Old Mill Creamery
171 Old Mill Ave #3515, Pigeon Forge
(865) 453-4301
Customers' Favorites
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Ice Cream Flavor
Cookie Monster
Chocolate Chip
Menu
Photos
+22 photos
+21 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
If you're looking for high quality ice cream as well as interesting flavors, I would definitely try this. Had oatmeal cream pie ice cream which was good, a little bit bland, could have used a little bit more oatmeal flavor. But top of the list was whiskey ribbon ice cream, their own combination. Would definitely get that one again. They do offer samples.
The ice cream is great!
I got the Oatmill Cream Pie ice cream and it was really good!
There is plenty of seating outside for your family to sit down and have a good time.
⚠️ One warning: When we went, there was only one chocolate ice cream flavor, so chocolate lovers beware.
I got the Oatmill Cream Pie ice cream and it was really good!
There is plenty of seating outside for your family to sit down and have a good time.
⚠️ One warning: When we went, there was only one chocolate ice cream flavor, so chocolate lovers beware.
We had the best experience here. It was a quick stop on a really hot day and we ended up with 3 cups of ice cream and 2 slushies. The woman behind the counter was very sweet and helpful. The ice cream was so creamy and fresh. The slushies were refreshing (lemonade was not too sweet and not too tart). Prices were very reasonable. I would recommend stopping in for a treat!
You May Also Like
The Old Mill Pottery House Café - 3341 Old Mill St
![]()
Southern, American, Bakery, Gluten-Free
Old Forge Distillery - 170 Old Mill Ave
![]()
Distilleries, Whiskey Bar, Cocktail Bar, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian