Little Nicky's New York Pizza

Finally open later hours and on the weekends again! Delicious pizza, made with fresh ingredients. Incredible pastries made with proper pastry cream. Lobster tail pastries, napoleons, tiramisu, cheesecakes, all freshly made in house, and cookies brought directly from New York bakeries. Pick some dinner and dessert up on your way home, or eat in house. Always willing to work with allergies.

Love this place everything is great

Coming from Long Island i am so happy i found this place because I missed my pizza! By far the best NY pizza in the area!

The food was absolutely amazing! Truly authentic, New York pizza with friendly staff and exceptional service! The restaurant is very quaint. I definitely recommend visiting Little Nikki‘s New York Pizza! A definite must!

I love this place! Tonight we enjoyed pepperoni garlic knots, pizza, calzone, salad, keto pizza (made special for our dieting friends), and peanut butter cup/cookie dough cheesecake. Just wow! The atmosphere made me feel like I was just off the streets in New York City. The pizza is the best NY pizza I have ever had, outside of NY. The garlic knots were soft and full of flavor, and that marinara is to die for! We also had the opportunity to meet the owners and they were both awesome people as were the staff. We will be back, and soon!

I’m a pizza snob.. my mom had a pizza joint and it was the best back in the 1980’s… but the CRUST at Little Nicky’s Pizza brings back memories and might be better than my moms.. she’s no longer here…it is chewy yet soft… no better way to describe it.. the sauce.. I swear I’d eat it with a spoon!! Not spicy, not sweet.. but perfect. They know pizza… and the DESSERTS they make in house- I said I’d never make another dessert again.. I’ll buy from them! It has taken me a long time to go but I’ll be back as often as I have a breath. Thank You for a wonderful memory and the best pizza in town❤️

LISTEN THIS IS PIZZA!!!!! The bottom crust is perfectly crisp.
Eves dropping the owners are from NY.
The desserts looked so good. I am going to come back for some soon!!
It's a hole in the wall pizza joint but the best one I've eaten at in Knoxville!!!
You can tell its family and the food is made with passion!

Little Nicky’s pizza did not disappoint!! I’m from NY and am thrilled to have found a pizza parlor that tastes like “home”! The owners are from downstate (NYC) and the food and desserts are authentic! Fantastic pizza and wonderful Owners!! You won’t be disappointed!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Slice of Pizza

You can taste the love capisce ?. The owners are a fun couple from NY, and they are bringing all the gusto.

We really enjoyed talking with them. ASPETTA! ASPETTA!, I'll get to the good stuff. Hold your horses. ?

Pizza: Thin crust NY style. Large round pie covered in quality toppings. The sauce was seasoned and no tang. Perfection.

Cannoli: Fresh made in-house. Crust was lite and flaky and the filling had orange zest. Nomz

Tiramisu: Two types American or Traditional Italian. I had the OG. It had almond extract, but wasn't overpowering. Perfectly balanced.

Pros: Owners, Pizza, Desserts

Cons: they aren't cheap. Limited seating, not open on the weekends during the summer.

Vegetarian options: Veggie Pizza, Desserts

Parking: They share the lot with other businesses.

Kid-friendliness: Pizza! Sweet stuff! LOL

But they can be expensive.

Wheelchair accessibility: No large steps, but very small eating area. So you may find it difficult to maneuver.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Pizza, Tiramisu

LOVE LOVE LOVE this place. My girlfriend is from Jersey and she took me here for the first time. She said it's the "only" pizza in Knoxville and I'm a believer,

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We tried this place today on a recommendation! This place was amazing! The pizza was delicious and the cheesecakes were awesome! We enjoyed chatting with the owners! So nice! We can’t wait to go back again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best pizza I've had in Oakridge!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

THE best pizza and the only real NY style pizza around! And the pastries?!? Amazing!!!! The cassata cake and the St. Joseph's pastries are my favorites. Don't sleep on Little Nicky's!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely some of the best pizza in Knoxville! Truly a must try!
Don’t sleep on this place, everything I’ve ever had has been fantastic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Baked Ziti, Slice of Pizza, Italian Cookies

Went in for a quick bite to eat because I travel alot for work. Was recommended to try a chicken parm sandwich. Let me tell you that it was the best lunch I had in a long time. Add the dessert and you're done for. Friendly owners and an awesome place!

Parking: Easy, park your car and head in

Kid-friendliness: They'll be in heaven looking at the dessert display

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Chicken Parmigiana Hero