22 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sumter

Sambino's Pizza • $
1305 Peach Orchard Road, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Limone and Spaghetti w Meat Sauce
Homemade Bread w Seasoned Olive Oil
Shrimp Scampi Baked
Fresh Baked Bread
Kids Cheese Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Seafood Alfredo
Stuffed Shells
A Greek Salad
Deluxe Pizza

“SO PLEASED THIS PLACE IS OPEN AGAIN . WENT FOR LUNCH AND WAS GREETED WITH A WELCOME SMILE . STAFF WELL GROOMED " IMPORTANT " AND VERY FRIENDLY . EVRYWHERE WAS NEAT AND CLEAN . FOOD GREAT AND WELL PRESENTED . NICE COZY PLACE TO EAT AND RELAX . THANK YOU .“

4.3 Superb210 Reviews
Tony's Pizza Pizza • $
301 North Main Street, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Large Pepperoni Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza by the Slice
Burnt Steak and Mushroom
Tony's Special Sub
Large Cheese Pizza
House Special
Slice Pizza
Extra Cheese
Roast Beef

“Great place to stop in for a quick lunch. Food is always fresh and has a great flavor. The service is prompt and polite, one time I made an order for pick up and on my way they called me back just to let me know they were out of tatzike suace on my gyro and didn't want me to be disappointed before I got there. Great people.“

4.2 Good155 Reviews
Georgio's II Famous Pizza Pizza • $
344 Pinewood Rd, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Hamburger Pizza
Pizza Missing the Extra Sauce
Medium Cheese Pizza
Geogios Special Sub
Small Bread Basket
Georgio's Special
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Combo Spaghetti

“We have lived in Sumter for a while but had never stopped in here before. We stopped at the Dollar General next door and noticed it on the way out and decided to give it a try. First off, ley me say how rare it is to find a waitress who really seems to want to make sure you're taken care of, but also be friendly, personable, talkative, and kind. We had the pleasure of having Melissa as a waitress and she honestly deserves a raise! We loved her so much! She is single handedly the reason we will be back! It beautiful to see a friendly face and be welcomed so warmly! Best experience in town! She made us laugh and made sure we were taken care of! I got the Gyro dinner and my son got a Gyro pizza and both were amazing! Portions are great, and tastes delicious! The garlic bread with cheese is wonderful appetizer as well! We will be back for sure! Comfy booths too!“

4.1 Good197 Reviews
Tony's Place Fast Food • $
1870 US-15, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Steak & Cheese Sub with Fries
Tony's Special Sub
Tony's Big Burger
Chicken and Fries
Pepper Steak Sub
Mushroom Steak
House Special
French Fries
Chef Salad
blt Sub

“I have had their food about 6 times now. I love their subs and pizza. I have asked for items that turned out not to be on the menu and they added it to my pizza. The lady who takes my order is polite and always gets the order correct. I didn't rate the atmosphere as I have never dined in. I am always picking up food for my family“

4.3 Superb140 Reviews
DeMara's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
2070 Peach Orchard Road, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers Pizza with Extra Cheese
Meat Lovers Extra Cheese Pizza
Salad Dressing Extra Cost More
Garlic Bread and Summer Salad
Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Carbonara
Chicken Parmesan
Bacon Delights
Amici Cabonara
Cheese Cake

“Always great food and service“

4.2 Good215 Reviews
Chuck E. Cheese Pizza • $$
1121 Broad Street, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Large Build Your Own
Chuck E Cheese Meal
Small Dippin Dots
Pepperoni Pizza
App Sampler

“It’s ok. A bit small. Good games. Went late so didn’t expect too many people. One person behind counter so we waited about 12 mins to pay because others were selecting rewards. Otherwise pretty clean for an older spot. Trampoline part was closed an hr before closing and it’s 10$ more to use.“

3.9 Good162 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
4210 US-15, Sumter

“First time guest. Nothing but good things to say. Friendly, fast service. Top quality toppings. My new favorite pizza place, bar none! Two thumbs up! Five out of five stars. Love it, and will be coming back for more!“

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
493 East Liberty Street, Sumter

“First time guest. Nothing but good things to say. Friendly, fast service. Top quality toppings. My new favorite pizza place, bar none! Two thumbs up! Five out of five stars. Love it, and will be coming back for more!“

5 Superb10 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
3660 Pinewood Road, Sumter

“First time guest. Nothing but good things to say. Friendly, fast service. Top quality toppings. My new favorite pizza place, bar none! Two thumbs up! Five out of five stars. Love it, and will be coming back for more!“

4.7 Superb7 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
1175 Loring Mill Rd, Sumter

“First time guest. Nothing but good things to say. Friendly, fast service. Top quality toppings. My new favorite pizza place, bar none! Two thumbs up! Five out of five stars. Love it, and will be coming back for more!“

5 Superb6 Reviews
Sambino's European Bistro Bistros • $
1104 Alice Drive, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Rolls Bathe in Butter and Garlic
Greek Salad with Chicken
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Mozzarella Sticks
Fettucini Alfredo
Personal Pizza 10
Blackened Salmon
Chicken Parmesan

“Great food and service. Also has Karaoke on Mondays.“

4.1 Good237 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza •
230 Old Manning Road, Sumter

“First time guest. Nothing but good things to say. Friendly, fast service. Top quality toppings. My new favorite pizza place, bar none! Two thumbs up! Five out of five stars. Love it, and will be coming back for more!“

5 Superb4 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
2041 Thomas Sumter Hwy, Sumter

“First time guest. Nothing but good things to say. Friendly, fast service. Top quality toppings. My new favorite pizza place, bar none! Two thumbs up! Five out of five stars. Love it, and will be coming back for more!“

5 Superb4 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
294 S Pike West, Sumter

“First time guest. Nothing but good things to say. Friendly, fast service. Top quality toppings. My new favorite pizza place, bar none! Two thumbs up! Five out of five stars. Love it, and will be coming back for more!“

5 Superb4 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
3290 Broad Street, Sumter
4.8 Superb4 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
1268 Peach Orchard Road, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Oven-Baked Chicken Alfredo Pasta
My Hut Box Entree \u0026 Side
Triple Chocolate Brownie
Breaded Boneless Wings
Pepperoni Lovers Pizza
Hawaiian Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Super Supreme Pizza
Cinnabon Mini Rolls
Personal Pan Pizza

“Went here today and I ordered a large pepperoni pizza. I got there and guy handed me the box and about 10 pieces was on there. I was about to pop my lid. Until Shaun stepped in and had my pizza remade. He was amazing, his customer service skills are amazing. He make sure it was make correctly and he walked it to my car. Pizza Hut almost got one star from me but Shaun gets 5stars from me. (First picture is what I got) (second one is was was remade)“

3.7 Good168 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
1102 Broad Street, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
Fiery Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Magnifico
Classic Pepperoni
Deluxe Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Cheezybread
Meat Pizza
Wings

“I had pretty much given up on delivery pizza being any better than a good frozen pizza. Then we tried The Works pizza at Marco’s. Wow! Made me a believer again! The combination of the meats and veggies, the sauce, cheese and crust - probably the best pizza in town! The flavor! I also love the Greek salad. I get a small and have half of it for lunch the next day. Good job, Marcos!“

3.7 Good233 Reviews
Pizza Hut Express Pizza • $$
100 West College Street, Sumter

“Just wanted a dinner and a movie night at home with the kids. Always ordered online so I have no experience with anyone inside. Delivery has always been 45-55 minutes so I plan accordingly. Only complaint is every time I put in for contactless delivery, but it never happens. That’s not the end of the world. I recommend online order and delivery option.“

3.4 Good23 Reviews
Pizza Lane Pizza • $
460 Broad St, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Bacon & Cheddar Pizza with Alfredo Sauce
Pizza and Fries from the Buffet
Large Thin Crust Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
French Fries
Taco Pizza

“Restaurant is under newer ownership and has a new look inside and out. Best of the interior has been kept with facelift and new look. The atmosphere is very unique and works for both adults and kids. Best salad bar in Sumter with more to come. The buffet is good but expect it to get even better. Have not ordered off the menu...yet. A lot of good things happening here....we will be coming back.“

3.5 Good148 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $
435 North Guignard Drive, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

The Meats Pizza Takeout: Yes
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie
Sausage and Cheese
Tropical Luau Pizza
The Works Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Xtra Large Pizza
New York Pizza
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza

“I recently made a purchase at this location through the app. I wasn’t satisfied with the food. The quality wasn’t there for the price. I made a feedback statement through the app sharing my experience. Within a few hours Kim from the store reached out offering her apology and offered to make it right. I greatly appreciate papa John’s and team for caring about their customers and the product overall quality. They were prompt in responding and correcting the issue. And for that I’m grateful. I had been sick all week and I was not in a position to prepare dinner and they did not disappoint!! Thank you Papa John’s for taking care of me and my family.“

3.4 Good172 Reviews
Little Caesars Pizza Pizza • $
810 Broad Street, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

5 Dollar Pepperoni Pizza at Little Ceaser's
Extramostbestest Cheese
Pepperoni Crazy Puffs
4 Cheese Crazy Puffs
Wings and Sauce
Cheese Pizza
Breadsticks
Crazy Bread
Cookies

“My experiences here have always been great! I had the awesome lunch special and the customer service was top notch. The meal was fresh with some fabulous flavor. I definitely will be back when I’m in the area. I miss the pizza buffet, which hasn’t been there since COVID.“

3.3 Good202 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
1 Alice Drive, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Oven-Baked Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Pepperoni Lovers Pizza
Veggie Lovers Pizza
Traditional Wings
Personal Pan Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Supreme Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Breadsticks

“I called in my order, which was taken by a gentleman. When I got there, the young lady couldn't find it in the system. But she was so sweet and put my order in. I was running late getting back to work, but it was worth it because that food was so hot and fresh.“

3 Average225 Reviews

You May Also Like