50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Garden City

“While visiting from out of town, we decided to try this Marco’s Pizza for the first time, and it was a fantastic choice! The pizza was delicious, with great flavor and fresh ingredients that made it truly enjoyable. The service was friendly and quick, making us feel welcome even though we were new to the area. We also appreciated the cleanliness of the restaurant, which added to the overall positive experience. If we find ourselves nearby again, we’ll definitely be back!“

“Our hotel recommended Toffino's when I ask for a good pizza and we were not disappointed! And when we saw the fresh pastries my wife was sold! I have been making canollies for her at home because there is no place close to us and now I have to step up my game. The food was excellent, the atmosphere was very nice and the service was top notch! You won't be disappointed with anything!“

“I loved the food, i had the habibis sampler. Everything was delicious!“

“Delicious, so flavorful, we had the taco pizza and the pastor pizza and they were amazing! We will be back“

“Great drinking atmosphere“

“Great food and great service!“

“I have my doubts when you see an "authentic" NY pizza spot anywhere but downstate NY but they nailed it!“

“I love this place and have been getting for over 20 years now. The sauce is amazing and garlicky. However my absolute favorite WAS the hot Italian combo, warm meat and cheese with cold salad on it. However , today I couldn't eat it..my dogs did. The salad is no longer cold..is warmer than the meat and cheese and super soggy.I'll never order it again!
I love the place, but im upset today“

“Great pasta and stuffed shells! Salads are fresh too!“

“I had my first pizza from Mama Mia Pizzeria last night while visiting Myrtle Beach. It was one of the best pizzas I’d ever had! I highly recommend this restaurant, you won’t be disappointed.“

“We were told that there were no good pizzas in the Myrtle Beach area, but after doing a yelp search, we found Aromas. Their pizza is New Haven style( the owner is from CT). We had a large pie with pepperoni, crumbled sausage and mushrooms, and it didn’t disappoint. It was our first pizza in Myrtle Beach , and we will definitely return.“

“Best pizza in Myrtle beach! We absolutely love your food choices and menu. Highly recommended! Great delivery with out all the fees!“

“Always awesome! Love the Panzos.“

“13/10 delicious pizza and friendly staff“

“My wife and I had our first experience at Gios this week for our anniversary. Laurie was our server and was phenomenal. I had the Veal Mediterranean and my wife enjoyed the Chicken Alfredo. We enjoyed the charcuterie board and the escargot for appetizers and finished with the Tiramisu. Everything was fantastic! We will be back!“

“We came in to get out of the rain. Best decision. The bartender Jeff was amazing. He was attentive and kept a lively conversation. We definitely would recommend.“

“There was a VW bus inside. I would go again just to sit inside the bus.“

“Our little family stopped in today and had such an amazingly warm and inviting waitress everrr!!!! Her name was Lake!! She said call her Ocean if you can’t remember Lake bc it’s still a body of water but just don’t call her anything else lol! :) she was just super sweet about our toddler maybe being sort of loud so we asked for a seat away from the rest so it’s not so disruptive and she just assured us that we don’t have to worry about that or feeling bad about having a toddler. And to enjoy ourselves. It was just truly a greatly pleasure to be waited on by someone like herself so polite and understanding and VERY KIND!!! She needs a bonus! We left her a nice tip :) and we will be back to for pizza as well bc everything was super hot and good! But for the most part we will be back for the awesome service of miss Lake! You are the bomb girly! God bless you:) again great pizza and great service!“

“Omg, this was so good! I went months ago and just spent 20mins looking for it on google maps. For whatever reason it does not appear in search when you search “pizza.” But it did on apple maps 😊 Im excited to order from here next time“

“Great view, great service and great food.“

“Carolina Forest location. Ate there last Saturday night. Second day they were open. Staff and food were both incredible!!! Will definitely will be back.“

“Food is so yummy!! True Italian hard to find but it’s right here at r-way. Thank you!“

“Always get the my style pizza and the Sicilian deep dish both well done and they are great… we always get extra sauce and well done , we love it“

“Just moved to Myrtle Beach 2 days ago from upstate NY,, this was by far the best pizza I have ever had. Ordered a large pie with meatball ricotta, and this pizza was quite large, super thin crust, and tasted amazing. The price for the pizza was only 20 dollars,, very good deal in my book. Roma pizzaria is my go to pizza joint, and I highly recommend them“

“We've ordered here a couple times everything on their menu is great. only complaint would be phone etiquette. whomever takes your orders is very rude. Sorry not good business practice!“

“Everything we had today was excellent. We were impressed with the amount of items available on the menu along with unique items like the Asian BBQ Nachos. The crispy wonton that is under the nachos made the dish wonderful. The staff that helped us were very friendly and helpful with suggestions. We will definitely be back. 🙂“

“The Fettuccine Alfredo was amazing!“

“Great food, friendly service and comfortable atmosphere. The best place in SC for pizza per my autistic son. Thank you!“

“We stumbled upon Fox’s Pizza Den while searching Google for pizza near us. It’s located beside a Speedway gas station, but don’t let that scare you away. We had just returned from Brookgreen Gardens on New Year’s Eve and didn’t realize they were closing soon. Even so, they kindly let us place our order and sit down to eat.

My family ordered wings and pizza, and everything came out incredibly fast. The wings were cooked perfectly and sauced just right—I took the recommendation from the young lady at the counter and went with the Teriyaki Hot, which did not disappoint. The pizza was well made and tasted great. The XL pizza was more than enough to feed my wife, our two boys (ages 4 and 7), and me.

They easily could have turned us away since it was close to closing time, but instead they made us feel welcome and taken care of. Thank you for your hospitality and for taking such good care of my family.“

“I ordered 2 medium pizzas from this location and they were so greasy the box was breaking at the bottom. The pizzas were also not completely cooked all the way. The brookie I got was burnt as well. I called the store and the manager got all upset and yelling because I told her the food was horrible and told me to bring it back up there to get it remade or a refund. Keep in mind I paid for delivery so I didn't have to drag my two young children out in the storm. I asked for her name to speak with her manager and she hook up on me after telling me they wouldn't send any bad food out and there wasn't anyone above her in the management change. I would never order from this location again. Horrible staff Horrible food.“

“Been getting pizzas here for over 20 years and never got a bad pie. Great pizza and great service especially from Coach Dugan, he has been there just about every time that I've come by, always friendly and courteous with a smile.
Big kahuna can't go wrong“

“We have been enjoying your restaurant for many years,but last night was the first time we were disappointed. We brought a couple with us for their first time there.We had been praising everything about it but last night we ordered off the regular menu,not the early bird specials and the portions were smaller than what we had on the early bird specials! It was excellent as always,but we were still hungry when we left. We’re not huge eaters and usually have leftovers!“

“We tried out their breakfast. Their pizza was already amazing so we were excited to see them opening up early and serving breakfast. I can tell you, you won’t be disappointed! Absolutely delicious! Great service and atmosphere too. Rosaria is amazing! She talked to all of her customers and made sure everyone loved the food. Definitely not disappointed and will be back. For breakfast and lunch“

“The assistant manager that was there tonight (5/1) was the sweetest. His customer service is impeccable. He was also making sure the pizza bar stayed stocked and I could tell he really cares about the way his store is ran when he is there. You do such an amazing job and I hope this comes around back to you because thank you for your hard & dedicated work. You truly deserve the recognition. ❤️“

“The pizza is just as fabulous as I remember from 40+ years ago! Clean, plenty of seating. Friendly owner.“

“Great cheeseburgers, excellent pizza (best crust ever!). I love the mac and cheese, all the dishes where shrimp is included (cooked properly!), macaroni salad, and the chicken wings ROCK. I will continue to be a patron!“

“Best pizza I have had in a long time!!! Fresh ingredients excellent service!!“

“Absolute best pizza and salad bar around!!! We love Massey Pizza!!!!💯🍕🥗“

“We had a great experience at Christos. Food and service were excellent. The owners came out and checked on us and we had a fun and friendly conversation about all sorts of things, including about Greece and Italy. Highly recommend and we will be back“

“My husband & I came for a 'date' this afternoon--great wings & soft pretzels & beer!! Can't wait to come back!“

“Looks can be deceiving me and my girlfriend went here for some pizza and we where a little skeptical at first due to some reviews but we went ahead and got there 14 inch pepperoni pizza and it was fantastic it’s cooked in a proper pizza oven only took about 15 min from order to getting the pizza I watched them pull it and box it the crust on the pizza was perfectly crunchy on the bottom as soft on the top a excellent sauce to cheese ratio and pepperonis everywhere“

“Maybe a little light on cheese. Our regular place was closed for Christmas week. I have always liked Marcos so this was a good back up plan. Pizzas were exactly what was ordered, that is a rarity for chain pizza joints, 5 stars for service! Will have marcos again“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Oh so tasty!“

“Absolutely delicious!!!“

“We went out for the Panthers game last night.We didn't do so well in the playoffs, but in the meantime, let me give a shout-out to Gator Zone Sports Bar and Grille in Murrells Inlet for the love/support for the game, the impeccable service (owners, Angela and Eric out and about talking to everyone), and the great food. Can’t forget our bartender/server, Alana. She’s on point! We had a heck of a good time.“

“The staff is helpful and pays attention to detail in the food prep, customized orders and cleanliness of the restaurant. The food is always fresh and tastes amazing. Mod size pizza enough for 2 meals and equally fresh the next day. Highly recommend the balsamic drizzle!!“

“Excellent meal and delivery 👍🏼“

“Very friendly staff and the local folks we met there were so welcoming and hilarious! The drinks were very good and the beer was cold. Will make this place a go to place everytime we are here!!“