New York Pizza Company, East Ridge

Awesome New York style pizza, Dave Portnoy would be proud to have a slice from here.

I ordered the meatball sub and picked up on my break. I thought I was getting a real meatball sub.. after all the compliments I'd heard about the pizza I thought the meatball sub would be homemade large meatballs/cheesy sub. It was absolutely not to my liking. If you like those frozen tiny meatbals that come in a bag this is for you. I didn't like the spongy texture. I took one bite with the meatbals and pulled all of them out and just ate the cheese and bread. The cheese could be a MUCH greater quality. I almost got a pizza but the pics showed all the pizzas with scarce cheese and sauce poking thru all over. I almost knew when I saw the the writing on the door with markers it wasn't professional at all and did not look good need to order signs. Simple and clean is better. After all the hype people all over this area have about this place I was disappointed. Then I reread the menu and it simply says Italian meatballs. No homemade or anything like that. That says it all. Literally my fault.

Great service, and the crust was terrific.

Tasty pizza, NY style. Friendly and professional staff. Nice n clean ambiance, but looks like they might still be putting some things away from a move? Regardless, great pizza. Kiddos thought it was pretty darn good, too. 👌

The absolute best pizza I have had in Chattanooga! I’ve been to New York multiple times and this place is by far the closest thing to authentic New York pizza! Highly recommended!!

We were devastated with NYPD (closer to our home) closed but relocated & reopened with a changed recipe. Their pizza went downhill & we had no replacement in our area. Them we heard this couple from our church opened their own place. It’s very far away from us so it took us awhile to get there & now we’ve been there twice in a little over a month! We’ve got our excellent thin crunchy NY crust and perfect toppings again! If you have not been here, you have to try it. We’re hooked!

I was born and raised in NYC. This pizza is the real thing. Check it out!

I ordered the Antipasta salad and it was delicious and the pizza is phenomenal

Closest pizza to NYC's pizza in the Chattanooga and Cleveland area.

They definitely have the best NY style pizza in the Chattanooga area.

Was invited to a child's birthday party. The atmosphere was very nice. Staff very helpful and professional. And the pizza was fresh and sooo good. I ordered a 12' supreme it was enough for leftovers. I will definitely go back. Next time I'm getting the Stromboli I heard it was delicious 😋

I’ve tried every pizza place within a 30 mile radius of Chattanooga and this is by far the best pizza in the area. My family did a taste test comparing multiple other pizza, places in Chattanooga and this place won by landslide. The flavor is great. The calzones are also delicious. If you love pizza, do yourself a favor and get an order placed ASAP.

Finally able to stop in to try their pizza, live in Cleveland. I’m a bit of a pizza snob, grew up in Brooklyn, and can’t find true NY style locally. As soon as my wife and I entered the place, the smells bought back the memories of home. Met the owner, Nannette and had a great time talking with her. Ordered a pizza to go and while waiting, had to try a slice of the Sicilian pizza, it was “like butta”, crisp on the bottom and soft on the inside. Got home and had the regular pizza, with sausage, and it was amazing. 💯 will be back!

Best New York style pizza close to Cleveland, TN

This is one of best pizza places in Chattanooga. This place needs more people in it giving them business because they deserve it. They are nice people with excellent food. I want to try all their food, but we like the pepperoni pizza we end up just getting it all the time. They even offer a gold leaf pizza for the boujee people with the $$$. My only suggestion would be to fix the fountain drink situation. Ice machine needs to work properly and some of the soda syrups are off. I also think separate sweet tea and unsweet tea containers would be nice. But that is a minor issue because the food is so good.