Stopped here for lunch. I ordered a small pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni. It was awesome! Great flavor. I'll definitely come here again, wish there was one in Denton.
Kristen C
This used to be our favorite pizza spot. Unfortunately, There is a new owner. And sadly it has gone downhill. They have taken away all our favorite dessert pizzas (the MAIN reason we ordered from here). The staff that answers the phone is quite frankly rude and sound put out when asked questions. They no longer deliver. I'm just really bummed because this was our go to pizza place. We will not be ordering from here again. ?
Sean Burke
Discovered this place late in May '22 and immediately became my default pizza joint. Large pizzas were roughly $20.75 each, fantastic flavor and easily a 4.5+ star place.Now in July '22 and under new management same large pizzas are roughly $23.50 each (13% inflation, in only 2+ months). Pizzas look similar, but are now devoid of flavor (except for the taste of chewy and slightly burnt crust).Asked for an unbiased second opinion over dinner and reply was "bland" Staff was perfectly fine on this takeout order, zero issues there.
Stacy Flaum
No one knows what they are doing. They were out of most beers. The wine was old. We ordered an appetizer and it came after the pizza came out. They didnt have plates so we had to eat off of pizza tins which were bent and slippery and one of our kids slipped onto the floor. The pizza was raw and burnt on the bottom. When were reached out to the owners we were informed he had recently sold it and apologized for him and forwarded to the new owner. While we were sitting another customer waited that entire time for his walk in order while we listened to them re-fire 3 pizzas because they kept burning them. Not sure who the owner is but they need to show up and take over.
Petra Zamora
This glass of wine was $8.50 before tax, guys!!! My goodness! It’s the cheapest tasting wine ever. What a rip off. I have never felt cheated like this before. Don’t go and buy a bottle of wine for $6 from Kroger then come and sell a tiny portion for $9 each. I know you’re trying to make money but this is a rip off
Raquel Saldivar
I'm so sorry, I don't like leaving bad reviews but I am so surprised how much I dislike this pizza, cheese bread, and chicken wings. I found the pizza burnt in the bottom but soggy in the middle, it seem your oven may be way to hot. The sauce it's not very good, and the chicken wings were not cook and very slimy, had to put them in my air fryer to finish cooking them. Was surprised to see that their cheese bread is just a piece of bread with mozzarella cheese and, then baked, absolutely no flavor. If I wanted a piece of bread with cheese I could do that at home. Was so disappointed, was really expecting NY style pizza, this is not it.
usmcpof
Went in to order two pizzas to-go. Total was $40.01 and the cashier would not spot the penny, but rather broke my third $20 bill into $19.99 in change. I guess it all adds up. Sat for 30 minutes and watched the pizza makers do their thing. Although I applaud that they are at least employed, they’re not well trained or sanitary. Only one of the five seemed to care about doing a good job. Saw a number of pies come out with big air pockets in the dough. Midway through my 30 minute wait, the cashier came over to confirm what I had ordered….there went my hope. When all was said and done, pizza was average at best, especially considering the price. Attached are two photos. I always thought a margherita pizza had tomatoes on it and fresh mozzarella. Please note the folded pepperoni pizza. The picture was taken at the restaurant immediately after the guy handed it to me. There is no pride displayed by any employee. This place will close by summer’s end, I suspect.
Cori Ventura
To the owner of Goodfellas. Do you know your employees are cleaning the lobby an hour early and telling customers they can’t sit in the lobby a whole hour before closing because the staff will be cleaning around us? I’ve worked in fast food and fine dining and never ever were we to “close” the lobby down an hour early. We would lock the doors and clean the lobby after hours. The pizza is great and we most definitely sat down and ate our expensive delicious pizzas in the lobby bc the restaurant closes at 9 and there is not sign indicating the lobby closes at 8. Once we were done by 8:30pm we wanted to wash our hands and the bathroom door was locked. The young man taking our order was very polite about everything and no disrespect to him. Just thought this would be a teachable moment.
Myranda J.
I'm obsessed with Goodfellas. It's so nice to have a place with real ingredients used to make each pie. I ordered my usual pepperoni pizza and it was baked to perfection.
Tj A.
This afternoon was the first time I have ever eaten at GoodFella's and it was probably the best pizza I've ever had. I'll definitely be coming back. Plus the man working behind the counter was very friendly. If you're in the area, definitely go check them out.
Y'all, great pizza! We typically do take out, but have eaten there on one occasion. Pretty funny, we had no clue how large the 28 inch pizza is. It's huge!!! If you haven't tried this pizza, you should. The cauliflower crust is very good!
Latoya B.
Cauliflower pizza is amazingly delicious! It's crunchy and chewy! The wait was a bit long but worth it!
Ashley S.
One of my favorite pizza places in Texas that comes close to east coast pizza!!! I made a small personal white garlic pizza with sun dried tomatoes, spinach, grilled chicken. It is overpriced for such a small pizza but it is yummy!
Alex Perez
I was so disappointed. I would choose no stars if that were an option. We were so excited for this pizza as it looks great online. The first problem was the guy who took the order, he seemed to be under the influence. When I came to pick up the order my wife phoned in it was difficult for the guy to put the items together. He left out an entire pizza from our order. I realized this when I got him to feed the entire family the night before Easter. When I opened the other pizzas the were stale and cold. It was just terrible. I called the manager and he said he’d have to general manager call me. That was Saturday, today is Monday. I asked for something to be done and they offered me cinnamon sticks. I mean seriously????? I’d really like for a GM to call me to make this right.Alex
Troy Strass
Fantastic Pizza! Went in and enjoyed a wonderful salad, cheesy bread and a Santinno Supreme. So now when in The Colony or in Little Elm You can get amazing Pizza.
Stopped here for lunch. I ordered a small pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni. It was awesome! Great flavor. I'll definitely come here again, wish there was one in Denton.
This used to be our favorite pizza spot. Unfortunately, There is a new owner. And sadly it has gone downhill. They have taken away all our favorite dessert pizzas (the MAIN reason we ordered from here). The staff that answers the phone is quite frankly rude and sound put out when asked questions. They no longer deliver. I'm just really bummed because this was our go to pizza place. We will not be ordering from here again. ?
Discovered this place late in May '22 and immediately became my default pizza joint. Large pizzas were roughly $20.75 each, fantastic flavor and easily a 4.5+ star place.Now in July '22 and under new management same large pizzas are roughly $23.50 each (13% inflation, in only 2+ months). Pizzas look similar, but are now devoid of flavor (except for the taste of chewy and slightly burnt crust).Asked for an unbiased second opinion over dinner and reply was "bland" Staff was perfectly fine on this takeout order, zero issues there.
No one knows what they are doing. They were out of most beers. The wine was old. We ordered an appetizer and it came after the pizza came out. They didnt have plates so we had to eat off of pizza tins which were bent and slippery and one of our kids slipped onto the floor. The pizza was raw and burnt on the bottom. When were reached out to the owners we were informed he had recently sold it and apologized for him and forwarded to the new owner. While we were sitting another customer waited that entire time for his walk in order while we listened to them re-fire 3 pizzas because they kept burning them. Not sure who the owner is but they need to show up and take over.
This glass of wine was $8.50 before tax, guys!!! My goodness! It’s the cheapest tasting wine ever. What a rip off. I have never felt cheated like this before. Don’t go and buy a bottle of wine for $6 from Kroger then come and sell a tiny portion for $9 each. I know you’re trying to make money but this is a rip off
I'm so sorry, I don't like leaving bad reviews but I am so surprised how much I dislike this pizza, cheese bread, and chicken wings. I found the pizza burnt in the bottom but soggy in the middle, it seem your oven may be way to hot. The sauce it's not very good, and the chicken wings were not cook and very slimy, had to put them in my air fryer to finish cooking them. Was surprised to see that their cheese bread is just a piece of bread with mozzarella cheese and, then baked, absolutely no flavor. If I wanted a piece of bread with cheese I could do that at home. Was so disappointed, was really expecting NY style pizza, this is not it.
Went in to order two pizzas to-go. Total was $40.01 and the cashier would not spot the penny, but rather broke my third $20 bill into $19.99 in change. I guess it all adds up. Sat for 30 minutes and watched the pizza makers do their thing. Although I applaud that they are at least employed, they’re not well trained or sanitary. Only one of the five seemed to care about doing a good job. Saw a number of pies come out with big air pockets in the dough. Midway through my 30 minute wait, the cashier came over to confirm what I had ordered….there went my hope. When all was said and done, pizza was average at best, especially considering the price. Attached are two photos. I always thought a margherita pizza had tomatoes on it and fresh mozzarella. Please note the folded pepperoni pizza. The picture was taken at the restaurant immediately after the guy handed it to me. There is no pride displayed by any employee. This place will close by summer’s end, I suspect.
To the owner of Goodfellas. Do you know your employees are cleaning the lobby an hour early and telling customers they can’t sit in the lobby a whole hour before closing because the staff will be cleaning around us? I’ve worked in fast food and fine dining and never ever were we to “close” the lobby down an hour early. We would lock the doors and clean the lobby after hours. The pizza is great and we most definitely sat down and ate our expensive delicious pizzas in the lobby bc the restaurant closes at 9 and there is not sign indicating the lobby closes at 8. Once we were done by 8:30pm we wanted to wash our hands and the bathroom door was locked. The young man taking our order was very polite about everything and no disrespect to him. Just thought this would be a teachable moment.
I'm obsessed with Goodfellas. It's so nice to have a place with real ingredients used to make each pie. I ordered my usual pepperoni pizza and it was baked to perfection.
This afternoon was the first time I have ever eaten at GoodFella's and it was probably the best pizza I've ever had. I'll definitely be coming back. Plus the man working behind the counter was very friendly. If you're in the area, definitely go check them out.
Restaurantji Recommends
Y'all, great pizza! We typically do take out, but have eaten there on one occasion. Pretty funny, we had no clue how large the 28 inch pizza is. It's huge!!! If you haven't tried this pizza, you should. The cauliflower crust is very good!
Cauliflower pizza is amazingly delicious! It's crunchy and chewy! The wait was a bit long but worth it!
One of my favorite pizza places in Texas that comes close to east coast pizza!!! I made a small personal white garlic pizza with sun dried tomatoes, spinach, grilled chicken. It is overpriced for such a small pizza but it is yummy!
I was so disappointed. I would choose no stars if that were an option. We were so excited for this pizza as it looks great online. The first problem was the guy who took the order, he seemed to be under the influence. When I came to pick up the order my wife phoned in it was difficult for the guy to put the items together. He left out an entire pizza from our order. I realized this when I got him to feed the entire family the night before Easter. When I opened the other pizzas the were stale and cold. It was just terrible. I called the manager and he said he’d have to general manager call me. That was Saturday, today is Monday. I asked for something to be done and they offered me cinnamon sticks. I mean seriously????? I’d really like for a GM to call me to make this right.Alex
Fantastic Pizza! Went in and enjoyed a wonderful salad, cheesy bread and a Santinno Supreme. So now when in The Colony or in Little Elm You can get amazing Pizza.