A little back story: where we live Godfathers are mostly out of business. My husband's family introduced me to taco pizza when we were married almost 30 years ago. The Godfathers that are in business don't do justice to the original Taco Pizza. We are staying over in Souix Falls and notice there is a Godfathers Pizza and decide to order a pizza- and now it's settled if we want taco pizza we have to come to Souix Falls
Kim Rybicki
Pizza not that
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Bryan W.
Sadly my favorite Pizza Place Godfathers let me down tonight. 1 Value Deal #3A Large Original - Create your Own Pizza Extra Signature Sauce Extra Mozzarella Extra Beef Caramel Monkey Bread Mini Cheese Missing the Extra Cheese and the Extra Sauce. Not good for the most overpriced pizza in town. Things like this are starting to happen more and more with them. Not sure if I want to continue ordering from them.
Christopher Helm
Would love to give this a better rating but unfortunately I am unable to try them. I called their online listed phone number and the lady who answered told me it was the wrong number. I tried finding a different number to no avail. You can't order online, it tells you to call the store. I called back and asked for the number from the same lady as before (they share a building with the other business). She gave me a number to a different store. I called that store to try and get the correct number. They only have the number listed online. I guess Godfathers no longer wants business. Too bad, I liked Godfathers.
Chris H.
Ordered a jumbo pizza for pickup. 40 minutes later I'm there to pick it up. Manager says they are out of jumbo crust and that they were supposed to call me but "forgot". manager offers 2 large instead and says it will be another 40 minutes. 40 minutes later I come back and another manager says he was supposed to call me but forgot and they are out of jumbo crust. I said I covered that 40 minutes ago with another manager and explained that I was supposed to get two large instead. Manager 2 goes back to talk to manager 1 for five minutes and comes back to say manager 1 "forgot" to tell the kitchen to make my 2 large pizzas. So 2 managers that can't complete simple tasks like making a phone call or telling the kitchen about a change in an order are running this place. No wonder it gets worse every time I go there. You won't have to worry about me coming back. I went down the street to Pizza Hut and they had my order done correctly in under 30 minutes. If I could rate this zero stars I woils.
Kristi H
I’m sorry to say our pizza with extra cheese was not good. It was chewy and so flat that I doubted the extra cheese. The cheese bread we ordered was fresh out of the oven but I think it was cooked too long because it was dry chewy cheese. I’d really like to leave a better review. The upside was they were very friendly on the phone and in person.
Alex S
I couldn’t believe how expensive pizza was. I spend less at a nice dine in restaurant.Pizza was 2/5 stars. Cheese bread was 1/5 stars.To many better options in SF to ever order here again.
Steve D.
I'm a Godfather's fan, but this location was over-priced and under-staffed. The small (10") classic combo on original crust ($17.69) was enough for two because of all of the toppings and cheese. The mini (6") ham and pineapple pizza ($5.89) worked for my mom. They had a nice dining area with background music, a buffet bar and a soda dispenser, but the dining area and buffet bar were closed - most likely due to a staffing shortage. I only saw one employee, who was working hard to both man the counter and prepare pizzas on a somewhat busy day. This resulted in slow service at the counter. If I didn't love the pizza so much, I'd be going with two stars.
Stopped by at 6pm, was told they closed early..Why the heck would you close early on a Friday night at 6pm? Then was told sarcastically that she would be there tomorrow. Good for her, I will not cuz I wanted tonight..
Jason Karimi
Quality classics.
Jeremy C.
Hard review to make. I love their beef pizza. For my taste best in town, but they are terribly over priced. I deal with the price because of the flavor but last Friday's experience was inexcusable. I called in an order for my pizza for carry out and was told 30 minutes. When I got there the staff including the manager were rude and said my pizza wasn't ready yet; pull around and they would bring it out. So I parked out front with everyone else waiting on pizza. After waiting another 45 minutes in their parking lot (total of 75 minutes now) I went in to be told my pizza was sitting on the warmer! No apologies and more rude behavior. When I got home the pizza was cold and definitely not fresh. They lost a loyal customer and with the way they run things I can't recommend them to anyone.
Crystal R.
Delivery driver was really nice and so was the woman who took my order but that's where the good experience ended. Waited 1.5 hours for this pizza.... Currently waiting again... it's been 64 minutes since we called and requested they come get their hockey puck and replace it with a pizza we can actually eat. Crust is hard as a rock #GodfathersPizza
Gary J.
I ordered a large taco pizza online, it's the 4th of July so I felt like I'd leave a good tip for the delivery driver working hard on the holiday. I left a $20 tip. It took 30 minutes longer than expected to receive the pizza, which I get because it's a holiday and everyone is short handed these days. The driver that arrived was very rude, she rang the doorbell over and over until I opened the door, which only took about 10 seconds. I said " hey how's it going?" And she just handed me the receipt to sign. She said nothing then handed me the pizza. I said "have a good day" and she turned around and walked away and never said a word. I opened up my large taco pizza (which looks more like a medium to me) and it's half taco and half supreme or something. Wtf? I double check my order online and on the receipt and they both show large taco pizza. I was starving so I'm planning to just keep it but I call to let them know just in case someone else ordered this and is getting mine. The first time I called as soon as I said there was a problem they hung up on me. The second time the girl listened then said "oh boy let me get somebody" then put me on hold for 5 minutes. Nobody picked up so I hung up. All I know is I'll never be back. There is too much great pizza in Sioux Falls to deal with this incompetent nonsense.
Clerk was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Chicken
The manager here is a punk!
A little back story: where we live Godfathers are mostly out of business. My husband's family introduced me to taco pizza when we were married almost 30 years ago. The Godfathers that are in business don't do justice to the original Taco Pizza. We are staying over in Souix Falls and notice there is a Godfathers Pizza and decide to order a pizza- and now it's settled if we want taco pizza we have to come to Souix Falls
Pizza not that
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Sadly my favorite Pizza Place Godfathers let me down tonight. 1 Value Deal #3A Large Original - Create your Own Pizza Extra Signature Sauce Extra Mozzarella Extra Beef Caramel Monkey Bread Mini Cheese Missing the Extra Cheese and the Extra Sauce. Not good for the most overpriced pizza in town. Things like this are starting to happen more and more with them. Not sure if I want to continue ordering from them.
Would love to give this a better rating but unfortunately I am unable to try them. I called their online listed phone number and the lady who answered told me it was the wrong number. I tried finding a different number to no avail. You can't order online, it tells you to call the store. I called back and asked for the number from the same lady as before (they share a building with the other business). She gave me a number to a different store. I called that store to try and get the correct number. They only have the number listed online. I guess Godfathers no longer wants business. Too bad, I liked Godfathers.
Ordered a jumbo pizza for pickup. 40 minutes later I'm there to pick it up. Manager says they are out of jumbo crust and that they were supposed to call me but "forgot". manager offers 2 large instead and says it will be another 40 minutes. 40 minutes later I come back and another manager says he was supposed to call me but forgot and they are out of jumbo crust. I said I covered that 40 minutes ago with another manager and explained that I was supposed to get two large instead. Manager 2 goes back to talk to manager 1 for five minutes and comes back to say manager 1 "forgot" to tell the kitchen to make my 2 large pizzas. So 2 managers that can't complete simple tasks like making a phone call or telling the kitchen about a change in an order are running this place. No wonder it gets worse every time I go there. You won't have to worry about me coming back. I went down the street to Pizza Hut and they had my order done correctly in under 30 minutes. If I could rate this zero stars I woils.
I’m sorry to say our pizza with extra cheese was not good. It was chewy and so flat that I doubted the extra cheese. The cheese bread we ordered was fresh out of the oven but I think it was cooked too long because it was dry chewy cheese. I’d really like to leave a better review. The upside was they were very friendly on the phone and in person.
I couldn’t believe how expensive pizza was. I spend less at a nice dine in restaurant.Pizza was 2/5 stars. Cheese bread was 1/5 stars.To many better options in SF to ever order here again.
I'm a Godfather's fan, but this location was over-priced and under-staffed. The small (10") classic combo on original crust ($17.69) was enough for two because of all of the toppings and cheese. The mini (6") ham and pineapple pizza ($5.89) worked for my mom. They had a nice dining area with background music, a buffet bar and a soda dispenser, but the dining area and buffet bar were closed - most likely due to a staffing shortage. I only saw one employee, who was working hard to both man the counter and prepare pizzas on a somewhat busy day. This resulted in slow service at the counter. If I didn't love the pizza so much, I'd be going with two stars.
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped by at 6pm, was told they closed early..Why the heck would you close early on a Friday night at 6pm? Then was told sarcastically that she would be there tomorrow. Good for her, I will not cuz I wanted tonight..
Quality classics.
Hard review to make. I love their beef pizza. For my taste best in town, but they are terribly over priced. I deal with the price because of the flavor but last Friday's experience was inexcusable. I called in an order for my pizza for carry out and was told 30 minutes. When I got there the staff including the manager were rude and said my pizza wasn't ready yet; pull around and they would bring it out. So I parked out front with everyone else waiting on pizza. After waiting another 45 minutes in their parking lot (total of 75 minutes now) I went in to be told my pizza was sitting on the warmer! No apologies and more rude behavior. When I got home the pizza was cold and definitely not fresh. They lost a loyal customer and with the way they run things I can't recommend them to anyone.
Delivery driver was really nice and so was the woman who took my order but that's where the good experience ended. Waited 1.5 hours for this pizza.... Currently waiting again... it's been 64 minutes since we called and requested they come get their hockey puck and replace it with a pizza we can actually eat. Crust is hard as a rock #GodfathersPizza
I ordered a large taco pizza online, it's the 4th of July so I felt like I'd leave a good tip for the delivery driver working hard on the holiday. I left a $20 tip. It took 30 minutes longer than expected to receive the pizza, which I get because it's a holiday and everyone is short handed these days. The driver that arrived was very rude, she rang the doorbell over and over until I opened the door, which only took about 10 seconds. I said " hey how's it going?" And she just handed me the receipt to sign. She said nothing then handed me the pizza. I said "have a good day" and she turned around and walked away and never said a word. I opened up my large taco pizza (which looks more like a medium to me) and it's half taco and half supreme or something. Wtf? I double check my order online and on the receipt and they both show large taco pizza. I was starving so I'm planning to just keep it but I call to let them know just in case someone else ordered this and is getting mine. The first time I called as soon as I said there was a problem they hung up on me. The second time the girl listened then said "oh boy let me get somebody" then put me on hold for 5 minutes. Nobody picked up so I hung up. All I know is I'll never be back. There is too much great pizza in Sioux Falls to deal with this incompetent nonsense.