10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Seneca

“My fiance and I stopped in last night for a quick bite and a little country music bingo. We ended up leaving having one of the most fun nights I can remember. The atmosphere is so friendly and welcoming, from the staff to the customers. We were only expecting to stay an hour but ended up staying most of the night. yall treated and made us feel like we'd been coming there forever. im sad we're leaving for our next contract but if we ever come through this area again, we will absolutely be back- i just wish we'd found yall sooner! Thank you for the yummy food, the wonderful southern hospitality, the endless laughs and amazing little memory we got to make on one of our last nights here!!! Tyler, I wish you and your crew much success, you have a great little spot and amazing people there!!! ❤️👌“

“Haley is such an attentive bartender and always makes an effort to connect with everyone who walks in. She remembers names, makes people feel welcome, and creates a friendly atmosphere that really stands out. Even for someone like me who doesn’t usually interact much, her warmth and consistency are noticeable. The food is always great too, so it’s easy to keep coming back.“

“I have eaten here many times since 1998 when they were in the old location. The first time we tried the place we were here looking for a lake house to buy and the entire family voted to come back the next night... and the following night. Three meals in three days. Over the years we have gotten to know many of the wait staff and have never had a disappointing meal. We have carried as many as 10 friends over at one time and have always been treated like family. Most of the time it's just the two of us, or maybe us with one couple. Frank I(the owner) s a real live character who we have watched go from a young black haired guy to a grey haired gentleman. We have seen his kids take responsibility and provide excellent service fitting the real NY Italian tradition that Frank brought here from the Empire State. The food is as good as any Italian you will experience. The sauces are fresh, the breads are fresh, the ingredients for every dish are top level... They make their all their sauces, etc fresh in the morning. The only thing they do not make is the pasta, and that's pretty easy to pick up... and a pain to make, so no problem. Expect a bit of a wait if you don't have reservations. There is some seating up front and you will likely have a lot of company to engage with. The place is popular... very popular. They have great desserts too. Obviously made with attention to detail. I love their Tiramisu and think is is the best I have had, period. The menu changes over time, so it's difficult to say what is the best dish. They had a Sicilian Trio of three pasta dishes for a while. If it ever pops up on the menu again, try it. The bar is a fun place to sit and eat if you prefer to eat rather than waiting for a table. They make great drinks, and they have a good wince list. If you see Frank, invite him over for a drink and he will join you if he's not too busy. I used to have a count of how many times we have eaten there... at about 150 I quit counting. Definitely this is the single most popular place on our list. Frank once told me to come by sometime and he would open a nice bottle of wine with me and my wife. We haven't caught him on a quiet night yet, but I'm certain he was serious. I can't say enough nice things about the place. It's great food, super service, casual atmosphere... A perfect "go to" restaurant that is good enough for special occasions and casual enough for an impromptu dinner after a day on the lake. Yes, we did build a lake house as a second home in 1999. After retiring in 2014, we build a second Lake place selling the first place and our home in Atlanta. So now we can eat at Paesano's on a weekday...“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“I went here after a stressful day. Abby was at the register and she could just tell. Within minutes of her positive, kind, and empathetic demeanor, she surpassed customer service and went into the kind of humanity that heals and uplifts others. She is a truly bright light and I will be back because of her.“

“Josh the delivery guy, was very polite and positive. just saying that it's the delivery people like this that's appreciated.“

“We ordered a pizza tonight and when we pulled up and was informed our pizza had fell so they was making another. The man who told us name was Bryan and let me tell you if he isn't a manager he should be because he first offered us a drink since we had to wait then when he saw our children he gave them cookies. He kept saying how sorry he was. But honestly his custmer service was so good that it didn't matter that they had dropped the pizza, its just good to know that he cared that much about customer satisfaction! Thank you Bryan and little Caesars!!!!“

“It does have good pizza and, most of the time, good service, but yesterday was a disaster. My great niece ordered it, and it was ready at 5PM, but it was not what she ordered. So they remade it, and it was the same exact thing they gave me the first time. So they had to remake it again, and this time they burned it. So they remade it again, and they got mine right, but they goofed up on my great nieces, but I took it anyway because I had no idea what she had ordered. I think Beavis and Butt-Head were working that day. I'll still go back to the restaurant, but if that ever happens again, I won't be going to that restaurant again, because it took 1 hour and 45 minutes to finally get my pizza, but they said they would reimburse it.“