Brother Shucker's Bar & Grill

Salmon was good
Steak was expensive and was so so.
For some reason, the waitress wouldn't get my salad so I could eat it before my meal came out. I asked her, and she said, no, she couldn't. Because this is how it was.

Yes, yes, YES!!! Hit this place for happy hour. One dollar oysters. Does anything more need said. They have a good bar, local beer, love music, helpful and attentive service staff, and a vibe that makes a comfortable experience relevant. This is an HHI must do. Full stop.

I don't like to leave negative reviews, I normally only use these for positive reviews.
We had the worst server tonight. Briana came to our table... 4 times in 2.5 hours? Dropped off drinks but never asked if we wanted anything. One of our friends had to go to the bar because it was so bad that she had not come by in 30 minutes to take a drink order. Again, I hate to do this, but what pushed me over the edge was that 3 20-something boys came and sat behind us. She flirted with them the whole time we were there and refilled their drinks 3 times and still did not come to check on us. From one server to another, girl lock in cause that was pitiful.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Cheap eats and drinks, but the experience was pretty cheap also. Dive bar. Wine in plastic cups, poor service, oysters were tasty though!

Oyster shooters were nothing more than an oyster dropped in Bloody Mary mix and vodka. Not creativity or flavor for $9. Shrimp taco was soggy and sloppy. The oysters on the half shell were good and the happy hour price was great. I think the owner should call Bar Rescue.

Great happy hour. Best Oysters on the island.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stopped here for happy hour on a Friday and it was great! Table service was fast, server was attentive and $1 oysters were great! As Floridians we were expecting the traditional smooth smoked fish dip, and it wasn’t exactly that. It almost tasted like tuna and not smoked. But I would 100% go back again and try their other menu items. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for good service, cold beer and good food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We went to Brother Shuckers for the oyster happy hour and it did not disappoint. They accommodated our large party and food came quickly. Prices aren’t as high as many restaurants on the island and portion sizes are huge. Came back the second week for happy hour again. Will make this a regular spot when we visit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

came for happy hour, great vibes. Sal & Alex were awesome bartenders, convinced me for my first oyster shooter which ended up loving. all other food was great as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The buger was excellent could not eat it all so big. We also ordered beef bites really good.

How can you beat $1 oysters, 50€shrimp.

Always a good time. Saturday nights with Groove Town Assault is 🔥

YES ABSOLUTELY! Ask SAL AND CHRIS! These men are the best and know how to make a mean Key West cocktail. 🍹 we love them so much! Photo creds to SAL!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My friend and I came to this bar the last night of our work trip, and I wish we found it sooner! Open super late, food was delicious, Sal hooked us up with some Oyster shooters! We've never had but they were good! Live music was great and Sal and Alex were very friendly and great company while we were out, made our last night so much fun!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great place for beer, trivia, and oysters. Very bar like atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5