Coming from New Jersey I had high expectations because it said New York style pizza and they actually had white pie, which is rare to find in San Antonio. Zero flavor, extremely dry, very skimpy on the ingredients. I had ordered broccoli and extra ricotta on mine which I did not receive. Basically, you could’ve eaten the box that it came in and received the same flavor. Not a fan 👎🏼 very expensive as well. The pizza and a Greek salad came to $40.
Food: 2
Kevin Bunch
Ordered 24 wings, pizza, etc. The wings had no sauce. Ranch and blue cheese were included but absolutely 0 buffalo sauce. This place is starting to go down hill. How do you box 24 wings plain?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Eduardo Perez
Best pizza in San Antonio closest to NY pizza. Gotta get the large. The texture and taste is different than a medium or small believe it or not.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Damian Wagner
Never a bad experience. Pizza is good and the dinners are great. Always friendly and fast
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Flores
This is definitely my go to for pizza restaurants. Everything is delicious. The service is tremendous and very friendly. Everyone must try this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob M
As a NYC guy this is pretty good pizza but you can get more bang for your buck at Grampies which also has great NYC pizza. This place was good on pat booker but whoever runs this place are so incredibly cheap with toppings you hardly taste them. Compare say a sausage slice against grampies and you will see what I'm saying.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Michael
Lived in NY for 13 yrs. These guys are the closest to NY pizza in SA, can’t believe some of the low star reviews. I used to go to the one on I-10, now they are even closer!
Margie Martinee
What is going on? This is the third time we go there to pick up a quick lunch they advertise a two piece salad and a drink but when you go inside, there is no pizza they tell you oh we don’t have any we could make it if you’re advertising this you should have a pie ready to heat up two slices so that your customer can take it at the time they arrive there People are picking up quick lunches. They don’t want to sit around and wait for a pizza to be made so if you’re advertising have the stuff ready so annoying the guy behind the counter. Oh no we don’t have anything I said what do you mean? Oh we have to make it with a big smile on his face. No apologies. I’m sorry but we have to make them we ran out. They can’t tell me they ran out because it’s the third time me or someone in My family goes there to pick up a quick lunch to drive back home and they have nothing in Place. management needs to know about this cause I love this pizza, but the service has been crappy. .
Service: 1
Juan Garza
Great pizza, great family atmosphere! My son and I come here at least twice a month!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura Beth
Delicious pizza, as close to the New York taste as you can find in Texas
I always love they're chicken Alfredo Pizza. The staff is amazing. Everybody's good. Wonderful Pizza is delicious. I just wish DoorDash could figure out how to add mushrooms. So I usually go pick it up because the store always gets it right 😉
Zamira Keating
Ordered delivery. Got the pepperoni the meats and cheese. It’s thin NY style pizza similar to what I grew up eating in NY. Not as oily as in NY- and that’s not a bad thing.
Christopher
Your counter help can admit they messed up and the cooks think they don't need to fix the food? Why did we pay?
benny beaner
pizza is good has nice little crumbs of dirt and all the earth seasoning From it being dropped on the ground and still served to customers.
Vince B
I understand y’all get busy but that’s no reason to constantly tell people that it’ll be ten minutes when in reality the pizza doesn’t get put in until you remind them. Also when we politely inform you that we’ve been waiting longer than usual, it’s probably not best to disregard customer and look behind them and say “who’s next?” I (used to) order pizza here all the time, disappointed. I’d rather eat cardboard at dominoes.
Coming from New Jersey I had high expectations because it said New York style pizza and they actually had white pie, which is rare to find in San Antonio. Zero flavor, extremely dry, very skimpy on the ingredients. I had ordered broccoli and extra ricotta on mine which I did not receive. Basically, you could’ve eaten the box that it came in and received the same flavor. Not a fan 👎🏼 very expensive as well. The pizza and a Greek salad came to $40.
Food: 2
Ordered 24 wings, pizza, etc. The wings had no sauce. Ranch and blue cheese were included but absolutely 0 buffalo sauce. This place is starting to go down hill. How do you box 24 wings plain?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
Best pizza in San Antonio closest to NY pizza. Gotta get the large. The texture and taste is different than a medium or small believe it or not.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Never a bad experience. Pizza is good and the dinners are great. Always friendly and fast
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is definitely my go to for pizza restaurants. Everything is delicious. The service is tremendous and very friendly. Everyone must try this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As a NYC guy this is pretty good pizza but you can get more bang for your buck at Grampies which also has great NYC pizza.
This place was good on pat booker but whoever runs this place are so incredibly cheap with toppings you hardly taste them.
Compare say a sausage slice against grampies and you will see what I'm saying.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Lived in NY for 13 yrs. These guys are the closest to NY pizza in SA, can’t believe some of the low star reviews. I used to go to the one on I-10, now they are even closer!
What is going on? This is the third time we go there to pick up a quick lunch they advertise a two piece salad and a drink but when you go inside, there is no pizza they tell you oh we don’t have any we could make it if you’re advertising this you should have a pie ready to heat up two slices so that your customer can take it at the time they arrive there People are picking up quick lunches. They don’t want to sit around and wait for a pizza to be made so if you’re advertising have the stuff ready so annoying the guy behind the counter. Oh no we don’t have anything I said what do you mean? Oh we have to make it with a big smile on his face. No apologies. I’m sorry but we have to make them we ran out. They can’t tell me they ran out because it’s the third time me or someone in My family goes there to pick up a quick lunch to drive back home and they have nothing in Place. management needs to know about this cause I love this pizza, but the service has been crappy. .
Service: 1
Great pizza, great family atmosphere! My son and I come here at least twice a month!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza, as close to the New York taste as you can find in Texas
Restaurantji Recommends
I always love they're chicken Alfredo Pizza. The staff is amazing. Everybody's good. Wonderful Pizza is delicious. I just wish DoorDash could figure out how to add mushrooms. So I usually go pick it up because the store always gets it right 😉
Ordered delivery. Got the pepperoni the meats and cheese. It’s thin NY style pizza similar to what I grew up eating in NY.
Not as oily as in NY- and that’s not a bad thing.
Your counter help can admit they messed up and the cooks think they don't need to fix the food? Why did we pay?
pizza is good has nice little crumbs of dirt and all the earth seasoning From it being dropped on the ground and still served to customers.
I understand y’all get busy but that’s no reason to constantly tell people that it’ll be ten minutes when in reality the pizza doesn’t get put in until you remind them. Also when we politely inform you that we’ve been waiting longer than usual, it’s probably not best to disregard customer and look behind them and say “who’s next?” I (used to) order pizza here all the time, disappointed. I’d rather eat cardboard at dominoes.
Loading...