Benny Rappa the Italian Fisherman
$$ • Italian, Seafood, Cocktail BarAbout Benny Rappa the Italian Fisherman
Customers' Favorites
Shrimp & Scallops Sozio
Shrimp & Scallops Sozio
Chocolate Cannoli
Limoncello Cake
Seafood Lasagna
Recent Reviews
105 ratings
Share your opinion about Benny Rappa the Italian Fisherman
Benny makes yo I feel like his guest from the minute you walk into his restaurant. Come on, locals, we can't let this one slip away. Visit often and spread the word
Delicious dinner and lovely atmosphere, cozy and not noisy like most others. This was our second visit… definitely going back. And ask for Olivia and is a terrific server. Just go!
Came here to celebrate my birthday with my mom and godmom and it was our first visit after we had heard great reviews about the food.
Well not only was the food amazing but the staff and owners were superb! Staff can make or break a restaurant and they made it! They made a point to make sure my evening was special, with birthday wine glass, napkin, and desert plate ❤️ we will be coming back for sure!
Well not only was the food amazing but the staff and owners were superb! Staff can make or break a restaurant and they made it! They made a point to make sure my evening was special, with birthday wine glass, napkin, and desert plate ❤️ we will be coming back for sure!
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4:30 - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 4:30 - 10PM |
| Thursday | 4:30 - 10PM |
| Friday | 4:30 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 4:30 - 10PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Benny Rappa the Italian Fisherman offers an enchanting atmosphere with warm welcomes from the servers, creating a friendly environment right from the moment guests enter. The restaurant is known for its delicious seafood lasagna and swordfish dishes, which are culinary art, served hot and fresh. Benny and his wife are great hosts who make sure that special celebrations, like birthdays, are truly memorable. The staff, including Michele, provides first-rate service, making every dining experience terrific. The beautifully decorated restaurant has attention to detail, featuring lighted menus and checks. Although parking may be limited, the restaurant's charm and the awesome Caesar salad keep guests eager to return for more delightful experiences. Locals are encouraged to visit often and share the word about this gem in Cherry Grove, as it has quickly become a favorite dining spot for many.