Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Love everything I tried, service is excellent.

Amazingly delicious pies! The woman helping us was super helpful and so sweet. Definitely returning soon.

I will say, I was a bit apprehensive about spending $40 on a pie for my wife's birthday.

1. Not a huge fan of banana cream pie

2. It's a pie....

BUT, this was thee best pie I have EVER had. The whole crust is like a sugar cookie and the filling wasn't just some banana floof like pudding or something.

If you have never tried anything from Buttermilk Sky I'd HIGHLY recommend!

Maybe our expectations were too high? We bought a stack of pies in the end. Some were good & some not.
Whenever we go to a new place we tell the employee “This is our first time here” usually they are a little nicer & give us a rundown of what they offer. Not this time. The employee seemed to not care. She just said ok & stayed quiet. So we were busy looking around trying to figure out what things were. The sun really comes in & beams down on all the glass making it a little difficult to read some of the signage. I asked a few questions like what was the I-40 & what the prices were. I also asked if they offered other items. We ended up buying a stack of 4 pies to try. After we paid, I saw there were some other items for sale that we would’ve included, but the employee seemed to ring us up so quickly we didn’t get a chance to add them to the order. I was still looking at other pies while she had wrapped up the 4 & said the total. We were the only customers in there so I was surprised by rush to move us along.
The ones we bought included Nanny’s pecan which was good, but the I-40 was waaaay too sweet, couldn’t taste anything but sugar. The custard pie was over baked. There’s definitely better ones on the market. Then we had the lemon. 🍋 Nice flavor & not too sweet.

This was my first time stopping by and the pies are amazing. You can't go wrong with any flavor but the Keylime is my number-one choice 😋

I stopped by this place after eating next door at Cheba hut. Got two small pies and let me tell you the peanut butter creams is absolutely delicious! Can't wait to try the key lime!

Every single pie I have purchased has been so delicious!! Always fresh and make excellent gifts too. Lovely interior and super friendly service. Also recently tried the vanilla thumbprint cookies and they almost made me cry they were that close to perfection!

The store gives such welcoming and friendly vibes! The lady who helped us was the best!

My husband brought this chocolate pie home to cheer me up from being sick. OMG this pie is better than my grandma's pie. My eyes rolled back and I had a moment. It is very sweet but worth the diabetes. I could only eat a few bites but definitely ordering for the holidays from them!

Wonderful! Great pies and great service! I loved what I got!

I got the chocolate cream pie for a dinner party. It was unbelievable! There were only 5 of us and it was almost gone! It was so good and so unique tasting. I really thought it would just be a little after dinner sweet, instead we ALL devoured it. Highly recommend. I will be back to try different flavors. This is my new go-to for events when I need to bring something.

This place is awesome! Wonderful Pies

The pie crust alone keeps me coming back! It’s so soft and flavorful. The pie fillings on top of the pie crust is heavenly! I live 25 minutes away from this pie shop and I’m very close to becoming a regular. I always get 4 pies and it’s a struggle to make it home without ripping open the bag.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding, 4 Pie Pack

Definitely the best pecan pie I've ever had. The peanut butter pie was also out of this world! I love that they have little personal pies so you can treat yourself to a little sweet without having to eat a whole pie by yourself over a week. Great concept and execution!

Dietary restrictions: Glutenfree

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pecan Pie, Peanut Butter Pie

Excellent visit. We bought a sample of the pies and enjoyed them immensely. Would recommend - note - takeout - there is a small bench there to eat at but it is almost an afterthought.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5