Wow I cannot believe we haven’t been here before because we have been missing out!!! Everything was delicious, service was amazing, and the restaurant is beautiful/very clean. The chicken Alfredo pizza was my favorite! Next time I’ll add a few veggies to it, but I was very impressed with the chicken - super tender! This will definitely be our go to pizza place moving forward.
Debbie Philbin
My husband and I ordered take-out from this restaurant last weekend and the food was delicious. We highly recommend the Smoking Goodfella pizza and Smoked Stuffed Wings with gouda mac-n-cheese. The owners and staff are extremely nice and and axious to help with any questions and we will definitely go back and enjoy more from their menu.
ChuckTidwell
This is a great place to split a large pie with the family. The service and food is top notch. Try the Smokin' Goodfella!
Alyssa M
First time there and the service was EXCELLENT I do not remember our waitresses names, but they made sure that our cups were always full with our beverage AND made sure to keep bringing out our bottomless mimosas. 100000/10 would recommend!
Shelbycrfl
Great pizza, fried ravioli but, their wings are awful. Very bland, taste like there is no sause. Disgusting!!!
Veeta P.
We decided to order carry out instead of dining in. We placed an order of spaghetti and meatballs, stiffed wings, side salad and sausage infused bread. My husband gave his name and we waited at the bar. Two of the servers were really nice. They shorter one(didn't know her name) checked on us and asked if wanted a drink. After sitting there for 20 minutes my daughter noticed a bag in the warmer for 10 minutes so she said to her dad is that our food. He went over to inquire and the tall blonde servers says oh yeah I was about to go and check on your food. He told her that's our food in the warmer and she says you're Craig right and he was like no I'm William the name on the food. She was like oh and handed him the food with no apology or sorry for the wait. We had not utensils or napkins. My daughter enjoyed her meatballs and spaghetti, the wings were okay and the infused sausage bread was like fried salty toast. I would love to try the pizza but not sure if I want to return.
Kathy E.
No words. Just horrible food and experience. Far better places to get pizza nearby. I will say the decor is beautiful.
Marissa K.
Best pizza in Columbia area and we have tried many. Wish carryout was an option on Sundays
Rokat Ier
The outside is very unassuming, but once you enter you'll realize all is good with the world. The supreme pizza has everything and it is superb. The crust is naturally very thin but not crispy, being stone fired the bottom and edges of the crust get darkened naturally. Sauce has a pleasant subtle sweetness to it and the cheese here is special. It is advertised as mostly lactose free, free of preservatives and other additives and is easy on the tummy, which I wholely agree with.The salads are also really nice, the greens are fresh and the house ranch is creamy. I also tried the salad that is slices of smoked cheese on top of tomato slices, the cheese slices are very thick and the tomato very thin.Service was friendly, professional, and very helpful even though we had a lot of kids. They had plenty of crayons and coloring pages for us. I was particularly pleased that she offered to make us all new drinks to go.
Karen N.
My sisters and I stopped in for lunch one day and we were pleasantly surprised at how good the pizza was. I am very picky about my pizza but I highly recommend this place. It was reasonably priced and it had a diverse menu. The service was excellent. I will definitely be back.
The staff is amazing and so is the pizza. We cannot wait to go back. The waitress played with our daughter and she did not want to leave. This has become our new pizza place and am so happy we found it.
Edwin S.
Only 20inch that I can find! Got the Supreme and added five toppings for a measly two dollars each! Owners on site and a great addition to the business! I would have discussed their military service but I was to happy to find this gem! I thank them for their service and their commitment to great pizza! Sixteen year old employee restored my faith in young people! She was professional beyond belief! I would hire ten of her! PLEASE try them over and over! We need this all over the state! (Franchises)?
Tiffanie C.
I tried this place on the recommendation of a coworker who is vegan and likes this place because they have vegan options. I'm not vegan, I love all kinds of food. I enjoyed the great many options for toppings and I ended up getting a 16" Supreme Pizza, with added chopped garlic and meatballs. It was fabulous! 1) the crust is puffy on the edges, light and crispy on the bottom. The dough is the kind of dough that has so much flavor you don't mind eating the edges, you know? 2) the sauce, was a traditional fresh tomato based sauce and it not only perfectly complimented the toppings it was just enough. Even though I had a ton of ingredients on my pizza, the center point of each piece wasn't soggy at all. It takes skill to balance sauce with potentially wet ingredients so you get an awesome pie that doesn't have a soggy middle. 3) toppings! Pepperoni and Italian sausage were standard, but the meatballs were divine. I will definitely be willing to order a meatball sub from here because you can see that they make their own meatballs, these are not frozen. There is actual herbs those meatballs. The vegetables were also nice, especially the red onion. I really appreciated that they minced the red onion quite small so that you could a few bits of onion in each bite without it being a huge chunk of onion. The bell peppers were thinly sliced and overall it was just a fabulous pizza. I will definitely be coming back here again.
Carol Ann S.
The menu said that Grandma's pie was thin crust. Not so much. Some folks expect what is on the menu. This was take out, first time there. My husband ate a couple slices but I cannot tolerate gooey thick crusts. Do not trust the menu. Not to mention the cheese. Not fully melted, under the just melted cheese on top, the cheese is still in shreds underneath - not cooked enough to fully melt the cheese.
Kyle Wampler
Authentic new york style pizza. They don't try to be too fancy. Simple ingredients with an amazing taste. If you want to know what new york style pizza is all about then give this place a try. I highly recommend.
Wow I cannot believe we haven’t been here before because we have been missing out!!! Everything was delicious, service was amazing, and the restaurant is beautiful/very clean. The chicken Alfredo pizza was my favorite! Next time I’ll add a few veggies to it, but I was very impressed with the chicken - super tender! This will definitely be our go to pizza place moving forward.
My husband and I ordered take-out from this restaurant last weekend and the food was delicious. We highly recommend the Smoking Goodfella pizza and Smoked Stuffed Wings with gouda mac-n-cheese. The owners and staff are extremely nice and and axious to help with any questions and we will definitely go back and enjoy more from their menu.
This is a great place to split a large pie with the family. The service and food is top notch. Try the Smokin' Goodfella!
First time there and the service was EXCELLENT I do not remember our waitresses names, but they made sure that our cups were always full with our beverage AND made sure to keep bringing out our bottomless mimosas. 100000/10 would recommend!
Great pizza, fried ravioli but, their wings are awful. Very bland, taste like there is no sause. Disgusting!!!
We decided to order carry out instead of dining in. We placed an order of spaghetti and meatballs, stiffed wings, side salad and sausage infused bread. My husband gave his name and we waited at the bar. Two of the servers were really nice. They shorter one(didn't know her name) checked on us and asked if wanted a drink. After sitting there for 20 minutes my daughter noticed a bag in the warmer for 10 minutes so she said to her dad is that our food. He went over to inquire and the tall blonde servers says oh yeah I was about to go and check on your food. He told her that's our food in the warmer and she says you're Craig right and he was like no I'm William the name on the food. She was like oh and handed him the food with no apology or sorry for the wait. We had not utensils or napkins. My daughter enjoyed her meatballs and spaghetti, the wings were okay and the infused sausage bread was like fried salty toast. I would love to try the pizza but not sure if I want to return.
No words. Just horrible food and experience. Far better places to get pizza nearby. I will say the decor is beautiful.
Best pizza in Columbia area and we have tried many. Wish carryout was an option on Sundays
The outside is very unassuming, but once you enter you'll realize all is good with the world. The supreme pizza has everything and it is superb. The crust is naturally very thin but not crispy, being stone fired the bottom and edges of the crust get darkened naturally. Sauce has a pleasant subtle sweetness to it and the cheese here is special. It is advertised as mostly lactose free, free of preservatives and other additives and is easy on the tummy, which I wholely agree with.The salads are also really nice, the greens are fresh and the house ranch is creamy. I also tried the salad that is slices of smoked cheese on top of tomato slices, the cheese slices are very thick and the tomato very thin.Service was friendly, professional, and very helpful even though we had a lot of kids. They had plenty of crayons and coloring pages for us. I was particularly pleased that she offered to make us all new drinks to go.
My sisters and I stopped in for lunch one day and we were pleasantly surprised at how good the pizza was. I am very picky about my pizza but I highly recommend this place. It was reasonably priced and it had a diverse menu. The service was excellent. I will definitely be back.
Restaurantji Recommends
The staff is amazing and so is the pizza. We cannot wait to go back. The waitress played with our daughter and she did not want to leave. This has become our new pizza place and am so happy we found it.
Only 20inch that I can find! Got the Supreme and added five toppings for a measly two dollars each! Owners on site and a great addition to the business! I would have discussed their military service but I was to happy to find this gem! I thank them for their service and their commitment to great pizza! Sixteen year old employee restored my faith in young people! She was professional beyond belief! I would hire ten of her! PLEASE try them over and over! We need this all over the state! (Franchises)?
I tried this place on the recommendation of a coworker who is vegan and likes this place because they have vegan options. I'm not vegan, I love all kinds of food. I enjoyed the great many options for toppings and I ended up getting a 16" Supreme Pizza, with added chopped garlic and meatballs. It was fabulous! 1) the crust is puffy on the edges, light and crispy on the bottom. The dough is the kind of dough that has so much flavor you don't mind eating the edges, you know? 2) the sauce, was a traditional fresh tomato based sauce and it not only perfectly complimented the toppings it was just enough. Even though I had a ton of ingredients on my pizza, the center point of each piece wasn't soggy at all. It takes skill to balance sauce with potentially wet ingredients so you get an awesome pie that doesn't have a soggy middle. 3) toppings! Pepperoni and Italian sausage were standard, but the meatballs were divine. I will definitely be willing to order a meatball sub from here because you can see that they make their own meatballs, these are not frozen. There is actual herbs those meatballs. The vegetables were also nice, especially the red onion. I really appreciated that they minced the red onion quite small so that you could a few bits of onion in each bite without it being a huge chunk of onion. The bell peppers were thinly sliced and overall it was just a fabulous pizza. I will definitely be coming back here again.
The menu said that Grandma's pie was thin crust. Not so much. Some folks expect what is on the menu. This was take out, first time there. My husband ate a couple slices but I cannot tolerate gooey thick crusts. Do not trust the menu. Not to mention the cheese. Not fully melted, under the just melted cheese on top, the cheese is still in shreds underneath - not cooked enough to fully melt the cheese.
Authentic new york style pizza. They don't try to be too fancy. Simple ingredients with an amazing taste. If you want to know what new york style pizza is all about then give this place a try. I highly recommend.