Brooklyn Pie Co.

9500 S I-35 Frontage Rd, Austin
(512) 284-7780

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mike Elmasian

Very happy with this pizza

Breeanna Pilney

pizza is huge!! our first time here so we didn’t quite know how to order, but everything was great! pizza is by the slice, but they are super big so be warned, lol. will definitely come again! :)

TYP TWO

2 slices of pepperoni and fries was $30 dollars... the pizza is not that good, my opinion. I rather go to whataburger and get two large combos for $30. These prices are crazy and I'll never eat here again. I'll take.my ass to home slice or aviator pizza.

Graham Threinen

Gave them three chances via DoorDash. Dough tasted like cardboard and was completely undercooked each time. The leftovers were thrown away. Overpriced and crap quality. Never again

Maritza Herschmann

I’ll be honest, this is one of the most disappointing pizza places in Austin. There was not enough ranch or mariara and ordering extra sauce was expensive for sauce. Also, the garlic knots were covered in some sort of butter sauce that was terrible and messy and didn’t hide the burnt bottoms of the garlic knots. Plus, no seating and poor service.

Jordan Su

This was some of the BEST pizza I’ve had in Austin. The staff were all very friendly, and the food came out quickly. So I’ll definitely recommend if you need a cheat meal, it’s so worth it.

AJ Su

Food was amazing and delicious!! Service was fast and the staff were very helpful. Would definitely come again!!

René Casiano

Overpriced, undercooked - Just meh. Pretty much only worth it if you're drinking next door.

David Lanagan

Best Pizza this side of the Mississippi.

Meridith Kulik

Mind blowing pizza

Adrian Trevino

Cold food, ordered at 6:45, just got at 8:00pm. I understand doordash takes sometime, but if your food is made and sits for more than 15 minutes, remake it. It will make your customers more happy.

Micaiah Lufcy

So I stopped in looking for some New York style pizza. That in and of itself is hard to find in texas. I ordered two slices and a coke and it was almost $18. I will say the slices were gigantic. And they were almost the size of a large pizza just 2 of them together. The pizza was all right and the service was just meh. No friendliness are personality. Just 17 something dollars and it will be out in a few minutes. Thats it no offer of napkins

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Pie

John Doee

The food is pretty good, especially the wings. Close to what you can get in NY, but it's on the pricey side.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Wings

Meryl

Food is not bad!
The one thing that can be improve is when ordering a Large salad we should have more dressing and not have to pay for them!

Nikhil Bhoj

Tasty pizza!

Loading...