Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Worst pie ever. Waste of money. Tried chocolate and coconut and threw them both away. I have never left a review before but this was so disappointing I had to.

The ladies always greet me with respect. And usually I am door dashing for customers when I come in there. But I gave one of your peanut butter pies, a try and OMG! It was amazing!!!

My first time trying the pies here, and I will definitely be back. I grabbed a few small pies (peanut butter cream and key lime) and a parfait and all were great, but the chocolate parfait was my favorite. If you haven't tried the pies here you need to soon.

My wife and I stopped by to check out the pie shop. We bought a small chocolate cream pie and a small coconut cream pie. We decided to eat them while sitting on the front patio. Each pie was absolutely delicious. No complaints. The store was very clean. The atmosphere was warm and friendly and the staff was very pleasant.

Picked up an assortment of pies for my workplace to celebrate Pi Day. First of all, the shop smelled amazing when I went in! The decor is cute and the cashier was very helpful and friendly. She made a suggestion that saved me money. :) I chose the pecan pie and it was easily the best pecan pie I've ever eaten. The crust is buttery and flaky. The filling was perfect. Highly recommend!

This place is so stupidly priced that u cud go to the store and buy the stuff urself and it be cheaper! They arent worth $32. This lady shud be arrested for robbing people of their hard earned money. ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING!!!!!🤮🤮🤮🤮

Great food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good food but they’ll lie to you and say the restrooms are out of order. I guess they believe their customers are dumb. Next time I’ll just go to Krispy Kreme or Dunkin’ so when you eat you can also have a restroom available.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

Everything was awesome!! Perfect end to a Thanksgiving meal! Very nice people that run the place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Dutch Apple

This store is always so clean and the staff is super friendly. I bought pies for my boyfriend here and they were all phenomenal! Caroline at the front recommended them, she was so kind!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I don’t care how good of food any place has…if the management is willing to trash good employees on false pretense, I will never give my business to them. If a business can falsely eliminate someone, and not have the respect and backbone to explain why they do what they do…their negative and coward attitude reflects their business period. I will give all my business to any and every place other then here. I wish good things on the employees, but really hope this business doesn’t last. What you sow you reap!

Wonderful little pie shop. We got three of the 4-inch pies: Peanut butter cream, coconut cream, and buttermilk pie, and split them. All of them were delicious, and tasted like the pies my mother and grandmother used to make.
I can't wait to go back and try some of the other varieties: Granny's apple, chocolate cream, and especially the I-40 (pecans, chocolate chips, and coconut), which sounds like the Kentucky Derby pie my sister makes. Well worth your time for a visit!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 4 Peanut Butter Pie

I didn’t even purchase anything from here, but the place nexts doors restroom was broken. They let us come in and use it and we’re just SO kind. I wish we had gotten food from here, too!!!

Both the key lime and Granny’s apple are my absolute favorites from here. Whenever I want a sweet treat and it’s pie, Buttermilk Sky Pie never disappoints me. The store associates are always eager to help and friendly. Y’all should check them out and try the Granny’s Apple pie ?

Parking: Parking is free and plenty of spaces are available.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Granny's Apple Pie and September's Pie of the Month Caramel Turtle, Key Lime Pie

Absolute best coconut pie I’ve ever had !