt Brothers Pizza only..“

“Maybe a little light on cheese. Our regular place was closed for Christmas week. I have always liked Marcos so this was a good back up plan. Pizzas were exactly what was ordered, that is a rarity for chain pizza joints, 5 stars for service! Will have marcos again“

“Very friendly staff and the local folks we met there were so welcoming and hilarious! The drinks were very good and the beer was cold. Will make this place a go to place everytime we are here!!“

“Had dinner and drinks on Thankgiving eve. The restaurant and bar were packed. Our appetizers and meals were great. The portions huge! We sat at a table on the bar side. Our waiter, Steven was exceptional. This young man enjoys what he's doing and it shows. Thanks for a great meal and experience.“

“THE FOOD IS DELICIOUS. MY FAMILY, AND FREINDS WAS IN THE AREA AND WANTED SOMETHING WHOLESOME AND GOOD AND THIS IS ONE OF THOSE PLACES WE THOUGHT WE WOULD TRY AND LOVED IT TOO DEATH, SO GOOD TALKED THEM TO DEATH GOTTA COME BACK FOR MORE ONCE AGAIN“